The Russian-Ukrainian War Thread

Feanor

Super Moderator
Staff member
You will always find naysayers or bits of informations to say that Ukrainian successes are in fact failures, that their effect is the opposite of what was expected, that the front line is collapsing...

No, the front line is not collapsing. Except in the Pokrovsk direction, Russian progress have been terribly slow and in a few spots, while most of the 1000 km front line remains unchanged. They didn't even enter Chasiv Yar, two months after reaching the outskirt of the town. They barely crossed the canal for the n-th time.

They are closing in on Toresk and Vuhledar (which was supposed to be taken 2 years ago), and of course Pokrovsk where they made their only significant advance. Anywhere else, Russian advances have been stopped.
I wouldn't be so quick to argue this. Consider how quickly Russia went from the outskirts of Pavlovka to sweeping through Prechistovka, along the road west-south-west of Ugledar. I suspect there are directions where Ukraine is stretched very thin. Depending on where Russia attacks and where Ukraine deploys their scarce reserves, we may see other locations where Ukraine loses ground quickly. Right now the entire front line from the Pokrovsk axis down to Velikaya Novoselka is in question. Depending on decision made by the two sides, and successes or failures in the field, Ukraine might face a loss of the entire southern Donetsk region over the next 6 months. This would set the stage for a Russian campaign on Slavyansk-Kramatorsk next summer. Or a Russian campaign into Dnepropetrovsk region, if they so desire. The current situation is bad for Ukraine, and has every potential for getting much worse along many other areas other then just Pokrovsk.

And this is without touching the slow but steady collapse of the Seversk salient (where Russian forces recently took Vyemka), or the Russian push towards the Oskol river which is now getting close, or the continued Russian advances in Toretsk, or the recaptured of practically the entire Rabotino salient, negating much of the painful and bloody gains Ukraine made last summer. Russia is not going to take Kharkov, Dnepropetrovsk, or Zaporozhye, any time soon. And a cross-Dnepr assault is even less likely in my opinion. But it doesn't mean the situation is rosy. It's not, and the current developments are generally all negative for Ukraine. Selidovo is bigger than Krasnogorovka, yet compare the pace of the gains there. Both took place this year, geographically both are in the same area, and in principle Selidovo is the tougher target (with the two large refuse mounds on the north-east forming, in theory, perfect natural forts).
 

KipPotapych

Well-Known Member
When I saw that video earlier today, I thought it was terrifying. I looked it up, and it seems it's not quite as horrific as it looks, if this article is correct:

Rather than staying in one place, the moving drone spreads the product of the thermite reaction along its flight path as it burns. This is not likely to cause casualties. The droplets of molten iron fall like a sprinkle of white-hot rain, but anyone in a bunker or covered trench will be safe and even in the open troops in helmets and body armor are well protected, so long as they do not make the mistake of looking up.

What the thermite rain will do though is set alight any flammable material it falls on. After a dry summer, crops and vegetation burns easily and the thermite spray leaves hundreds of thousands of tiny fires in its wake. As the video shows, some of these spread and join up to create larger conflagrations. The combined effect of smoke and flame may present more of a problem to occupying troops and force them to abandon the position.

...Though spectacular, the new weapon is unlikely to be decisive. Thermite fire will not destroy Russian positions, unless applied more intensively, but it will certainly strip away protective cover. Perhaps more importantly, the effect of Dragonfire drones on morale may be considerable, and this ultimately be Russia’s weak spot.


Link:
‘Dragonfire’: Flamethrowing Drone Burns Up Russian Positions

You guys are a much better judge of this than I. Do you think this is correct?
Glad to see you around, Captain Ironpants.

From my very basic understanding of the subject matter, the description in the article is accurate. While this may present much bigger concern for the Russians, this still falls into the same category of MLRS and air-to-air missiles on the Ukrainian sea drones. It does look menacing though, for sure. And it surely shows the potential for future development.
 

Fredled

Active Member
@Feanor I agree that the situation is very bad for Ukraine. But I disagree that the front line is collapsing or that the Russian advance is fast or that it was accelerating. From snail pace to sludge pace, it's not an acceleration. The situation is not very bad because of the speed of the Russian advance. It's very bad because Putin has not yet taken the decision to stop the war, and instead deploys even more troops to invade Ukraine. This forces the Ukrainians to deploy more troops to stop the Russians and to suffer greater losses. And nobody knows how long Ukrainians can withstand their losses without breaking suddenly.

I don't think that the battle can last indefinitely, the way it is now. One day, one of the two sides will break and the other will be able to push several hundreds of km in their direction in a matter of days. As Russians are rather advancing and Ukrainians rather retreating, the odds of an Ukrainian collapse are higher than a Russian one at the moment.
I don;t expect the slow grinding to last another year with so many losses on both sides. Things will unfold faster, IMO, either by Ukrainians regaining an advantage or the Russians keeping their.
 

