Re the winner between Lynx and Redback and politics could the decision come down to cost ?
Re the winner between Lynx and Redback and politics could the decision come down to cost ?
.
Assuming both vehicles are equal, or near enough to equal, then the decision will be very political (in my opinion at least).
We have a Federal Election due by May this year so the ‘cost’ could come down to which Electorate gets to build the new fleet of IFVs, pick the right electorate and you stay in Government too.
,
... a Greens dominated one with no qualms about dishonouring defence agreements.
oldsig
This election the last thing Defence (or those of us who support Defence) needs, is a minority Left of the Left Government requiring Green support to Govern.
you may be right?
I can only presume that the opposition has current security/intel assessments. And obviously further if they assume govt.
currently defence has bipartisan support, I can only presume it’s at its current posturing for reasons.
….. but that’s venturing into politics.
I share the sentiment tho.
Bipartisanship politics?, that's a dinosaur! I can't remember a time when that existed actually.
Really? One party makes the call and orders and procures equipment, and the other does nothing at all, but begrudgingly agrees with the decision makers, is hardly bipartisan.2020 FSP and DSP have bipartisan support. Both parties were extremely supportive.
2016 DWP has bipartisan support.
The vast, vast majority of defence decisions are bipartisan. Ironically, that brings it's own problems. But the two major parties are quite similar in this area.
Really? One party makes the call and orders and procures equipment, and the other does nothing at all, but begrudgingly agrees with the decision makers, is hardly bipartisan.
Did the Lib/Nats agree with the Rudd/Gillard/Rudd government's call to do nothing at all for defence, particularly NAVY?
What about the Hawke Keating era?
Was there bipartisan support for gulf war 2?
Because the ALP were extremely critical of our involvement in participating due to the weapons of Mass destruction call.
You can't actually be suggesting that Labor are better for defence though Volk?
- Considering the RAN is still using the gear ordered in the Hawke Keating years and that gear is expected to continue serving for between another one or two decades it can be all that bad. Yes it could and should have been better but I have more issues with the shipbuilding black hole of the late 90s early 2000s than the the perceived one now.
Defence suffered under every Labor government that you can remember? Do you not remember back to Menzies almost total lack of action at the start of WW2 and Labor’s John Curtain taking the country through the war?
How about this forum returns to defence, not politics?
Not old enough to remember Curtin and Menzies old mate. Whitlam is the 1st PM I can remember.Defence suffered under every Labor government that you can remember? Do you not remember back to Menzies almost total lack of action at the start of WW2 and Labor’s John Curtain taking the country through the war?
How about this forum returns to defence, not politics?
Defence suffered under every Labor government that you can remember? Do you not remember back to Menzies almost total lack of action at the start of WW2 and Labor’s John Curtain taking the country through the war?
How about this forum returns to defence, not politics?
I can just remember Curtain mainly because of my old man’s ranting at the very frequent blackouts in Sydney during 1950ishNot old enough to remember Curtin and Menzies old mate. Whitlam is the 1st PM I can remember.
Politics are allowed when they directly refer to defence. The politics being discussed in the present discourse meet that criteria. The Moderators are monitoring the discussion very closely.Defence suffered under every Labor government that you can remember? Do you not remember back to Menzies almost total lack of action at the start of WW2 and Labor’s John Curtain taking the country through the war?
How about this forum returns to defence, not politics?