While I'm sure many would applaud the announcement of a new replenishment ship for th RNZ navy I wonder how it trully fits their needs. I can't help but think an opportunity was not lost in taking a very good holistic look at how New Zealand deals with the maritime enviroment and builds up future a fleet of ships to meet this need and not just keep replacing like fleet units. Single ships of any flavour will always have a limit in availability to provide a service to government. The new tanker while impressine in size seems such an odd capability for such a small navy.If it has a duel function of stategic lift with a large capacity to transport / sustain deliver goods / vehicles and personnel over and above the ship crew then it may have some justification. But for a navy of a couple of medium sized frigates and two OPV's one has to question ,why?..... Is it more a case of being a coalition asset where NZ can show the flag and make an international contribution., well may be it has merit. Then maybe why not tie in with Australia's Cantabria class and have the benefits of a class of three in the south Pacific. Is it the price?
No I can't help think NZ would not have being better served having the functions of the current Canterbury and Endeavour reroled into a two class multirole ship providing both fleet supply and amphibious duties.
Await more details of the new ship with interest and wonder what will happen when Canterbury is retired.