Feanor

Super Moderator
Staff member
@Feanor I agree that the situation is very bad for Ukraine. But I disagree that the front line is collapsing or that the Russian advance is fast or that it was accelerating. From snail pace to sludge pace, it's not an acceleration. The situation is not very bad because of the speed of the Russian advance. It's very bad because Putin has not yet taken the decision to stop the war, and instead deploys even more troops to invade Ukraine. This forces the Ukrainians to deploy more troops to stop the Russians and to suffer greater losses. And nobody knows how long Ukrainians can withstand their losses without breaking suddenly.
Russia's offensive went at ~100 sq km a month from October to April. Now it's more like 400 sq kms per month. Within the context of hundreds of thousands of sq kms it's not much. But the trajectory is telling.

Case in point, Ukrainian forces are withdrawing from the old front line north of Krasnogorovka as Russian forces are assaulting Zhelannoe Pervoe. Russian forces are also advancing inside Selidovo, and are on the outskirts of Ukrainsk. The southern direction is developing.


I don't think that the battle can last indefinitely, the way it is now. One day, one of the two sides will break and the other will be able to push several hundreds of km in their direction in a matter of days. As Russians are rather advancing and Ukrainians rather retreating, the odds of an Ukrainian collapse are higher than a Russian one at the moment.
I don;t expect the slow grinding to last another year with so many losses on both sides. Things will unfold faster, IMO, either by Ukrainians regaining an advantage or the Russians keeping their.
That's curious. I knew there were major losses relatively speaking, and I know a collapse for one or the other side has to come eventually, but you really think it's this close? I would not have been surprised to see this be a 4 year war, since the losses numerically aren't that big compared to the populations. For Ukraine, what do you think the bottleneck is? Getting enough people into uniform? Pushing enough through the training centers?
 

hauritz

Well-Known Member
When I saw that video earlier today, I thought it was terrifying. I looked it up, and it seems it's not quite as horrific as it looks, if this article is correct:

Rather than staying in one place, the moving drone spreads the product of the thermite reaction along its flight path as it burns. This is not likely to cause casualties. The droplets of molten iron fall like a sprinkle of white-hot rain, but anyone in a bunker or covered trench will be safe and even in the open troops in helmets and body armor are well protected, so long as they do not make the mistake of looking up.

What the thermite rain will do though is set alight any flammable material it falls on. After a dry summer, crops and vegetation burns easily and the thermite spray leaves hundreds of thousands of tiny fires in its wake. As the video shows, some of these spread and join up to create larger conflagrations. The combined effect of smoke and flame may present more of a problem to occupying troops and force them to abandon the position.

...Though spectacular, the new weapon is unlikely to be decisive. Thermite fire will not destroy Russian positions, unless applied more intensively, but it will certainly strip away protective cover. Perhaps more importantly, the effect of Dragonfire drones on morale may be considerable, and this ultimately be Russia’s weak spot.


Link:
‘Dragonfire’: Flamethrowing Drone Burns Up Russian Positions

You guys are a much better judge of this than I. Do you think this is correct?
Using it on civilian targets such as crops is technically a warcrime. Incendiary weapons aren’t new. I don’t think it is game changing but I certainly think it will give soldiers hiding in tree lines or trenches something else to think about. It wouldn’t be as effective as napalm but I don’t imagine having even comparatively small amounts of molten metal poured on you would be a pleasant experience.
 

KipPotapych

Well-Known Member
Using it on civilian targets such as crops is technically a warcrime. Incendiary weapons aren’t new. I don’t think it is game changing but I certainly think it will give soldiers hiding in tree lines or trenches something else to think about. It wouldn’t be as effective as napalm but I don’t imagine having even comparatively small amounts of molten metal poured on you would be a pleasant experience.
Yes, for sure. But I think the main concern would be rather fast and well targeted elimination of any and all cover and exposure of positions, including trenches, bunkers, etc. These were most significant in defending against Ukrainian offensive last summer.
 

Fredled

Active Member
@Feanor I don;t think it's close, but it won't last like that 10 years. It's true that none of the two countries have been fully mobilizing. I think that it's because the number of soldiers is not as relevant as in prior wars. I think that it's limited, not by political decision or by the unwillingness of the population, but by the equipment available and by the training required to use this equipment.
A sniper and instructor said an interview that if you give a gun and a helmet to a newbie, he will be basically useless in combat. It takes at least 2 months and half for basic training, and they still didn't even start with advanced systems and vehicles...
__________________
About the thermite drone: It's a little bit more than reducing foliage. On the video we see a secondary explosion. If it falls on ammunitions, they may explode. If it falls on soldiers, it can cause serious burns. It won't cross a helmet, but it will cross most clothes, albeit maybe not winter ones or raincoat. It depends on the intensity.
Anyway, getting that effect from a quad or hexcopter drone is remarkable.
 

Feanor

Super Moderator
Staff member
Update.

