As I understand it, the two new AOR's have been reported as scheduled for delivery in 2019 and 2020 (will that slip? Who knows), the statement by the Def Min the other day, announcing the names, said that the ships would enter service from 2020 and reach FOC in 2022.
And of course on top of that, the DWP and DIIP are suggesting a decision just prior to 2025 on if a 3rd AOR or additional Choules type ship would enter service in the late2020s!
A number of years ago, the Dutch government considered selling off the Karl Doorman just as it was being completed as a way to ease their budget problems at the time. Some here strongly recommended purchasing her as a solution to our stalled JSS project and then building 1 or 2 more here. Unfortunately for the RCN, wiser heads prevailed in the Netherlands and the Karl Doorman serves their navy and sometimes the German navy. Meanwhile, our AOR situation has only been partially addressed with Asterix and apparently 2.3 billion is not enough for SeaSpan to build two Berlin class AORs! Time for a visit to South Korea to shop around. A Tide class ship works for me.
A number of years ago, the Dutch government considered selling off the Karl Doorman just as it was being completed as a way to ease their budget problems at the time. Some here strongly recommended purchasing her as a solution to our stalled JSS project and then building 1 or 2 more here. Unfortunately for the RCN, wiser heads prevailed in the Netherlands and the Karl Doorman serves their navy and sometimes the German navy. Meanwhile, our AOR situation has only been partially addressed with Asterix and apparently 2.3 billion is not enough for SeaSpan to build two Berlin class AORs! Time for a visit to South Korea to shop around. A Tide class ship works for me.
There is a third way. The Royal Netherlands Navy has combined two ships into one. Their JSS Karel Doorman has been given quite an extensive RAS capability combining this with her amphibious function.
I think in a navy strapped for resources this is a very smart compromise and could easily work for the RAN
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/HNLMS_Karel_Doorman_(A833)
Absolutely and with that pricing Canada could get 3-4 ships. Too bad pollies feel corporate welfare is more important.
That kind of reminds me of the Canadian JSS program.Yep, and that is sort of what is alluded to in the DWP noting the cross over of functions. It certainly makes sense.
I do not understand why DoD are so low key on events like this. Barret witnessed the keeling laying of NUSHIP Supply yesterday and there was bugger all press reporting.
https://twitter.com/Australian_Navy/status/931765952106004480?s=17
There is a third way. The Royal Netherlands Navy has combined two ships into one. Their JSS Karel Doorman has been given quite an extensive RAS capability combining this with her amphibious function.
I think in a navy strapped for resources this is a very smart compromise and could easily work for the RAN
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/HNLMS_Karel_Doorman_(A833)
John, aren't there further ships of the Asterix type available for conversion? Is it planned to convert say two more ships rather than go ahead with the Berlins? This conversion seems satisfy both the RCN budget and also keeps the Shipyard in work.
Found this page which illustrates the impressive conversion results.
MV ASTERIX -Exterior Tour of RCN’s Interim AOR | Roger Litwiller
Karel Doorman is built by Damen and our new ice breaker RSV Nuyina is being built now. Time lapse of the build at the link.
Australia’s new icebreaker – RSV Nuyina — Australian Antarctic Division
Truly impressive. Congratulations RAN.
And here in Canada we wait.
There are provisions in the contract after lease that the RCN could buy her, maybe that's why your beloved PM is stalling see how she stacks up
MV Asterix -Why Not HMCS ASTERIX? | Roger Litwiller
On the question of the potential 3rd AOR for the RAN, I have often thought do we really need a 3rd 'pure' AOR in RAN service?
.
And especially with our Kiwi cousins across the ditch also acquiring their new large AOR too.
.
yes we need the third but from my perspective I believe we should have four just for the RAN, we are technically a two ocean Navy one either East or West with the third being a replacement for either when they go in for maintenance
That's NZ sovereign capacity not always available to the RAN, hence one of the reasons why we leased Cantabria
Four AORs for the RAN? That is la la land, where is the budget and manpower going to come from to own and operate 4 x AOR's?
How is the RAN going to employ 4 x AOR's? Even if the RAN ends up with three 'pure' AOR's I would imagine that we would only ever see two in operation at any one time with two crews swapping from one to the other.
And yes of course the new RNZN AOR will be a sovereign NZ capability, but I'm sure having a total of three AOR's either side of the ditch will be worked out by both our Governments for the benefit of all.
I think you missed the point of what I actually said too, I said do we really need a 3rd 'pure' AOR.