Given the delays and overruns created by home-grown upgrades (K2/C-130LEP) and procurement of un-proven aircraft (NH-90) would there not be a certain amount of reluctance to strike out on our own and create another bespoke platform?A timely reminder of the level the NZ P3s where upgraded too. This would indicate to me that the RNZAF would not be interested in some of the simpler ASW platforms on the international market. However it also shows that given internal room and enough electrical power that some of the offerings could easily be upgraded to meet our requirements. As I have only seen the basic RFI I would imagine that what is in the fine print would be telling, as this should tell us to what level the various functions capabilities would be considered desirable
Given the delays and overruns created by home-grown upgrades (K2/C-130LEP) and procurement of un-proven aircraft (NH-90) would there not be a certain amount of reluctance to strike out on our own and create another bespoke platform?
The above projects certainly strike a contrast to the COTS/MOTS purchases of the T-6/A-109/SH-2G(I) which were successfully accomplished in a much shorter timeframe.
There appears to been lessons learned from previous acquisitions, both by NZDF and the ADF, with the current NZG being risk adverse when it comes to defence acquisitions. They have apparently learned the lesson that something mature and MOTS / COTS is less costly both fiscally and temporally, meaning that mature MOTS / COTS have a greater probability of being delivered both within budget and on time. This is especially pertinent with aviation acquisitions. The current NZG also appear to have learned the lesson that cheap is not always best in the long term because it is a false economy, in that the platform numbers, maintenance and sustainment costs tend to balloon out as the platforms age and such costs become disproportionate vis a vis another platform, or a higher quantity of platforms, that had higher up front costs but in the long term would have been cheaper to sustain and maintain.Given the delays and overruns created by home-grown upgrades (K2/C-130LEP) and procurement of un-proven aircraft (NH-90) would there not be a certain amount of reluctance to strike out on our own and create another bespoke platform?
The above projects certainly strike a contrast to the COTS/MOTS purchases of the T-6/A-109/SH-2G(I) which were successfully accomplished in a much shorter timeframe.
Given the delays and overruns created by home-grown upgrades (K2/C-130LEP) and procurement of un-proven aircraft (NH-90) would there not be a certain amount of reluctance to strike out on our own and create another bespoke platform?
The above projects certainly strike a contrast to the COTS/MOTS purchases of the T-6/A-109/SH-2G(I) which were successfully accomplished in a much shorter timeframe.
The SH2G(I) acquisition was a lucky break for us, because if the RAN had stuck with the acquisition then we would have either had to undertake an expensive MLU of our 5 x SH2G(NZ) and still have the problem of not enough airframes. Or we would have had to replace the 5 x SH2G(NZ) with another type at considerable expense; somewhere in the region of what the NH90 acquisition cost us.The above projects certainly strike a contrast to the COTS/MOTS purchases of the T-6/A-109/SH-2G(I) which were successfully accomplished in a much shorter timeframe.
Jealous, I am. Wonder if they were up for a special reason. Battle of Britain day is next Thursday.Just had a formation of the Ohakea Spitfire and Avenger circling the town. could not hear the spit due to a noisy Wright engine. looked fantastic with all the sounds of yester year.
Jealous, I am. Wonder if they were up for a special reason. Battle of Britain day is next Thursday.
Jealous, I am. Wonder if they were up for a special reason. Battle of Britain day is next Thursday.
Cobber, I was born here in Christchurch and bought up in Southland, so I am a diehard MainlanderNgati you will just have to move here then you won't be jealous any more. LOL
So it would be interesting to know how much money has been allocated for the replacement of the C130 and how far this would go with each optionI was trying to find some consistent pricing for the possible Herk replacements but found that most quoted prices were either inconsistent or out of date. I did however come up with the following ballpark comparison between the contenders. I would stress that this is based on flyaway cost and not total program costs. For the cost of 5 C130J's you will get
3 to 3.5 A400m's
3.5 to 4 Kawasaki C2's
6 KC390's
I think the Airforce would prefer the bigger 2 types as the RFI appears to be written with this in mind. Treasury would probably go for the KC390 and if some political deal is made the C130 cannot be discounted.