Not I started working on this yesterday but didn't finish it. As of right now today we don't have the next batch of map updates, and things are quiet about what's going on in Selidovo, Zhelannoe Pervoe, or other areas where we would expect to see action. It's possible we've got some fog of war and things are happening even now. It's also possible they're not. Unfortunately neither side bothers to forward their internal reports to me.

Kursk front.

Ukraine has taken the villages of Malaya Loknya, Nikolaevka, Staraya Sorochina, Novaya Sorochina, Orlovka, Mar'evka and Pogrevki. Near Martynovka some ground changed hands back and forth without any significant changes.


Russia hits a Kirpi MRAP and a Kozak armored car with wire-guided drones.


Ukrainian T-64BV getting taken out, Kursk region.


Repeated FPV drone strikes on a Ukrainian tank.


Ukrainian pickup truck destroyed, occupants KIA, due to allegedly a Russian ambush.


Russia hits a Ukrainian M577s in Kursk region. I suspect it's likely these vehicles are being used as regular APCs.


A small pile of Ukrainian vehicles and infantry getting hit by Russian drones.


Kursk border area, allegedly a Ukrainian tank getting hit by a Lancet. I can't make out what gets hit, but it's a moving vehicle, and it explodes pretty spectacularly.


Ukrainian Humvee hit by an FPV drone, Kursk region, outcome unclear.


Ukrainian M113 destroyed, Kursk border area.


Russian munition drope and wire-guided drone strike on a disabled armored Humvee.


Russia hit a vehicle column in Sumy region. It appears they were grain trucks.


Russia hits the positions of some vehicles and infantry. Allegedly this is a strike on 3 HIMARS TELs however we can't really make it out. Personnel flee from the strike and are picked up by two vehicles that are labeled evacuation group in the videos. They explosions from the strike are also quite large and it's one missile per strike. There do appear to be secondary explosions. They're definitely hitting something, and we have people moving around. But see directly above... that was also "something". This is Sumy border area.


And another video very similar to the one above, allegedly a M270 MLRS. It does look like the boxy vehicle we would expect, and it's interesting that the first Iskander misses, with the second one hitting it. Note Ukraine definitely concentrated assets of this type to attack Russian pontoon bridges across the Seym. And since last fall Russia has demonstrated the ability to find and hit dynamic targets much deeper then before. So it's not inconceivable that Russia has taken this opportunity to take out a number of Ukrainian longer range missile systems. However the video just isn't good enough. If all the videos we have are accurate, Russia has done quite a number on Ukraine's M270/HIMARS fleet.


Russian strike on a Ukrainian MLRS of some sort. Allegedly a Czech Vampir.


Russia hit allegedly a Ukrainian Buk-M1 battalion in Sumy region. I can't tell what they're hitting but there appear to be secondary explosions.


Russia hit the university building in Sumy, it's unclear what they intended. They also hit an old shoe factory that was allegedly repurposed to assemble UAVs, and a machinebuilding plant of some sort.


Russian FAB-3000 strike into a forest where Ukraine was allegedly staged. Note both sides use tree cover to hide from drones and artillery.


Russian strike on Ukrainian positions near Sumy.


Russia's 810th MarBde with a BTR-82A, improvised drone cage, and log armor.


Ukrainian POWs, Kursk region.


A destroyed Ukrainian BTR-4 near Gir'yi. This is where an entire company of them was lost. The fighting has shifted westward.


A destroyed Ukrainian SBA Novator armored car.


A destroyed Ukrainian T-64BV with mine trawl, Kursk region.


Russian forces captured a knocked out MaxxPro International, with KIAs inside. Warning footage of corpses.


Two destroyed Cougar-H MRAPs, Kurks region. Note Russia also captured at least one such vehicle intact.


Ukrainian forces hauling away a BREM-1, Kursk region. Note it's unclear if this is a Ukrainian BREM-1 that got knocked out or a Russian one they captured.

 

Feanor

Super Moderator
Staff member
Kharkov front.

A Ukrainian T-64BV burns in Volchansk, allegedly after a Russian drone strike.


Ukraine hit Belgorod again, reportedly hitting residential buildings and a kindergarten with MLRS fires. Note this is two waves of strikes, not one. Ukraine also hit Shebekino.


I wanted to throw a spotlight on this video specifically. The occupants of the car apparently got notification of a Ukrainian strike, they exited the car, and immediately ran to one of the nearby concrete shelters that Russia has set up all over Belgorod. The strike lands seconds later.


Russia hit the sports palace building and a shopping center in Kharkov. There are reports from Ukrainian social media sources indicating Ukrainian military personnel were using the shopping center. Namely that Ukraine's 3rd Bde (Azov) took it over. Reportedly Russia used 3 5V55 missiles from an S-300, and 3 Iskander missiles. There are also unconfirmed reports of a machinebuilding plant getting hit.

In a separate strike Russia hit the machine hall of a power plant in Kharkov, namely the TES-2.


A Russian Grom-1 munition was used during one of the recent strikes in Kharkov.


