Agreed Chis, as beneficial as C-17 is, for us a few times a year would not warrant the costs (Aqquisition, maintainence and operation) of having them run around half empty/in NZ/training flights etc. The medium lifters have been mooted to fill a gap in our transport sector and for all reasons that have been brought up on here and now we want to go even bigger with even less available at even more cost all the while potentially cutting out the medium lifters (or some other capability) all together.
Some possible options I see would be
A. 2 C-17s, 5 legacy C130 (B757 gone) and wait out the SLEP life until we win lotto.
B. 2 C-17s, 2 C130J-30s (no medium lifters) heavy transport taken care of.
C. 2 C-17s, 4 C-27s (nil C130 size) more coverage spread.
D. 4 A400s, 5 C-295 (somewhat unproven depending on time) better numbers
All options with B757 gone, another factor/loss to take into account (remember NZ context not doomsday theory)
I still feel A400 would be our best option in terms of fleet size, capability (covers 90, LAV etc) and costs. Like NH90 by the time we have got our moneys worth out of the SLEP all the niggles should be ironed out. If only we could get a couple of C-17s, a few A400 and some medium lifters we would be top of our transport game however cost (both short and long term) dictate and say a big resounding no or adversely affects fleet numbers whichever direction you go.