If you don't mind, I would like to share some of my thoughts as an outsider on what you wrote:
1. An integrated multimission groundbased 3D surveillance radar system. I hear those ppl groaning in the background "We have those already".... I tell you its insufficient, there are still gaps in between (although i hear arguments about awacs being used as gap fillers here) and bane of the scenario is that it is not fully integrated. Numbers required?... that is something that only specialists within RMAF would need to come up with but my best guesstimate puts it at 6 radar heads in peninsular and another 6 in East Malaysia. The idea is to cover the vital points and let the 2nd layer of airdefence and the AWACS fill the gaps.
2. Multimission AEWC/ABCCC platform. How many? 6 would be good. 4 is minimum. These should be integrated with the ground based 3D surveillance platforms as well as the SAM batteries and the fighter assets.
9. Networked integrated system between command, control, sensors and shooters.
1. Upgrading the groundbased 3D surveillance radar system and the acquisition of an AWAC platform is something that needs to go hand in hand. With Malaysia's large coastline, it would make sense.
(i) I am not so concerned about the number of the AWACs acquired, as they are very expensive (so 4 would be a good number to start), rather I am more concerned that Malaysia needs to acquire the ability to integrate the AWACs with Malaysia's command and control systems.
(ii) In this respect, the Thais have focused on scholarships for their defense science graduates sending them abroad for training so that they can come back to enable the system to develop to its full capacity. Likewise Singapore sent scholars abroad to learn from the US at the time of the acquisition of the E2C AWACs.
(iii) The acquisition of AWACs signifies the RMAF's coming of age as a capable air force. This maturity must be supported by mature planning and purchase decisions, such as the use of operational analysis (OA). OA is a quantitative management technique to generate detailed plans that is tied to the purchase of new systems. For more details see my comments on OA in
another post.
4. Fighter assets. Definitely something multirole, twin engined (due to the maritime expanse), long legs, AAR capable, with sensors and weapons to the hilt. My choice would be a mix of hornets and Su-30MKM. Min of 2 sqn of 12/18 hornets each (C/D upgraded to some level should be sufficient) and 2 sqn of 18 Su-30MKM each. Best advice here will be to put the F5 and Mig29 out to pasture as soon as feasible to minimize the logistic nightmare.
2. I think that Malaysia really needs to choose between the F18 and the Su-30MKM platforms. It would make logistics planning much easier on the air force.
6. Support assets. Instead of going for 4 x A400M, I would have gone for 4-6 militarised A330/340 with AAR capability. reason being its a jet ac, bigger payload (more fuel for the AAR, bigger capacity cargo and as well as troops). Not really sure whats the AAR capability for A400M but as its a prop, definitely the speed is lower than that of a jet, payload probably slightly lower and fuel offered maybe even lesser. In example, a 60000 lb offload for AAR will only refuel 4 Su-30MKM taking on 15k lb fuel each. What if the strike force require a 4+4 mix?.... Besides now the tanker can fly at about the same combat speed of the fighter, so on a long haul, the fighter can stay with the tanker all the way until punch time.
7. Helicopter. RMAF must release the role of troop support and heli lift to the army and concentrate on specialising in CSAR and Spec Ops. After all with the Eurocopter Cougar being given the LoI approval this is the most logical step as the Cougar is too small to step into heli lift and troop support.
3. I think that the A400M and Eurocopter Cougar are good choices.
There is no need to panic about the delays with the A400M:
(i) as it would mean the manufacturer would have to compensate the buyer (hopefully cheaper planes for Malaysia);
(ii) I would like to note that in terms of pure speed all mid air refueling tankers cannot keep up with fighters. The tankers would give the RMAF aircraft more time on station (for both offensive and defensive counter air sorties). As the RMAF matures and uses AWACs, time on station for fighters become more important; and
(iii) the A400M specifications are excellent and more capable than C130s so it upgrades Malaysia's military lift and mid air refueling capacity.
Other than news reports on the corruption issues (and the posts by other forum members here), the Eurocopter Cougar is very reliable.