6th Generation Fighters Projects

50% of the UK share would be silly. Germany would have to get some of both the UK & Italian shares for any redistribution of work share to make sense.

Well the rumored mix was 40/40/20.. I think quite a bit of that UK value would be in the engines alone with Rolls and IHI.. How movable that is to Germany is a good question anyway.

I certainly don't see Japan moving a single mm on their workshare. They aren't going to spend any time on it.

Japan got a lot of industrial development from F-2, e.g. in developing the first operational fighter AESA radar.
It was useful, even if the platform itself was not what they had hoped for the money invested. However, the end of the coldwar was a peaceful period, so it doesn't really matter that much, except that that is what they have right now to fly against J20s. The J20 is the real deal and a very capable aircraft. It is already being fielded in large numbers. China has enough local airframes they could sell them to... Russia?

The next king's mother was English, through & through - & so is his wife. How German do you think he feels?
English is a Germanic language. A bit of eye poking on my behalf. But it is possible that the UK and Germany and italy could work out a way to get Germany enough workshare they buy into the project. Japan is not the country who is going to do that. Japan is not equiped or interested in more european negociation.

Japan just announced its doubling its defence budget for the next 5 year period.
 
Japan's_next-generation_fighter_aircraft_concept.jpg

I believe this time around it is already too late for Japan to leave GCAP and back and revive toward their F-X (F-3) program. However as info that GCAP shares participation basically divided equally on three way between Japan, UK, and Italy, bringin new partner must be equally agrees upon by all three. Japan so far that shown reluctance to accept new partner (Germany in program).

Thus whoever wants to bring German to the equation in my opinion has to (basically) sell their participation shares. If both Euro partners want to bring Germany and Japan does not, as like any commercial ventures, parties that want to bring Germany are the ones that split shares with. Thus 66% divided into 22% each and Japan retain 33%, as giving Germany equal rights seem not in Japan interest. Off course the split must be agree by Japan, but does not mean Japan has to agree to split shares to bring another partner in.

next king's mother was English, through & through - & so is his wife. How German do you think he feels

One thing that in my opinion Charles did right in marrying Diana is he bring another blue blood that trace back (altough as not pure legitimate lineage) to House Stuart. That diluting his house more dominant German origin blood.
 
A new engine is a significant part of GCAP development, & from what I've read RR is leading it but with major contrbutions from IHI & Avio, in that order. Nobody wants to spend the billions needed to develop a new engine of the desired performance alone, & I don't think MTU has the resources to do it alone in a reasonable time. So, I don't see anyone wanting to put their own engine in it. I think they'll all want access to the finished product, & think it'll probably be better, & cheaper for everyone, than if they develop their own.

MTU is owned by Rolls Royce, I highly doubt they would be interested in developing two separate engines for the same airframe.

A rebadging effort maybe, but not a whole second engine. Not at the same time as they are still developing Ultra Fan, plus starting a new midsize engine to re-enter the high-volume narrow body market.

Plus significant investments in SMR and Submarine Reactors.
 
One thing that in my opinion Charles did right in marrying Diana is he bring another blue blood that trace back (altough as not pure legitimate lineage) to House Stuart. That diluting his house more dominant German origin blood.

I think you and @StingrayOZ are overstating the impact of the King and PoW's lineage in the decisions of the Government of the day.

And overstating how much impact that distant heritage is going to make over whatever statements they may make in private to Government Ministers and Department secretaries.
 
MTU is owned by Rolls Royce, I highly doubt they would be interested in developing two separate engines for the same airframe.

A rebadging effort maybe, but not a whole second engine. Not at the same time as they are still developing Ultra Fan, plus starting a new midsize engine to re-enter the high-volume narrow body market.
I agree, but I was replying to "a Japanese GCAP might well be using IHI engines, while a UK version using RR, a German version can use a MTU Aero one if they want", which I read as suggesting that Germany might commission MTU Aero to produce a German engine for German GCAP.

BTW, I think MTU Aero Engines is separate, & not owned by RR. RR owns the other parts of MTU under Rolls-Royce Power Systems. Similarly, Rolls-Royce Motor Cars is owned by BMW. They've agreed to keep the same names, but not operate in the same sectors. Rolls-Royce's German aircraft engine business was set up with BMW, when they took over KHD Luftfahrttechnik GmbH.
 
