IMO Gripen would have been a good fit if Canada had gone Superhornet.
Same engines:
- Superhornet is a great bomb truck, uses all US weapons for naval strike, twin engine etc. LRASM, AIM174, Aim260, maverick, growler variations. But also austre capability, short field capability. Deliveries would be already happening. They could have stood up a squadron by now.
- Gripen is a smaller light weight fighter, agile, smaller, euro style weapons like meteor. Also cold weather and austere capable. IMO I see it kind of in the vein of a combat capable aircraft, but with trainer running costs.
- No one can really afford large air forces these days, but ~64 SHornet + ~92 Gripen would provide Canada with numbers. It could permanently deploy a Squadron of Gripens to Europe, and support that with a flight of Superhornets. Gripens could provide a great airframe for European NATO training exercises, international integration stuff.
Two different types doesn't mean impossible. Particularly if there is commonality. The USN supports multiple airframes off a ship.
Hornet->superhornet was specifically designed to be painless. While the superhornet isn't cheap, the transition to superhornets would be fast and cheap in comparison. If global war ever broke out, Canada could literally call on all previous hornet maintainers/pilots and run them through that same program.
With the gripens, I would make them your lead-in jet trainer. With simulators etc these days, that's not an impossible jump. There is a two seat version as well.
I don't think Canada understand sovereignty cohesively. Unless you have your own entire locally developed fighter (and all its subsystems) that isn't going to happen. You can of course make yourself way more independent. With something like Superhornet or gripen, you buy more spare engines, have more airframes to cannibalise if you have to, more spare parts, try to get locally production of common use parts etc. You make alliances with fellow users that could lend spares or even entire airframes.
I think if Canada had went for the Super Hornet, it would have entirely invalidated any reasoning outside of current politics to operate the Gripen. From what I have seen, Gripen E/F's purchase and operational costs are really not that far off from every other modernized 4th generation fighter, certainly not to the point where it's comparable to a trainer. Austere, short field capability is dubiously relevant to Canada as we do not subscribe to the dispersed operational doctrine that Sweden utilizes, we physically cannot use that same strategy in the North. If anything given how many F-35 operators are present in Europe, Gripen is an integration and interoperability downgrade alongside lacking in capability for a European deployment.
Gripen is too complex and costly to justify using as a lead-in jet trainer, it would be a major misallocation of resources and a waste of an aircraft.
I'm a bit confused on why Canada would be looking at building a force to match something like Brazil. When it could be building a much more capable force, matching something like Australia.
If you are particularly worried about sovereignty and independence (although Canada actually enacting independence from US economically or in any military significant capacity, or even politically is another thing). Front line fighters are probably not the units that will offer huge independence from anyone, but a large stock of Spares and equipment has seen other countries operate US aircraft under complete sanctions for decades.
But Canadian defence budgets aren't really blowing up, despite the rhetoric.
Also with the US alliance the question isn't really are you aligned with America. Its which part of America/what kind of America are you aligned with? Which American defence services, what American defence companies may still be able to support things outside of the US because they are a very international organisation or rely on overseas sales.
This current situation is all down to ongoing political issues between Canada and the United States, there is minimal military, industrial or economic logic behind the potential of a mixed fleet of Gripen and F-35. Regardless of what happens with the US outside of open conflict, we are always going to be contributing to NORAD collective defence together. This is the primary mission of the RCAF and we need to be interoperable with the US to make this happen.
I don't think this is a decision being made based on capability or cost.
Its a decision being made to "punish" the United States for how Trump is treating them diplomatically at the moment, plus possibly a continued reaction to the whole situation with the Boeing/C Series saga which led to Bombardier having to sell the program to Airbus at a huge loss (and renaming them to the A220).
As well as Tariffs the US is also doing other thing such as blocking the opening of the Gordie Howe Bridge because apparrently the US Government wanted to own a portion of it and getting upset about not enough US Manufactured materials being used in construction. This despite the Canadian Government funding 100% of the construction cost (in the Billions) and then handing over 50% ownership to the state of Michigan at zero cost.
Nothing around this decision has anything to do with the Bombardier/Boeing slapfight, just like it had very minimal to do with the Super Hornet not being chosen for the interim or full fighter programs. These issues are long done and buried, this is all to do with current ongoing political tensions between Canada and the US.
I still think if this is the platform, then Canada still hasn't ordered enough for robust capability. It should be more like 8. Perhaps with an ELINT version as well.
Also F-35 has its weak spots. Particularly in Blk III configuration. Carrying large weapons negates it stealthy profile, its single engine, it has limited range, its hard to integrate new weapons and systems on, its not going to be a great EW platform because of stealth etc. USN/USAF Is already moving to its new platforms in development so like Blk IV may be cut short and no major upgrades past that. in high tempo global conflict there is a parts supply bottleneck on that platform.
What's Canada's armed drone program like?
Canada looks to be negotiating 6 GlobalEye AEW aircraft and rumours are circulating that they are also looking at 4-6 EA-37B Compass Call like aircraft based on the Global 6500 platform as well.
The F-35 carries a respectable armament even internally, especially once Sidekick is fielded. Even in a situation where the F-35 is carrying external weapons, it is still leagues stealthier than any 4th generation fighter available. Stealth is not a binary switch that is turned off when external stores are carried, it reduces the effectiveness to various degrees depending on the amount and munitions carried, but it doesn't negate the inherent design features of the aircraft. Modern single engine fighters have proven to be reliable and have minimal issues, Canada would not be looking at the F-35 if this was not the case. We have been involved in development of JSF since the late 1990's and engine reliability has been a key sticking point for us. F-35's range is fairly substantial on its huge internal fuel tanks, and apparently stealthy fuel tanks have been trialed by nations like Israel.
Block IV will not be cut short, nor will major updates to the aircraft somehow stop going forward. Countless partners including Canada are relying upon Block IV to keep the aircraft relevant. There are over 1,300 F-35's of various makes and models currently built and countless more planned to be built by a number of militaries. Future support and upgrades will not be dropped or going anywhere, anytime soon. Even if the USAF/USN/USMC were to cut all of their F-35 orders tomorrow, there is still enough of a fleet present to justify ongoing support and upgrades.
Not much regarding drones at this point, although there seems to be plans eventually to move forward with unmanned drone wingmen platforms.