Russian gliding bomb strikes around Kharkov.


Russian strike on the Kharkov tank factory.


Russian airstrikes in Volchansk.


Oskol front.

Russian forces have finally taken Sin'kovka. Near Peschanoe Russia's advance continues to develop in multiple directions, most notably taking a large number of positions south of it. Meanwhile Ukraine has countered attacked towards Tabaevka, near the base of the salient. Theoretically this could threaten Russia's salient in Peschanoe, but at this point it looks like Russian positions in Berestovoe, Stel'makhovka, and south of Peschanoe are all about to meet if they haven't already. Russia gained some ground near Makeevka and has captured Stel'makhovka, and where Russia has reached the Zherebets river they've expanded their area of control north and south.


Russia hits a crossing over the Oskol.


In the last update we had reports of a Russian bomb strike on the military commissariat in Kupyansk. Now we have video confirmation.


Russia taking out a Ukrainian Grad near Redkodub, Kharkov region. Note this is west of Makeevka, in eastern Kharkov region, so on the Oskol front, in point of fact on the left shore.

 

Feanor

Super Moderator
Staff member
Seversk salient.

In the north Russian forces are advancing on the hills north of Belogorovka. In the center Russian forces have taken Vyemka, but it appears Ivano-Darievka originally reported under Russian control is still in Ukrainian hands. Lastly, Russian forces have advanced in Pereezdnoe, taking approximately a third of the village.


Chasov Yar.

Russia continues to expand their area of control on the other side of the canal, and has also crossed the canal at Kalinovka. North of the town Russian forces have entered the village of Grigorievka.


Russian FAB-3000 strike inside Chasov Yar.


Russia's 80th Recon Bde in action near Chasov Yar.


Russia's truck-based depth-charge MLRS is still active near Chasov Yar.


Gorlovka-Toretsk.

Russia has gained ground inside Druzhba, meanwhile Pivnichnoe is now fully under Russian control. In Toretsk Russian forces have pushed up to the refuse mound next to the prison complex. Taking it is likely a pre-requisite for further pushes into the center from at least this direction.


Footage of the ruins on the outskirts of Toretsk/Dzerzhinsk.


Pokrovsk Axis.

On the western direction Russian forces have crossed the Zhuravka region and captured most of Grodovka, the village is now ~90% in Russian hands. Note Ukraine has at least one major defense line immediately north of there, and it's likely Russia will try to bypass it either along the rail berm like they have been or by flanking through nearby Mirolyubovka.


On the southern direction several things are happening. Russian forces are assaulting Selidovo gaining the hospital in the south of town, and the suburbs east of it, are on the outskirts of Ukrainsk, and are pushing into Zhelannoe Pervoe. In between Ukrainsk and Galitsinovka, Russia has taken Dolinovka. This three-pronged assault makes it harder for Ukraine to concentrate their defenses at one spot and based on what reports I've seen it seems Ukraine has chosen to defend Selidovo, a choice both logical and most impactful as it both blocks at least partly the route to Kurakhovo, and to Pokrovsk from the south. Meanwhile Ukrainian forces have begun falling back from the large pocket between Karlovka, Nevel'skoe, and Krasnogorovka. We don't know what line Ukrainian forces are falling back to, and Russian advances here don't seem to be the results of attacks, rather the results of a Ukrainian withdrawal.


The dynamics on the Pokrovsk axis from Aug. 1-31st.


A Ukrainian officer from the 59th Mech Bde claims they abandoned Novogrodovka because of it's bad position. It might be true that they abandoned it (Russia took it with minimal fighting), but why would they let Russia take the two refuse mounds immediately north of it? You can't tell me those are bad positions.


Russian forces raising the flag in Galitsinovka, Karlovka, and the mine complex in Novogrodovka respectively.


Russian FPV drone hits a Caesar howitzer near Tsukurino. Note the drone loses signal so we don't see the moment of impact, and we don't have BDA footage.


Ukrainian T-64BV destroyed near Selidovo.


An M1 burns somewhere near Pokrovsk.


Russia hits the Druzhba hotel in Pokrovsk.


Russian forces capture a knocked out Kirpi MRAP on the Pokrovsk axis.


Ukrainian POW on the Pokrovsk axis.


Russia hauling away an M1 and a Leo-2A6.


Ukraine is evacuating Pokrovsk. Reportedly the town now has ~30 000 people left (out of 60 000) and the evacuation is ongoing. The banks, mail service, and hospital, already shut down.


In Mirnograd Russia struck the halls of the Experimental-Mechanical plant, where Ukraine was allegedly doing vehicle repairs.

 

Feanor

Super Moderator
Staff member
Krasnogorovka-Maksimil'yanovka area.

Russian forces have pushed westward out of Krasnogorovka. Note I will likely soon combine the southern piece of the Pokrovsk axis updates with the Krasnogorovka area as they're closer related to each other at this point then the southern and western portions of the Pokrovsk salient.