I think you and @StingrayOZ are overstating the impact of the King and PoW's lineage in the decisions of the Government of the day.

My point was that global alignment is changing, and UK and Germany can, and for part of history, have gotten along. I think Germany can be the key continental alliance partner for the Uk, and UK the key European alliance partner for Germany. There is key complimentary outlook and capabilities. UK likes to lead, has clear ideas, has political resolve, but money doesn't match ambition, industry is light on. Germany has money, industry, but lacks political decision, political will, conops, ability to run a military alliance and perform all key command and control of it. That is a very short messy few word outline of what I see.

Not that because two people bumped uglies a century ago you are tied into an alliance.

The key thing here is not GCAP. It that the UK and Germany could form the basis of a wider alliance, and GCAP could be a key stone example of how that would work.

Burning all of that for 2% of a workshare is stupid.

The whole point of a military is deterrence. Yes, you should have sovereign capabilities. But they should link in to form a larger stronger multinational alliance. That is true deterrence, credible multinational response that would go all in. UK and Germany combined - that is a credible defence pact. There are only two people that need to consult and decide, that is small enough and agile enough to make it work.

This could be how Europe operates beyond NATO. If UK and Germany agree, that is enough to lead everyone else. You have enough political/military/social mass to make things happen with just those two. I don't think another huge everyone has equal vote even if you make tiny contributions European system is going to work. It needs to be based on mass. Other smaller nations can join in if their beliefs and capabilities align, but it isn't essential. If the UK and Germany agree, then its likely others will see that clear enough to join said coalition.

It is in Japan's interest to get the UK and Germany to talk to each other. But europe needs to work this out. The way europe is structured, IMO, a simple democratic one nation one vote on every decision doesn't work for operational military decisions. It hasn't worked for military weapons development.

The fact that many UK and German businesses are interdependent or interlocked, or inter-owned, is a strength not a weakness. Again, this stupid everyone needs exactly 33.3333% of work is stupid. Projects cannot and have not worked that way. That is a very small minded, box flogging, EU style peace business mindset. Not what people do when facing existential threats. Neither the German nor UK nor Italian economy would collapse if one country has slightly different workshare. This is purely just national pride absurdity.

And its that's kind of stupidity that will see larger more powerful nations, tear these smaller powers apart. Economically and literally on the battlefield.
 
Pistorius set out the timetable in an interview with the Funke Media Group, published on Saturday, 7 November 2026, and relayed by dpa. His goal, he said according to the German-language dpa report carried by n-tv, is a directional decision in the first quarter of next year. The two options: buy into the British, Italian and Japanese GCAP programme, or let Airbus build something new with other European partners.

....Either way, the message is the same. Berlin wants a seat at the design table and a healthy share of the work, but it is not proposing to build a fighter on its own.


We have a semblence of a timeline for a decision on Germany's participation. But if Germany keeps to this narrow self-interest of workshare/business mindset, it is a non-starter.

European politicians need to have some back bone and tell Germany that the boat has sailed; if they want to be a paying passenger, sure, but they don't get a say on the direction of the voyage.
 

Dasault lead French 6th gen with ACF and seems potentially can invite Spain to join again. So German choice is not that much. Either become follower in GCAP or create 3rd Euro 6th Gen program.

France is pursuing a sixth-generation aircraft on its own, though it still leaves the door open for other countries to join. Dassault Aviation is leading the development under the Avion de Combat du Futur (ACF) program.

Seems it is really going to be in Rafale class, as they say GCAP design is too big for them.
 
The Financial Times reported that Italy rejected Germany's request for a full participation and share into GCAP. Reportedly, Germany rejected observer status but a full seat, workshare on the table.

But a couple of hours later, another statement from the Italian government said the FT article was misleading and it fully supported Germany's participation.

If I read between the lines, "participation" can mean anything and my intepretation is the FT article is likely not wrong, but the framing didn't suit Italy. The politicians are tip-toeing around saying no.

 
Back
Top