Coincidentally I came across a reference in Norman Friedman’s “U.S. Destroyers, an Illustrated Design History” to LAMPS in which the SH-2 was described as “an elderly airframe with limited potential, even though it was thoroughly rebuilt (and re-engined) for LAMPS use.”
He was wrong about that and a good many things. Many SH-2Hs were built in the mid 1980s so hardly old. The basic design is as old as the UH-1 and that is still going strong in new forms this decade.
This was referring to the type in 1969/70 not 2007 so why we not only selected it for the RAN but decided to opt for reconditioned airframes over new build ones is beyond me.
Because there was no difference between new build or refited airframes except the cost. In fact Defence considered new build airframes at an additional cost of $32m just to counter negative public perception. So the opinion of people with no knowledge of the airworthiness of the airframes would have cost us all over $30 million.