Russian FPV strike on a Ukrainian position, in the basement of a house, outskirts of Krasnogorovka. I suspect we're looking at those northern suburbs.


Ugledar area.


Russian forces have raced out of Pavlovka, broken into Prechistovka and have taken either all of it or almost all of it. Most, myself included, assumed that the initial westward push out of Pavlovka, was really meant to be the start of a northward push to encircle Ugledar, and this might still happen. But the advance happened so fast, and went so far, that two more pushes like that and Russian forces would be attacking Velikaya Novoselka from the east.

Near the highway Ugledar-Konstantinovka, Russian forces have taken a series of Ukrainian positions east of Vodyanoe, and have entered the mine shaft industrial buildings north of Ugledar. Of course the real fight will likely be for the refuse mound, as it dominates the landscape. But the buildings in question are fairly sturdy structures that Russia bombed more then once.

North of Konstantinovka Russian forces have taken the rest of the summer cottages up to the road.


Russian air and artillery strikes on Ugledar.


Russian infantry dismounts under fire and enter the mine buildings north of Ugledar.


A video from the Konstantinovka-Ugledar road. We see a couple of destroyed vehicles, allegedly Ukrainian. The person filming calls it the road of death and says there's antoher 40-50 such vehicles further down the road. This makes sense in priciple, the road has been in FPV drone range for a while, and was still the MSR for Ugledar.


Allegedly Ukrainian infantry withdrawing from Prechistovka, or according to another source from neighboring Zolotaya Niva. Note we've seem similar images when Ukraine withdrew rapidly from Avdeevka, and Russia's assault on Prechistovka was fairly quick. If the latter is true, it means Russia has made another rapid westward leap in this area.


Zaporozhye front.

Russian forces continue to advance north of Rabotino. The Ukrainain salient is effectively gone.


Around the former (future at this rate?) Vremyevskiy bulge Russian forces have bitten off another piece northward.


Around Burlatskoe village Russian forces strike a Ukrainian 2S22 Bogdana howitzer.

 

Feanor

Super Moderator
Staff member
Strikes.

Russia has carried out a large combined strike on Kiev, targets include the Artem and Antonov factories. Video footage shows some inbounds being intercepted right over the city.


It seems Russia has carried out a very succesfful strike on the 179th training center in Poltava where Ukrainian ELINT and EW specialists are trained. The KIAs are at least mid double digits, with at least one Ukrainian source claiming as many as 190 KIA. The wounded are apparently over 200, with some reports saying as many as 600 casualties net. Ukraine's official tally is 51 killed and 271 wounded. There are also reports that some Swedish personnel were killed in the strike and they were training Ukrainian personnel in preparation for the arrival of those AEW planes. Reportedly the strike took place during a formation. Note Ukrainian sources claim the casualties were mostly mobilized personnel with the officer trainees having taken cover during the strike, but confirmation is of course lacking. Additionally some reports indicate one of the missiles struck a hospital facility on the grounds of this training center. Other sources claim the missiles hit the dining hall, and a administration building.


Russia hit the Grand Palace hotel in Zaporozhye, allegedly being used as a Ukrainian staging area.


Russia hit the AV Metal factory in Dnepropetrovsk and apparently another training center, though details there are scarce.


Russia struck the port of Odessa again, targets unclear.


Russia hit L'vov, we have damage to what look like residential buildings, and allegedly a rail station.


Ukrainian vehicles parked in an industrial building without a roof get hit by a Russian Iskander strike.


A recent obituary in Ukraine suggests that Russia hit a Patriot position recently, as the killed service member was a Patriot SAM operator killed in a strike. There is also evidence of a recent strike near where the 138th SAM Bde is located.


Possibly related, possibly not, we have the commander (former commander?) of Ukraine's 160th SAM Bde killed. The unit reportedly operated S-300 systems in the past.


Russia used a new jet-powered decoy target, that had to be brought down by a SAM.


An interesting video of a Ukrainian MiG-29 downing a Shahed drone with an R-73 missile.


Ukrainian drone strikes attempted to hit the Migalovo airfield near Tver'. Results are unclear.


Ukrainian drone strike hit the Konakovskaya power plant in Tver' region.


Ukraine hit an oil refinery near Moscow, causing fire, allegedly small. One of the UAVs did crash into a private residence, possibly due to being shot down by small arms.


Ukraine hit a market in Donetsk reportedly using 155mm shells. 3 civilians are reported dead and 5 wounded.

 

Feanor

Super Moderator
Staff member
Interesting bits.

Russia seems to have started using some new munitions on Ukrainian columns. It's well more powerful then an ATGM and can hit a moving target. These might be Kh-38MLs.


Russia continues to use the longer ranged D-30SN gliding bombs in Ukraine. Reportedly their range is over 100 km.


A fully kitted out Russian BMP-3M with EW station, roof cage, extra armor, and camo-netting.


