Not in the next 15 years it's not.![]()
And not the if RMAF has anything to say about it. It remains to be seen if the current government will continue to bad practice of forcing the RMAF to accept stuff it doesn't really want.
Not in the next 15 years it's not.![]()
That's not really an option. The tender is iirc 35-40 aircraft, and is there to replace the F-5 fleet. So the F-18 will remain in service, along side the MiG-29N, and Su-30MKM. In other words choosing the F-16 would add another aircraft to the mix.
Leithen Francis said:Malaysia issues RFIs for fighters and AEW aircraft
25/03/10 - Malaysia has issued a request for information for fighters and airborne early warning aircraft, with a view to placing orders in 2011-15. The sudden flurry of activity has occurred because Malaysia's government is now formulating its 10th five-year national plan for the 2011-15 period, say industry sources.
Kuala Lumpur wants information on fighters such as the Boeing F/A-18E/F Super Hornet, Lockheed Martin F-16 and Saab Gripen. Russian arms export agency Rosoboronexport has stated publicly that it will offer the Sukhoi Su-30. Malaysia wants to order enough aircraft for one to two squadrons, potentially totalling 36-40 airframes. It is seeking to phase out its older fighters, such as the Northrop F-5, and simplify its fleet. Boeing and Sukhoi are arguably the strongest contenders because Malaysia already operates eight F/A-18Ds, that it ordered in the early 1990s, and 18 Su-30s that it ordered in 2003.
Meanwhile, the RFI for two AEW aircraft will bring the Northrop Grumman E-2 Hawkeye and Saab Erieye system in contention. The Swedish manufacturer has already been successful in selling one Erieye-equipped Saab 340 to Thailand, in addition to a first batch of six Gripens. The radar has also already been integrated with the Embraer EMB-145 and Saab 2000.
Northrop has previously sold E-2Cs to Japan, Singapore and Taiwan. The company is considered unlikely to offer the developmental E-2D for the Malaysian requirement.
Even though Malaysia has issued the new RFIs, suppliers have reason to be sceptical about its ability to progress to a contract award, as it has twice launched similar competitions in the past. A failure to follow-through with orders this time could result in some companies being reluctant to entertain future requests, some industry sources warn.
After the MiG-29N retirement U-turn by the Malaysian government, I'm not even going to venture a guess on how the Malaysians will choose this time.
If Malaysia wants to buy AWACs please buy 4 and not just 1 (which is tokenism). .
Cutting the number of fighter types would help with pilot numbers. Cheaper to train pilots on one type than many, & can get by with a lower ratio of pilots to aircraft than when you have penny packets of multiple different types.Fully agreed, numbers do count. In the RMAF's case the shortage of qualified fast jet crews is a major problem and has to be factored in. To cope with an increase in fighter strength the government has to start investing now in additional LIFT platforms and ensure that the Flight Academy and Flight Training Centre's 1 [basic] and 3's [fast jet] are able to keep pace.
The people responsible should all be shot..
The math doesn't add up. Malaysia wants 18 MKMs, 10 MiG-29N, 8 Hornets, and 35-40 new fighters. That doesn't add up to 54.
Or is the F-5 replacement also intended to replace the MiG-29N?
Sorry I was talking about real and currently existing replacement plans, not the ideal ones. Obviously I can sense you have a strong bias in favor of giving the RMAF what it wants, but on some level it's not that simple.
A purchase of fighter jets is not just a decision in the military-technical field, it's also a decision in the political and economic fields. And the politicians have to balance the three.
The current tender is also for 35-40 fighters. Not for 18 (to replace F-5s and Hornets). I'm not sure how many F-5s they operate, but from the looks the current tender may eventually either phase out the Fulcrums or see the RMAF go well beyond 3 squadrons.
You may be right about the commonality issue, which would leave more MKMs as the only sane alternative (provided they're not wiling to go with the H/SH trade-in).
However granted that they've already operated 4 types in under-sized squadrons of each type for quite some years, it wouldn't be surprising to see them operate 4 types once again, with something like the F-16 or F-18E/F replaced the F-5s, but leaving the basic F-18s in service.
Scrap the fulcrums. Sure. And replace them with what?
Well I never claimed to know that. But since you asked.
I really like the gripen. And okay the cost argument is pretty strong here, but its a really nice airframe that the RMAF can absolutely support. It has customers that have great potential to further develop the aircraft, and none of those are likely to give up on that development. I can see South Africa and the Tsjechs step into the development as partners down the line. Both those aerospace industry's are highly industrial, experienced and motivated to be players in that field. Maybe I'm a fanboy, but everyone likes the underdog, and I see a lot of potential if these players really start working together and the Malaysian aerospace industry be a real player if they get into that.
Next to the Gripen the RMAF could go for the F-16, but that would probably mean flying second hand planes, and that doesn't shake with my full replacement theory. But there would be a lot of cheap planes once the F-35 comes around.
There's the F-18. The Rmaf already fly's that one, but it truly is a legacy platform with a limited support lifespan. But the USN is going to retire theirs pretty soon and there may be some nice ones for sale then, but I highly doubt that and if you ask me I'd say the days of the F-18 with the RMAF should be numbered just as those of the Mig29 are.
They could buy more MKM's, they're big, they're bad and they're dangerous, to sum it up the MKM seems to me to be a very capable warplane and I respect it greatly. But is it the best plane for the job? And the RMAF has had a lot of problems with the maintenance infrastructure for the Mig-29's, and more country's have experienced these problems with Russian materiel. Therefore I dont like it.
They could also Buy the Rafale, it would cost them a bundle and they probably refuse to pay that, but it is a really cool aircraft that I like and therefor I list it here as an option. Offcoarse the Typhoon falls under the same category, a long shot but a very very cool option and it would make a great great news story and fuel many more excelent discussions here.
Now what more options exist? Well a lot of nice ones. They could go Chinese, and buy FC-1 or J-10. I like the J-10, its a cool plane with great aerodynamic properties, and a lot of potential. Also China is growing not only as a military power, but a military producer. They would represent an important regional ally, and could provide the entire Malaysian military with some nice and shiny gear.
But to me the Gripen is the best option for the RMAF, and could be the backbone of a plan to create an integrated airdefence system with AEW, ISR, AA refueling and maritime patrol capability's.
Here's a fictional plan for the RMAF:
- 3 sqn's of Gripens (50 - 60x) I'd like to put in another sqn tho
- 4x AEW aircraft: Saab Erieye on the Saab 2000 or EMB-145 platforms
- A maritime patrol fleet based on the Saab 2000 which would double as ISR platform (like nimrod)
- A light transport and mid-air refueling platform based on Saab 2000
Maybe the patrol fleet could be given a gunship task as a third option. The saab 2000 has nice range and the room to fit many different mission systems. They could even make it a modular system, even palletised like the USCG's Ocean sentry. But the importance of the saab 2000 is that the different tasks can be performed by the same basic airframe.
This means that for any Saab 2000 AEW and/or MPA variant to be created it needs to be developed off of 2nd hand aircraft that are currently between 12-18 years old, or the production line needs to be restarted.
Todjaeger said:An area which RMAF needs to be mindful of, particularly with the hodgepodge of fighters currently in service, is making sure future acquisitions are able to 'talk' to each other. I-Cheers