Ozymandias
Banned Member
.
quotes don't work
quotes don't work
*yawn* this is the attitude why I got out of the industry. It makes me happy that I never have to speak to DMO ever again.![]()
Here is a pretty big read (over 100 pages) it is a paper from the Kokoda Foundation on our future submarines, I have not read it all yet, but seems to have some good information on our strategic outlook etc and what is happening in the region.
Others on here with more knowledge than me may be able to pic it apart a bit more, and no doubt (have not got to the end yet) I would not be surprised if the end recomends Australia getting Virginia's, One of Ross' pet projects. So apart from that, I think it has some good background strategic information regardless of the obvious outcome, would be interested in opinions
http://www.kokodafoundation.org/Resources/Documents/KP17.pdf
I know we are not getting nuclear powered submarines; it was more of what are the design limitations of Astute over Virginia class submarine in a RAN operational perspective. Both Collins and Astute class had troubled beginning but with American help seem to have gotten over them.it just seemed that GF rebuke of the Astute class seemed a bit strange and that all is still not well with the submarine just wondering what the problem is.
That’s if he can without a CLM.
It was a very interesting read and covers the many build/contract method/risk mitigation/role of defence etc etc issues that are intimately part of the whole replacement question.
My reading is that it points to an evolved "Collins" as the only logical solution.
It also dispels many of the misconceptions trumpeted by the unimformed regarding the Collins project.
Another paper that should be read in conjunction with the above is the RAND corps analysis of the Astute's design and build and the lessons to be learned from that experience.
I cannot get the link to work but I'll give it for others to search and read
www.rand.org/content/dam/rand/pubs/monographs/1211/RAND_MG1128.3pdf
Alternatively, google Astute problems rand.
Have been trying to make it work for two days!
Cheers for that ! another 100 pageswill be an interesting read when I get to it, The Kokoda report was interesting in that they held the US Virginia as an example of how to get it right so will be good to read about the flip side.
Found it ok, here is the link I have
http://www.rand.org/content/dam/rand/pubs/monographs/2011/RAND_MG1128.3.pdf
Cheers
I was lucky enough to attend some of the "invite" briefings on the Virginias at various UDT Conferences in Hawai'i and Rome (and prior to me working in Govt)
As an aside it was in the period when some of my friends in APA accused me of working for DMO and pushing JSF - when I was actually working in Germany and the US as a contractor on subs and sig management for small skimmers. My passport doesn't lie but that doesn't stop the APA jihad against their opponents...
The focus on the USN to get it right, and pay attention to the shortfall mistakes of the Seawolf class was pretty rivetting
At the same time the US Dept of Commerce gave an additional brief on the problems had with the Astutes - and introduced members of the USN Team involved with sorting them out. (RN attending ranks looked a bit squeamish when this happened)
We were supposed to have learnt from the probs that caused UK Govt and the RN grief. You'd have to be an optimist to say that we have.
The Dept Commerce brief is not the RAND brief but I don't think its gone into the public domain
It is a real pitty we dont seem to be getting it right, especially as I understand it, that the US are ready with so much help for us to get it right. The US has not been shy in recent times to politely point out some things to the Government, they don't seem to be listening.
I have some fond memories of Hawai'i. Once the USN sub geeks found out who I was contracting to I never once paid for a beer.
If you were from Oz and worked in the sub industry they fell over backwards to be nice - It always cracks me up when you see "dud sub" commentary in Oz papers - these blokes lived and breathed UDT and sub warfare and they were highly respectful of Collins capability - and for that matter - some of the Australian niche expertise in modifying sensor capabilities. They had a lot of time for DSTO and to my mind seemed far more keen to listen to them rather than attend the NAVSEA briefings
But, both the major parties have contributed to the public perception that the subs are no good, and that we can't build them properly. I hate going home at christmas and having half arsed conversations with my mates when they bag our capability and expertise - but they're media consumers of TDT and APA
It frustrates me no end
But, both the major parties have contributed to the public perception that the subs are no good, and that we can't build them properly. I hate going home at christmas and having half arsed conversations with my mates when they bag our capability and expertise - but they're media consumers of TDT and APA
It frustrates me no end
Joy, here we go again!
Cookies must be enabled. | The Australian
I wonder if the poeple putting these ideas forward actually understand what is involved and how this will distort the entire defence budget.
That said, if it could be done for the price they postulate (highly doubtful) I suppose the A$10 billion in savings could be used to update the entire major surface combatant force to at least AWD standard or maybe reintroduce carrier airpower to the RAN....
:daz
Simon is a Research Fellow in the Economics Program at The Centre for Independent Studies and specialises in government industry policy and regulation. Before joining the CIS, he practised corporate law for several years at a top tier law firms in Sydney and London, after which he joined the NSW government’s industry division. He has degrees in commerce and law from the University of New South Wales.
For those of us who don't have an account at The Australian, the Centre for Independent Studies report is here: Publications - Future Submarine Project Should Raise Periscope for Another Look
For those of us who don't have an account at The Australian, the Centre for Independent Studies report is here: Publications - Future Submarine Project Should Raise Periscope for Another Look O yes the author is a lawyer
Cool thanks for that wee trick. I'm not knowledgeable on subs let alone nucs but I could pick a few sizeable holes in that story. Like "These subs don't carry nuclear weapons ..." They carry the Tomahawk which IIRC is quite capable of being armed with a nuclear warhead. Go figure - thats very basic research.Thanks for that, the other thing that works is highlighting the title, right click and google search, which will usually bring up the full text. Just don't tell Rupert!
Joy, here we go again!
Cookies must be enabled. | The Australian
I wonder if the poeple putting these ideas forward actually understand what is involved and how this will distort the entire defence budget.
That said, if it could be done for the price they postulate (highly doubtful) I suppose the A$10 billion in savings could be used to update the entire major surface combatant force to at least AWD standard or maybe reintroduce carrier airpower to the RAN....
:daz
I wonder where we would get the man power to staff the Virginia Class???? don't they use crap loads of personnel compared to the Collins? Not to mention all the different jobs there are on a Nuke Sub that are not on the Collins! In my uneducated military eyes getting a Nuke sub would take years and years of training just to operate them and put them to sea I think a lot of people(jurno's) just think a sub is a sub and that's it! they all go under water don't they?