Russian exotic recruitment continues, there appear to be Yemeni soldiers serving in the Russian military.


A RBU-1200 depth charge launcher on a wheeled carriage, presumably Russian.


The town of Kaluga has apparently purchased and donated a used Mi-8 helo to the war effort.


Belarus continues to mass forces on the Ukrainian border with the tactical marking B. I find their entrance into the fight unlikely, especially when Ukraine is still very capable of putting up a fight, but the scale of the buildup is larger then ever before.


Russia is opening a military academy campus in Mariupol'. The campus will be associated with the Nakhimov VMF school.


Ukraine's 154th Mech Bde with their M1117s.


Ukrainian soldiers from the 160th Mech Bde in training. The prior crop of brigades was the 150 series.


Ukraine's 61st Mech Bde with their T-72AMT.


Some rare Ukrainian M992A2 munition transport vehicles for their M109s.


A Ukrainian Strela-10 in desert camouflage. Likely a Jordanian re-export.


Ukrainian ZSU-23-4 that's been repaired and is ready for service. I think they removed the radar, suggesting it will be used for ground support roles.


Reportedly the Netherlands will hand over 28 BvS 10 Viking armored vehicles.


Reportedly 60 000 Ukrainian service members are currently undergoing training in EU countries.

 

Feanor

Super Moderator
Staff member
Allegedly Ukrainian infantry withdrawing from Prechistovka, or according to another source from neighboring Zolotaya Niva. Note we've seem similar images when Ukraine withdrew rapidly from Avdeevka, and Russia's assault on Prechistovka was fairly quick. If the latter is true, it means Russia has made another rapid westward leap in this area.

The consensus seems to be that this is the Prechistovka withdrawal. Suriyakmaps hasn't updated in a couple of days, however per Kalibrated, Zolotaya Niva has also fallen to Russia. In other words, we have 3 rapid advances in ~3 days. At this point the advances are north of Novodonetsko in the Vremyevskiy Bulge area. Moving forward I'll do a combined section in the updates for everything from Konstantinovka to Velikaya Novoselka, as it's all part of a bigger fight surrounding Ugledar, and possibly pushing on Kurakhovo from the south. What's interesting is that we haven't gotten anything on the Pokrovsk axis for a couple of days now. It's possible Russia is busy chewing through Ukraine's reserves, it's also possible they had to pause to secure the area they rapidly advanced through earlier. Lastly it's possible fog of war is hiding what's happening. However I suspect if there were any rapid movements, information would be leaking out suggesting Russia's advance has halted for one reason or another.

 

Sandhi Yudha

Well-Known Member
Update.

Russia hits a Ukrainian M577s in Kursk region. I suspect it's likely these vehicles are being used as regular APCs.
Thank you for collecting and share this all with us.
It is actually incredible that such a small UAV/kamikaze-drone can cause such a huge explosion.
 

Feanor

Super Moderator
Staff member
Thank you for collecting and share this all with us.
It is actually incredible that such a small UAV/kamikaze-drone can cause such a huge explosion.
Maybe the vehicle was being used as a munition transport? That's what the post claims. I don't think the drone made the large explosion.
 

KipPotapych

Well-Known Member
Belarus reportedly shot down a UAV over Gomel, which the Russian sources that I saw only identify as a drone that flew in from Ukraine. This is pretty obviously a Russian Shahed that wondered in from Ukraine. There were at least two reportedly crossing the Belorussian border yesterday.


It appears that Russia is probably using the Belorussian airspace to divert some drones from Ukraine before sending them back for a strike (usually on Kiev and area). I noted previously that the Ukrainian air forces report almost on the daily basis that Shaheds leave to Belarus. I believe what they don’t mention is that they usually come back. It appears that this one didn’t. This is probably the first such reported event, which doesn’t mean it is the first event though.

Kursk front.

Ukraine has taken the villages of Malaya Loknya, Nikolaevka, Staraya Sorochina, Novaya Sorochina, Orlovka, Mar'evka and Pogrevki. Near Martynovka some ground changed hands back and forth without any significant changes.
I believe they were taken days/weeks ago. I don’t think there was much progress in Kursk by any side for a while, as in there weren’t any changes to the actual frontline. I find Def Mon to be pretty solid with his maps, here is his last update from the day before yesterday that includes the villages mentioned:



What I see happening for the past couple of weeks is likely still the clarification of the actual frontline. For example, I see that some Russian sources adding a village or two to their maps now and then, while the Ukrainian sources shrinking the Ukrainian control zone. It looks like while there is plenty of active fighting going on, this has become a pretty stable front, at least for now.

An interesting article discussing the “top men” echo chamber. It is hard to believe that these people are serious:


In that regard,



I said earlier I would find the videos of the Russian fortifications in Kursk captured by Ukraine and I completely forgot about it. Today Rob Lee posted a segment of a longer video showing some of these fortifications. It’s not what I was referring to, but a pretty good example. The full video for those who do not use Twitter:


Or a short segment that Rob had posted:


Kind of shows you the difference of what Ukrainians show on their “media tours” even and what it should be like. Now only to properly man them so that they actually serve the purpose, lol. Otherwise, as the recent events had shown, you can build the best fortifications in the world and they still have very little meaning if there is no trained personnel in them, taking orders from capable officers.

