John Fedup
The Bunker Group
AOR is I think only one role of the JSS. They also want it to be able to resupply dry stores and sealift the Canadian Army and use it as a command centre.
I think with JSS they are a victim of too much multi rolling. They could grab a Container ship (or some sort of lease arrangement on one) and a tanker and get a very easy solution. This would free up funds for surface combatants and the Amphibious ship (which they wanted Largs Bay for). It would be better for the Canadian ship building industry imo too.
JSS has been all the color and movement in Canadian procurement, but there's not much of a fleet left to resupply.
Comparing Australia and Canada defence paths is very interesting. Australia had an event that meant it stopped dicking around with polishing turds and went out and got some very serious hardware. 2 first class LHD's, Largs, 3 AWD and is coming up with some sort of path for the frigate replacements and a serious sub project. There are issues, but there is progress.
Canada on the other hand has been gridlocked by indecisiveness, capability growth and investing in money pits and polishing turds to try and save money. Spending ~$400 m on a temporary solution seems wasteful. They would have been better to lease two commercial ships and put that money to a proper amphib.
Canadian military procurement is so constipated there are no turds to polish. Furthermore with inflation eating away the allocated money for new naval ships, there will be fewer ships so maybe only 1 Berlin AOR will get built. When Canada had a 16 surface combatant navy (4 Tribal class destroyers along with 12 Halifax frigates) it only had 2 replenishment ships. The RCN may very well only end up with 6-8 new ships to replace the 12 Halifax frigates and the 1 remaining (barely seaworthy) Tribal destroyer.