The Russian-Ukrainian War Thread

Of course it has a strategic value. It is important for the civilian traffic and the non-hazardous supply of the Crimean.
Okay, not a direct military strategic value, but the civilians are now trapped, or they try to get the drone attacked M14 to Mariupol.
It has clearly an indirect strategic value, because the gouvernment now has to cope with a limited suply road.
Currently appr. 2 Mio people are living in a trap with need of food, fuel, water (at least in summer). Without the bridge (raod and rail) these will have to be transported via the land route in the occupied Ukrainian south.
It seems to me that you are not aware of the strict traffic restrictions that were already in place for years. I don’t want to write walls of text and make numerous citations, so a short AI query that summarizes what has been the case for a long while now:

IMG_7596.jpeg

So everything you are saying has been a real life for some time now. Furthermore, the rail is still operational, at least partially. For now. Whether more strikes will take place to bring that part of the bridge down remains unknown (I doubt it will happen in the near future, but we will see).

Basically what happens now is that people - that is, civilians, but potentially military personnel as well - would have to travel a longer route around and at a higher personal risk. And the closer that route is to the frontline, the higher the risk, obviously.

In other words, strategic impact here is very limited, if existing at all.
 
It seems to me that you are not aware of the strict traffic restrictions that were already in place for years. I don’t want to write walls of text and make numerous citations, so a short AI query that summarizes what has been the case for a long while now:

View attachment 56026

So everything you are saying has been a real life for some time now. Furthermore, the rail is still operational, at least partially. For now. Whether more strikes will take place to bring that part of the bridge down remains unknown (I doubt it will happen in the near future, but we will see).

Basically what happens now is that people - that is, civilians, but potentially military personnel as well - would have to travel a longer route around and at a higher personal risk. And the closer that route is to the frontline, the higher the risk, obviously.

In other words, strategic impact here is very limited, if existing at all.

Was the strike then purely for propaganda, or was it part of a broader effort to overwhelm Russian air defenses and hit other targets along the Sea of Azov coast?
 
It seems to me that you are not aware of the strict traffic restrictions that were already in place for years. I don’t want to write walls of text and make numerous citations, so a short AI query that summarizes what has been the case for a long while now:

View attachment 56026

So everything you are saying has been a real life for some time now. Furthermore, the rail is still operational, at least partially. For now. Whether more strikes will take place to bring that part of the bridge down remains unknown (I doubt it will happen in the near future, but we will see).

Basically what happens now is that people - that is, civilians, but potentially military personnel as well - would have to travel a longer route around and at a higher personal risk. And the closer that route is to the frontline, the higher the risk, obviously.

In other words, strategic impact here is very limited, if existing at all.
You are right in terms of the traffic restrictions. But a large amount of private supply were transportet across the bridge. I can´t find the YT report, but during the last closing of the bridge nearly all private cars which drove from the Taman side onto the Crimean were stuffed with goods.

If you are referring to military strategic impacts they may be limited. But the civilian, political impacts are not to discuss in my opinion. And if the Railway will be transferred to the underwater department the situation will become worse.

If the Ukraine will be able
1. to destroy/substantial damaging the railway bridge
2. to destroy/substantial damaging the 3 truck carrying bridges at the entrance of the penisula
and
3. to block the M14 road for supply trucks heading to Crimea with a new drone campaign
then the life on Crimea will be uncomfortable. And with that problems it will be a strategic problem for the Russian regime.
 
I cannot see any, another, siege of Sevastopol starting any time soon. Russia losing more ships to supply Crimea? I happened before. Rationing, more civilians deaths? Is that how Ukraine is going to win the war?

Can Russia start a "bridge campaign against" Jarkov, and Kiev? Simply using heavy glide bombs against Jarkov? Is Ukraine (and we) going to call that terrorist attacks? With every great idea that Zelenski had, Ukraine has been suffering even more. How wonderful was the Kursk offensive, it achieved what exactly?
I can read, in Western media, great expectations about this attack, is it going to change the negotiations in Abu Dhabi? I don't know what Russia is going to do, but did Zelenski thought about the reaction?

Zelenski was asking for 70, EU is talking about 45. I cannot see Ukrainian future improving.
 
Back
Top