Syrsky with a “bombshell” in an interview to the CNN today:

And while admitting that Ukraine was under immense pressure in the area around Pokrovsk, the strategic city that has for weeks been the epicenter of war in eastern Ukraine, Syrskyi said his troops have now managed to stall the Russian advances there.

“Over the last six days the enemy hasn’t advanced a single meter in the Pokrovsk direction. In other words, our strategy is working.” he said.



In the meantime,



And



And



This is only my assumption, but Russians are probably consolidating, while bombing the Ukrainian positions in the city. I am still not entirely sure they will actually storm Pokrovsk right away and I think there are maybe better options for their efforts as I outlined in my previous post (multiple-posts post). Who knows.

It appears that Russians have finally established a position on the western bank of the Canal and it was now confirmed by Deepstate:



There maybe a very significant military aid package announced by the US in the near future - perhaps, coinciding with Zelensky’s visit.

U.S. President Joe Biden's administration is engaged in urgent discussions with Congress to allow it to use up $6 billion in military aid for Ukraine before a Sept. 30 deadline, according to multiple sources familiar with the matter.


Something else I had in mind that I wanted to post, but who knows now…
 

Feanor

Super Moderator
Staff member
Syrsky with a “bombshell” in an interview to the CNN today:

And while admitting that Ukraine was under immense pressure in the area around Pokrovsk, the strategic city that has for weeks been the epicenter of war in eastern Ukraine, Syrskyi said his troops have now managed to stall the Russian advances there.

“Over the last six days the enemy hasn’t advanced a single meter in the Pokrovsk direction. In other words, our strategy is working.” he said.



In the meantime,



And

To be clear it's easy (and at this point accurate) to argue that the southward push out of the Pokrovsk salient isn't an advance towards Pokrovsk at all because... well it isn't. Look at the map. It's an attempt to collapse Ukrainian lines north of Krasnogorovka, an attempt almost doomed to success given the configuration of the front line and how far Ukraine has already let Russia get. Afterwards it will likely be part of an attempt to take Kurakhovo.

And



This is only my assumption, but Russians are probably consolidating, while bombing the Ukrainian positions in the city. I am still not entirely sure they will actually storm Pokrovsk right away and I think there are maybe better options for their efforts as I outlined in my previous post (multiple-posts post). Who knows.
Well this supports the initial claim above. Russia has halted advancing on Pokrovsk and is hitting the Ukrainian forces in there before trying again. As opposed to simply rolling through those forces. If your point is that Russia hasn't given up, and that the strikes on Ukrainian forces also constitute progress since the weaken the defenses, ok. But they're not gaining ground. It might also be the case that they needed time to finish sweeping Novogrodovka which fell quickly but is still a town with a dense urban center that needed to be secured.

On a side note, there have been two Ukrainian counter-attacks developing in the Donbas. One* is in Selidovo where some reports have Ukraine retaking the hospital in the south and the suburbs east of it, and another has Russian forces pushed out of Selidovo towards the refuse mound. Given the speed of Russian advances before this, it would make sense that Russia didn't really dig in. To me the big question is whether Russia will hold that large refuse mound basically inside Selidovo. If Russia holds it, Ukraine's counter-attack is going to have problems. If they lose it, they might have to pull back, reinforce, and try again in a completely separate attempt.

Earlier when you talked about 2-3 weeks to Pokrovsk I mentioned the difficulties of taking towns like Selidovo for Russia. I still stand by my original assessment. Pokrovsk by year's end would be a great success for Russia and is by no means guaranteed.

* The other is in Novgorodskoe where it appears Ukraine's forces in the phenol plant never withdrew and a successful deblockading attack has just been made, though whether the intent is to have them evacuate, or reinforce and hold the spot is unclear.
 

KipPotapych

Well-Known Member
To be clear it's easy (and at this point accurate) to argue that the southward push out of the Pokrovsk salient isn't an advance towards Pokrovsk at all because... well it isn't. Look at the map. It's an attempt to collapse Ukrainian lines north of Krasnogorovka, an attempt almost doomed to success given the configuration of the front line and how far Ukraine has already let Russia get. Afterwards it will likely be part of an attempt to take Kurakhovo.
Yes, I agree. Then further south, if it works out for them. Like I said in my “long” post, I would probably be more worried about that development than Pokrovsk at this moment.

Probably the worst thing for Ukraine now is that Russia actually has options in their push. I wonder if they can do both after consolidating, digging in, etc. I guess the first question to answer would be whether they can do one.

