I get the impression that their equipment scales may be poor - they may not have good escape suits etc.
Very early for speculation, the Argentinians weren't even confirming there was anything other than communication issues.
I would be very hesitant to read much into a sound report. with MH370 the media was chasing every sound that was reported, including the chinese picking up their own sonar equipment, and phantoms and biological noises. It still is like bigfoot sightings.
I don't know about you personally, but I don't have much faith in submarine escape systems. Apart from the fact I think its doubtful I personally would fit through the tube (at least in Collins), absolutely everything needs to go perfectly right for it to work out. And its very slow to evacuate the crew, and in most circumstances would release water into the sub, so if you have a buoyancy issue its going to make it very difficult who goes first and who is last.
Assending from that depth is not with out risk of injury as well. Best case that then gets you to the surface of the southern Atlantic ocean, in 8m seas and 70km winds. The sort of seas that just broke your submarine.
It would not be my first choice, I would be doing absolutely everything else first. At least hold out until your expected arrival or next coms, maybe send up epbir etc.
It may just be they had a coms failure and other minor damage, and due to rough seas (which took out coms) they may be submerged.
I would wait for more news. They aren't even sure what the sat coms signals were. The USN is on the case and have a rescue team in place.
Very early for speculation, the Argentinians weren't even confirming there was anything other than communication issues.
I would be very hesitant to read much into a sound report. with MH370 the media was chasing every sound that was reported, including the chinese picking up their own sonar equipment, and phantoms and biological noises. It still is like bigfoot sightings.
I don't know about you personally, but I don't have much faith in submarine escape systems. Apart from the fact I think its doubtful I personally would fit through the tube (at least in Collins), absolutely everything needs to go perfectly right for it to work out. And its very slow to evacuate the crew, and in most circumstances would release water into the sub, so if you have a buoyancy issue its going to make it very difficult who goes first and who is last.
Assending from that depth is not with out risk of injury as well. Best case that then gets you to the surface of the southern Atlantic ocean, in 8m seas and 70km winds. The sort of seas that just broke your submarine.
It would not be my first choice, I would be doing absolutely everything else first. At least hold out until your expected arrival or next coms, maybe send up epbir etc.
It may just be they had a coms failure and other minor damage, and due to rough seas (which took out coms) they may be submerged.
I would wait for more news. They aren't even sure what the sat coms signals were. The USN is on the case and have a rescue team in place.
This Subs has just finish the refit 4 years ago..and although TR 1700 is only being used by Argentine Navy..but still it 'should' make San Juan as still in viable condition..
If the condition of their lead Subs not in reliable stage..which resulted on this situation..then Argentine Navy should ceased their Submarine operation and get out frm Submarine business..
Still bit early to blame reliability due to maintenance issue as culprit..altough seems indication shown there..
I'm getting a picture of a Navy in a greater state of decay than the Russian one just post collapse of the USSR. I hope the crew are rescued but it's a hostile place they're in.
Sub escape kit at the depths they may be at will be unusable I'd say so as has been said, if they're on the bottom, they will probably elect to stick with the boat.
The media report stated that the skiper of that subs reported that electrical problem already solved, and decided to submerge again while trying back to the base.
Wondering though, if the same problem reoccured while they are submerging, frm what I read so far on submarine operational, there's emergency procedures and redundancy system for emergency resurface. Can electrical problem caused total mechanical problem that hindered emergency resurfaced procedures ?
Mine too and yep, I too feel for the crew, their families and friends.Being stuck in a sunken submarine is pretty close to my worst nightmare. If they're still alive, I feel for the crew.
Me too and I think it's tomorrow that their O2 is supposed to be exhausted. All we can do is hope and pray for a successful conclusion.However, this is all speculation. I hope the poor buggers are found safe and sound but suspect the prognosis may be grim.
Me too and I think it's tomorrow that their O2 is supposed to be exhausted. All we can do is hope and pray for a successful conclusion.
The last known contact from the sub was was shortly after 07:30 Wednesday on Nov. 15th and it is now ~04:10 Buenos Aires time (GMT-3) Nov. 22nd. I have seen reports that stated 7 days of air while submerged, and others stating 10 days.
It is hard to say since the stated sub crew complement is 37, but 44 crew were aboard. If the 7 day figure was correct, then it is likely the crew only has a few hours remaining if they have not exhausted their oxygen.
Hopefully, the sub is just having comms problems and has been able to get to at least periscope/snorkeling depth somewhere just outside of the search box, or has some other thing happen which enables the crew to be safely rescued.
A noise has been detected in the search for an Argentine submarine after the oxygen deadline for the crew ran out.
Source: AFP - SBS Wires
3 HOURS AGO UPDATED 2 HOURS AGO
Argentina's navy said Wednesday it was investigating an unusual noise detected in the South Atlantic hours after it last communicated with a missing submarine, but refused to confirm whether it indicated an explosion.
The development came as the clock was ticking down on hopes of finding alive the 44 crew members now missing for a week despite a massive search of surface and seabed, amid fears their oxygen had run out.
The ARA San Juan would have had enough oxygen for its crew to survive underwater in the South Atlantic for seven days since its last contact, according to officials. At 0730 GMT Wednesday, that time had elapsed.
Navy spokesman Enrique Balbi told reporters a "hydro-acoustic anomaly" was detected in the ocean almost three hours after the last communication with the vessel on November 15, 48 kilometres north of its last known position.
A sound detected in the hunt for a missing submarine is "consistent with a non-nuclear explosion", Argentina has said.
The ARA San Juan has been missing in the South Atlantic since the middle of November and dozens of planes and boats have been involved in search.
Some 44 people are on board and the operation has entered a "critical phase" because the crew's oxygen supply could be running low.
Navy spokesman Enrique Balbi said relatives of the crew members have been told about the development and the search will continue until the fate of the crew is known
He described the blast, which was detected around the same time that the submarine sent its last signal last week, as "abnormal, singular, short, violent" and "non-nuclear".