John Newman
The Bunker Group
And nearly copied my post word for word, I'll just stop to say very much my thoughts as well. Apart from tight budgets with many hands outstretched (Subs, supply ships, future frigates, patrol boats etc) I can't really see the RAN ending up in a situation needing a carrier without having an ally alongside with one (USA/UK). All said and done, if the brief hit my desk with the will and want I'd be going for the Cavour too. Order a squadron of F-35B and before you know it you could be rolling.
Apart from the competing budget priorities (and even if Defence spending gets to 2% much soon than later and more importantly stays there!), I just can't see it happening, regardless of a way being found to afford such a capability without sacrificing another capability in the process.
Firstly you would need both major political parties to have a continuing bipartisan agreement that 'yes a fixed wing capability was to be re-established and maintained', and I can't see that happening for a start.
It would also need, in my opinion, some major shift in our regional circumstances with the resultant changes in our Defence and Foreign policies and outlook too.
I'm not anti carrier, my heart would like to see it, but my head tells me otherwise!