While CB90 might not be the actual solution there is a need to operate the Army’s new Tactical Littoral Craft, SOF RHIBs and to provide for growth in RHIB capability. Current Navy RHIBs are 9m types but SOF are 11m and there is potential that the Navy will upsize to this type. Further the TLC might come in as a CB90 sized boat, though I think a SB90E or JMEC size is more likely. Either way bigger means the other can be accommodated.
But thats a very large compromise. Going from a 9m RHIB to a 11m RHIB is prudent, but assuming to operate CB90 is a bit far. If we need CB90 to operate in the area you can motor them in, or carry and operate out of a LHD. SB90E sized is more reasonable and there would be several ways to launch ships of that size, not every hull would need to launch SB90E sized vessels. Thats not to say CB90 isn't useful, but placing it in a 1000t boat isn't going to be the best compromise. The OCV can still act as a base of operations for CB90 sized craft it just doesn't have to carry it as well. Maybe place them with the LHD or other large vessel.
I don’t see the need for Harpoon because this ship is not the ADF’s only ship killer asset. A guided missile for maritime interdiction (boat killing) is certainly something you would want but these are best on the helicopter – providing greater reach. Phalanx is a good self defence capability and probably already under consideration re the “autonomous self defence” capabity listed in the SEA 1180 documents.
Being able to carry harpoon could be useful for several reasons. Other nations might become interested (NZ, pacific etc). While Australia has other assets, there may be a case where they need to move away from the area (LHD, AWD and ANZAC) while the OCV has to stay closer, medical evac, insertion, extraction etc. Im not saying it would be its standard mode of operation, but may be a role it needs something a bit heavier. Also with that land attack harpoon may also be critical to strike targets during an insertion. Carrying harpoon would not be done at the same time as many of its other roles, weight margin should be there anyway (really about making sure console space is avalible etc, and there is an appropriate space to fit harpoons).
As a modular capability like Phalanx a medium calibre gun makes a lot of sense. But it isn’t really needed on MCM, Hydro or border protection missions.
But thats the genius of it, fit it as needed, on a per mission requirement. A ship like this would more likely be attacked by munitions Phalanx would be great at rather than a missile based system. RPG, drones, light missiles, motars, old naval guns etc. You more likely to be closer where missile systems may have difficulty engaging. Most of the time none of them would carry it.
76 mm would seem to be an ideal size and something we already have. (57mm I don't think we need). The remainder could be fitted with typhoons. I would imagine for SOF you would use the unit fitted with 76mm and a Phalanx mount with perhaps mini typhoon mounded stern. Operating with a CB90 under the protection of the OCV (and its helo), then able to dart out to sea where a much larger asset (LHD and AWD's) would protect, carry etc. Being able to refuel/resupply a CB90 I think is more important than carrying it.