Well this supports the initial claim above. Russia has halted advancing on Pokrovsk and is hitting the Ukrainian forces in there before trying again. As opposed to simply rolling through those forces.
Yes, and I don't think they can keep rolling and overextending themselves. That would be Kharkiv in 2022 on a smaller scale all over again. I am sure they learned that lesson. There will be a pause with small attacks here and there in that direction, but mainly levelling Pokrovsk, unless the Ukrainian defense crumbles further and significantly. They had to take a pause after Ocheritno (or just a bit after) as well before rolling further. It would probably be a much longer pause here though, I think.

If your point is that Russia hasn't given up, and that the strikes on Ukrainian forces also constitute progress since the weaken the defenses, ok. But they're not gaining ground. It might also be the case that they needed time to finish sweeping Novogrodovka which fell quickly but is still a town with a dense urban center that needed to be secured.
My point was more in regard to Syrsky’s “logic”: our strategy is working because the Russians didn’t advance a single meter in the direction of Pokrovsk in the last six days. Surely he has a much better understanding than me (not only of the current situation, but in the wide general sense as far as the subject of warfare is concerned), but that is clearly (intentional) dishonesty on his part. He (and we) can call this continued progress made by Russia on that front “no-longer-a-Pokrovsk-direction”, but his deductive logic would still be faulty. I believe this is clear.

Of course, we can also talk about “the enemy didn’t advance a single meter in the Pokrovsk direction in the last six days”, which is also not true (and a hyperbole). Pretty sure there were advances reported by Deepstate and others in (at least) Grodivka a couple or so days ago. Perhaps, there were others as well, but I would have to look. I don’t think that matters much though.

Also, to your point, if there is no enemy advancement on land, but one of your main hubs is being erased and loses significance because the enemy (maybe) felt comfortable to stop where they did, is your strategy still working?

Regardless, I am assuming most saw through what it was and many are having a (sad) laugh about it. A coupe of examples below.

This is in regard to “our strategy is working”:

IMG_6888.jpeg

This one is self-explanatory:

IMG_6890.jpeg

On this note, since I saw the handle, Lovely Lad had a very good thread about the Ukrainian logistics at Kursk that I forgot to post earlier:


On a side note, there have been two Ukrainian counter-attacks developing in the Donbas. One* is in Selidovo where some reports have Ukraine retaking the hospital in the south and the suburbs east of it, and another has Russian forces pushed out of Selidovo towards the refuse mound. Given the speed of Russian advances before this, it would make sense that Russia didn't really dig in. To me the big question is whether Russia will hold that large refuse mound basically inside Selidovo. If Russia holds it, Ukraine's counter-attack is going to have problems. If they lose it, they might have to pull back, reinforce, and try again in a completely separate attempt.
Interesting. Thanks for the insight. Yes, I agree about the speed of their advances. Perhaps the reason for the pause a bit further north. I just don’t see this rate of advance to last anywhere at this point. It just wouldn’t make sense. If it did, the situation for Ukraine is even worse than being reported, but I don’t think this is the case.

Earlier when you talked about 2-3 weeks to Pokrovsk I mentioned the difficulties of taking towns like Selidovo for Russia. I still stand by my original assessment. Pokrovsk by year's end would be a great success for Russia and is by no means guaranteed.
I hope my comment wasn’t taken as they were going to take Pokrovsk in 2 to 3 weeks, haha. Regardless, we are probably over month away from my comment and they aren’t at Pokrovsk.

No guarantees for anything, for sure, and lots of very smart people have been wrong more often than not in the past 2.5 years. Some are still suggesting in all seriousness that this is all part of some great mastermind plan that we are yet to see coming to life. And hey, maybe a few months from now we will be talking about that very plan (kidding, of course, but there is a little joke/truth in every joke).

The other is in Novgorodskoe where it appears Ukraine's forces in the phenol plant never withdrew and a successful deblockading attack has just been made, though whether the intent is to have them evacuate, or reinforce and hold the spot is unclear.
Is Novogrodskoe New York? In other words, this

IMG_6893.jpeg

Turned into this

IMG_6892.jpeg

To me it looks more like maybe Russia never had the control of that area in the first place? It’s been less than a week since that weird encirclement was reported and now all of a sudden there was this counterattack and breakthrough, while Russians have advanced on both flanks at the same time. Too weird.
 

Feanor

Super Moderator
Staff member
Is Novogrodskoe New York? In other words, this

View attachment 51676

Turned into this

View attachment 51677

To me it looks more like maybe Russia never had the control of that area in the first place? It’s been less than a week since that weird encirclement was reported and now all of a sudden there was this counterattack and breakthrough, while Russians have advanced on both flanks at the same time. Too weird.
That's the one. Russia according to some reports didn't take the phenol plant but instead surrounded some quantity of Ukrainian forces there. Note we never got a good explanation of what that quantity was. A platoon? A btln? Now Ukraine has deblockaded the forces in question. It's not clear if this is an attempt to retake the northern parts of Novgorodskoe, or if it's an attempt to let those forces escape.
 
Top