overlander
Member
Defence cuts: Carrier 'fully operational in 2030'
BBC News - Defence cuts: Carrier 'fully operational in 2030'
BBC News - Defence cuts: Carrier 'fully operational in 2030'
Defence cuts: Carrier 'fully operational in 2030'
BBC News - Defence cuts: Carrier 'fully operational in 2030'
I was wondering what people felt about the UK's ability to defend the Falkand Islands without a usable aircraft carrier? If the Argentinian's decided to launch a major invasion would they be able to cope with their existing naval defences?
I look forward to your views
G
I totally agree with your opinion but be careful that somebody here will write soon you are "running down the royal navy" as they write when I write the same opinions in this forum.Financially the UK maybe in dire straights but unless others know different Spain and Italy who are in a much worse situation still have a carrier capability.
The UK has worldwide military conmitments but our leaders have decided we can do without carriers - either Spanish and Italian politicians have got it wrong or the UKs government thinks defence is no longer a priority?
Originally the new carriers were to be equipped with 36 F35B now we are looking at 12 - the carriers are now a victim of the MoD/government incompetence in forward planning, managing budgets etc.
We didn't envisage our forces been used in Libya one year ago so how we can afford to wait to 2030 before one carrier is fully operational - the world is changing daily (look at the situation in Iran) and politicians are gambling with our security.
Financially the UK maybe in dire straights but unless others know different Spain and Italy who are in a much worse situation still have a carrier capability.
The UK has worldwide military conmitments but our leaders have decided we can do without carriers - either Spanish and Italian politicians have got it wrong or the UKs government thinks defence is no longer a priority?
Originally the new carriers were to be equipped with 36 F35B now we are looking at 12 - the carriers are now a victim of the MoD/government incompetence in forward planning, managing budgets etc.
We didn't envisage our forces been used in Libya one year ago so how we can afford to wait to 2030 before one carrier is fully operational - the world is changing daily (look at the situation in Iran) and politicians are gambling with our security.
Of far greater concern is the fact that the RAF has no maritime patrol capability (NONE!!), apart from a Hercules fitted with a MkI Eyeball. Seriously, WTF?
Should have had a few P-3Cs bundled with the RC-135Ws.
So the QE-class won't be the biggest defence fiasco because that place is reserved for the MR4. Oh wait, I just remembered the Chinook HC3...
We can't get *anything* right - we can't buy off the peg (HC3..) and we can't refurb existing kit (MR4) and we can't build to order (QE)
Here we goes again...I was wondering what people felt about the UK's ability to defend the Falkand Islands without a usable aircraft carrier? If the Argentinian's decided to launch a major invasion would they be able to cope with their existing naval defences?
I look forward to your views
G
Here we goes again...
Please understand this, while we, the Argentineans think that the Islands belong to us, the war in 1982 was the idea of a goverment that was anything but popular among us, quite the opposite...
Argentina with all his flaws it has been in a democracy for almost 30 years and there is no indication, internal or external of that changing in the future.
We will keep our claim forever, but a invasion is not a option, not because our military is far from a good shape, which is true, but because that everybody here think that that will be stupid, if the UK decide tomorrow to double the extesion of the area that is claimed by the islander as their EEZ then will see, but right now and in the foreseable future, that scenario is fiction.
In this thread you can find a more detailed insght about that in the "argentinian-blockade-falklands" thread, sorry I can post links yet.
Anyway since the UK begun with its defence budget cuts the Islands issue has been more and more recurrent...
I wouldn't say that. What the UK did to the Apache was about the best thing one could do with an attack helicopter.
And it has been one of the biggest successes I have seen in recent times in terms of military programs.
We could have bought the same specification as was in production for the Netherlands at the time. It met our needs. The whole thing was due to a crazy idea that a weird bespoke hybrid of new digital & old analogue kit, with a specially created interface to allow them to work together, would be cheaper than OTS.
It made as much sense as the "let's delete the gun from Typhoon to save money" lunacy, when it was already developed, bought & paid for, along with the ammunition. The studies which eventually decided that it would be cheaper to leave it in place cost more than the saving which the bean counters had hoped for, so it was pure waste.
I was wondering what people felt about the UK's ability to defend the Falkand Islands without a usable aircraft carrier? If the Argentinian's decided to launch a major invasion would they be able to cope with their existing naval defences?
I look forward to your views
G