Australia should be embarrassed that they are getting Super Hornets.
A pretty badly designed plane that is well-suited for aircraft carriers.
Very perplexed as to why they'd choose an inferior plane as compared to the other planes SEA countries have. Thailand already has the Saab Gripen. Indonesia and Malaysia have the Su-30 and Singapore has the F-15SG.
Very perplexed as to why they'd choose an inferior plane as compared to the other planes SEA countries have. Thailand already has the Saab Gripen. Indonesia and Malaysia have the Su-30 and Singapore has the F-15SG.
Nah... We should have secretly converted the sunken wreck of the Yamato into a space battleship. That would have been an excellent F-111 replacement.
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-xGv6vaj378o/TWeYM5aukuI/AAAAAAAABK0/0-w-IiLhT3Y/s1600/yamato.jpg
Australia should be embarrassed that they are getting Super Hornets. A pretty badly designed plane that is well-suited for aircraft carriers. Very perplexed as to why they'd choose an inferior plane as compared to the other planes SEA countries have. Thailand already has the Saab Gripen. Indonesia and Malaysia have the Su-30 and Singapore has the F-15SG.
The radar on those Super Hornets are top-notch, but it's only a matter of time before SEA countries upgrade their capabilities. Some options the RAAF could have done:
1) Ordered Silent Eagles, while keeping the existing F-111s in service.
2) Build a better plane suited to this generation based on the F-111 design, which would jumpstart the Australian defense industry (in consortium with American companies).
3) Upgraded the existing F-111s to better standards.
4) A combination of all three.
I'm a very big proponent of Australia having a strong air power to promote stability in the Asia-Pacific region.
Good. Feel stable then because we do have a strong air power. Please feel free to show me another force in South East Asia with a force structure as broad and as capable overall as ours and to discuss why exactly these forces are as broad as ours capability wise...
Obviously they dont have as much capability in terms of Air Lift and maritime patrol however given their much smaller geography it could easily be argued that they dont need to have such strong capabilities in these areas.
I would suggest that Singapore is as/more capable as the RAAF in the areas they need to be. G550's, E2, KC135R, F-15SG, F-16C Bk52+ networked with training, doctine and weapons to match. The RSAF has capabilities in some area's greater than ours.
Obviously they dont have as much capability in terms of Air Lift and maritime patrol however given their much smaller geography it could easily be argued that they dont need to have such strong capabilities in these areas.
H It's capabilities are strong but still deficient in airlift, AEW&C and maritime patrol, meaning ISR capability overall when compared to the RAAF.
The RSAF has developed a force structure capable of countering their geographic disadvantage against Malaysia and Indonesia even assuming they were near peers in professional competency.
With Wedgetail and the significant geographic disadvantage the RSAF faces I think the RAAF could protect Butterworth and degrade the RSAF bases over time.
The number of transports, MPA's and AEW platforms operated by the RSAF are more than sufficient, given the size of the country and its operational requirements.
So this would have some large implications for maritime strike doctorine no? GF your the guy who is most likely to know around here.... can you use JORN data to cue a AShM shot???????
I believe firmly that the RSAF is an extremely well equipped and modern force that is well suited to meeting Singapore's defence requirements.
With the RSAF having all their Singapore based aircraft and the RAAF deploying everything but the bare bones of force generation this would mean:
10 F-15E, 40 F-16D, 20 F-16C, 40 F-5S/T
vs
20 F/A-18F, 50 F/A-18A
With Wedgetail and the significant geographic disadvantage the RSAF faces I think the RAAF could protect Butterworth and degrade the RSAF bases over time. It would take a couple of weeks before we could contest air superiority over Singapore. The RAAF strike missions would be very much decoy heavy and using stand off munitions and air to air ambushes. But the geographic advantage would give a significant initiative advantage to the RAAF/RMAF. Singapore could launch very few sorties without the ops centre at Butterworth knowing about it and even with G550 AEW strike missions with supporting decoys could be positioned against Singapore resulting in multiple vector commitments.
The RSAF has developed a force structure capable of countering their geographic disadvantage against Malaysia and Indonesia even assuming they were near peers in professional competency. But add in another 60-70 high end strike fighters and supporting assets from the RAAF and it would be too much for them. Of course all this is ridiculous, as there is no real political situation which would see Australia against Singapore.
Do you care to explain as to the significant geographical advantages that would be possessed in the defence of say Butterworth than that of Singapore?
Defence and situational awareness in depth. If the RSAF wants to strike Butterworth they have to fly over 600km of Malaysia or up the straits of Malacca, South China Sea and so on.
Defence and situational awareness in depth. If the RSAF wants to strike Butterworth they have to fly over 600km of Malaysia or up the straits of Malacca, South China Sea and so on. During this transit there is plenty of opportunity for their strike to be detected. Frankly its almost impossible for Singapore to launch a strike mission without the takeoff being monitored easily from Malaysia.
On the other hand any strike from Butterworth to Singapore only has to worry about AEW detection before they cross the radar horizon (which they can chose to do when and where). Even with AEW like E-2 and G550 around Singapore (they won't be orbiting near KL unless the RSAF wants to lose their AEW) strikes from Butterworth can takeoff undetected and dogleg around to come in on Singapore from a range of directions.