The flyaway cost for the C130J is US$67.3 million http://www.saffm.hq.af.mil/shared/media/document/AFD-130408-079.pdfI was trying to find some consistent pricing for the possible Herk replacements but found that most quoted prices were either inconsistent or out of date. I did however come up with the following ballpark comparison between the contenders. I would stress that this is based on flyaway cost and not total program costs. For the cost of 5 C130J's you will get
3 to 3.5 A400m's
3.5 to 4 Kawasaki C2's
6 KC390's
I think the Airforce would prefer the bigger 2 types as the RFI appears to be written with this in mind. Treasury would probably go for the KC390 and if some political deal is made the C130 cannot be discounted.
The flyaway cost for the C130J is US$67.3 million http://www.saffm.hq.af.mil/shared/media/document/AFD-130408-079.pdf
The flyaway cost for the A400M is €152.4 million Projet de loi de finances pour 2014 : D?fense : ?quipement des forces et excellence technologique des industries de d?fense
The flyaway cost for the Kawasaki C2 is 20 billion yen http://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/20...-force-unveils-c-2-next-generation-transport-
The flyaway cost for the Embraer KC390 is US$50 million
EMBRAER KC-390 Medium-Range Transport Aircraft | Military-Today.com
These costs I have had to dig around for and are from my spreadsheet. The C130J and A400M costs come from official govt sources. The other two are not so reliable.
How current are these figures, A recent USAF order at the end of 2015 for 43 aircraft was quoted at US5.3 billion and that was said to be a 10 % saving due to the size of the order. As the USAF has had the aircraft in service for a number of years you would think that while it may include spares there would not be any setup costs involved. Other figures found generally put the C130 at around US100+ and the KC390 in the US80 to 95 mark but as I said there was significant variation. One web site I looked at (sorry I forgot to take the address) showed US military aircraft produced year by year and the cost per unit. this showed significant rises in cost recently.The flyaway cost for the C130J is US$67.3 million http://www.saffm.hq.af.mil/shared/media/document/AFD-130408-079.pdf
The flyaway cost for the A400M is €152.4 million Projet de loi de finances pour 2014 : D?fense : ?quipement des forces et excellence technologique des industries de d?fense
The flyaway cost for the Kawasaki C2 is 20 billion yen http://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/20...-force-unveils-c-2-next-generation-transport-
The flyaway cost for the Embraer KC390 is US$50 million
EMBRAER KC-390 Medium-Range Transport Aircraft | Military-Today.com
These costs I have had to dig around for and are from my spreadsheet. The C130J and A400M costs come from official govt sources. The other two are not so reliable.
The C130J figures were taken from US DOD Budget documents so when you open the link it will have the year somewhere. The A400M figures are from French Senate documents dated around 2013. The C2 data is from a Japanese newspaper so the date will be in the storyline. The KC390 timeline is anyone's guess.How current are these figures, A recent USAF order at the end of 2015 for 43 aircraft was quoted at US5.3 billion and that was said to be a 10 % saving due to the size of the order. As the USAF has had the aircraft in service for a number of years you would think that while it may include spares there would not be any setup costs involved. Other figures found generally put the C130 at around US100+ and the KC390 in the US80 to 95 mark but as I said there was significant variation. One web site I looked at (sorry I forgot to take the address) showed US military aircraft produced year by year and the cost per unit. this showed significant rises in cost recently.
The C130J figures were taken from US DOD Budget documents so when you open the link it will have the year somewhere. The A400M figures are from French Senate documents dated around 2013. The C2 data is from a Japanese newspaper so the date will be in the storyline. The KC390 timeline is anyone's guess.
Of course its not just capability and price, but which of the current contenders will offer us the best support in the long run, and through life cost of running them. Even China has their Y20 transport doing air shows and up for foriegn sales now.