Great link thanks Abe, it will keep me occupied while on sick kid duty today.
Been there done that, so good luck with that! Some interesting ideas here to ponder.
The Hellcats and Avengers would have ideal for the Implacables though would have been due for replacement by Korea. Maybe a Colossus / Majestic or even an Illustrious (or Indomitable), I imagine an Essex would have encountered the same US Dollar issues you mentioned, could have been leased during that conflict, and then retained to cover the modernisation of the Implacables to operate modern aircraft and maybe into the 60s as a training ship / fast troop transport.
The Implacable could serve through Korea. The Hellcat wouldn’t be too different to the Sea Fury for air to ground missions. For air to air they could operate a notional CAC Panther. The standard USN Panther was too high with wings folded (>16’) to fit in the Impacables’ short hangars. But Panther wing fold was at the wing root. One purpose built for the 14’ Impacable hangar could have a mid-wing fold in addition to the wing root fold for a folded height of around 12’ (tail height). Even without a CAC Panther you could hangar jet fighters like the Sea Vampire and Sea Venom on the Implacables.
A licensed CAC Panther would have been a very interesting option for the RAAF and RAN as it would logically have been followed by the Cougar and then Tiger with the Super Tiger becoming a no brainer. I assume the Australianised Panther and Cougar would have used RR Tay while the Tiger / Super Tiger would have gone for the Avon and possibly ADEN in place of the Colts. Who knows, maybe the advent of a substantial late 50s order for Super Tigers by the RAAF/RAN could have pushed it over the line in the “Deal of the Century” with the Australian mods offered as Euro friendly options.
The Grumman progression would be an interesting option for CAC. The Panther was originally selected for the RAAF because it was to be powered by the Nene and then the Tay which was just a slightly scaled up Nene. The Nene and Tay built by CAC were to be the centre of the Australian built post war jet fleet because the Nene would power the DHA built Vampire and the Tay GAF Canberra (which was also trialed with the Nene and at the time the Avon was on the secret UK only list). The Tay was also to power the CAC built Hawker P.1081 and the Nene used for early designs of the CA-23 (both after the Panther was passed over). Once the Avon was off the secret list the RAAF wanted it for the Canberra and CA-23 and the delays in the day fighter program meant by the time the Sabre was selected the Avon was available.
If they found the US Dollars to buy the Panther design then CAC could have built a RAAF day fighter, all-weather interceptor version and RAN fighter. The day fighter could be produced in place of the urgent buy of the Meteor for use in Korea. The all-weather interceptor design was prepared before CA-23 and had a radar operator in a coal scuttle position forward of the pilot’s cockpit. The Panther could also be built as a dual control trainer with the Nene in place of the Vampire trainers. It would kill of DHA as an airframe builder 10 years early but would strengthen CAC through to the Tiger.
With the Tiger I doubt that CAC could handle it capacity wise until the Super Tiger was conceived (1955) what with Panther, swept wing Panther (Cougar), twin seat Nene Panther (trainer) and the like. Also would CAC be building the Avon? If the RAAF had went with the Tay Canberra it wouldn’t be needed. Even when they selected the Avon the plan was to import them because of their higher cost. We only set up the CAC Avon production line to keep them in work. But if they are churning out Tays for Panthers that need would be redundant.
The J79 is closely integrated with the Super Tiger. The Tiger would probably still be a short range dog with the Avon in place of the Sapphire. Rather than stop off at the Tiger CAC could go straight through to building both the Super Tiger and the J79. They could even supply J79s for the last batch of wet wing GAF Canberras (which could boost their range and speed). I’m not sure if ADEN would be introduced because there would be no operational need to replace the existing HE firing 20mm guns (unlike the Sabre’s .50 FMJ M3s) but in a perfect would the unreliable Colts could be replaced by the Hughes revolver gun (twice the weight of the Colt for four times the ROF). Avoinics wise the Super Tiger had an excellent space and weight allotment and the Americans were producing the best stuff at this time by far. I doubt even RAAF production could help the Super Tiger in the ‘Deal of the Century’ and other competitions it lost as it was bribery and political manoeuvring that won those deals. But the CAC Tiger would be superior to the Mirage, F-104 and MiG-21s around the world and could be in squadron service by 1960.
What to follow the Super Tiger with is more problematic as they had nothing that would have suited Australia after the Super Tiger. Phantom would be nice but a CAC Crusader / Twosader (RR Spey 202 + other mods maybe ADEN, Ferranti Airpass, Firestreak/Red Top or not) would have been a good fit. It would have made a Corsair II buy instead of the F-111 and Skyhawk a possibility.
The Crusader is an even older design than the Super Tiger and offers lower performance. While the Twosader is a looker with CAC producing the Panther and then Tiger for 15 years the RAAF and RAN would be pretty heavily into US technology and not so interested in the Brit stuff. The RAAF and RAN wouldn’t need a CAC Tiger replacement until the late 60s, early 70s. With the J79 under production in Australia the Vigilante would be more likely as a Canberra replacement. Especially because the much stronger domestic aviation industry of CAC would alleviate the concerns of the Government of early obsolescence via the Vigilante compared to the then TFX. Rather this could be an advantage because they could replace all the Tigers and Vigilantes with a new strike fighter in the Phantom class.
The big question is what would have replaced the Implacables as they reached the end of their service lives during the late 70’s early 80’s. I can not think of a single realistic option.
Well this decision as to the parameters for the new carrier would be closely integrated with the new aircraft to replace the Tiger and Vigilante in the 1970s. Such a decision would have to be made around 1965 in order to define the direction. This would also be when Defence was flushed with cash thanks to the Indonesians and North Vietnamese. There would be a British option but they were rightly seen as an unreliable source of major weapons technology because of their financial and political retraction. Especially as by 1965/66 they had cancelled the aircraft (P.1154) and the carrier (CVA-01). The American option could focus on the F-X (aka F-15) or the VFX (aka F-14). Also for the carrier side the CVV was conceived as a replacement to the Essex class. It grew because someone decided it had to be big enough to fly the F-14 (which kind of made sense since at the time it was the only USN fighter in production). But it was about the same length as the CVA-01 just a bit bigger because it was better designed to operate aircraft.
So with CAC’s close alignment with Grumman the F-14 would be a natural leader. Australian money and involvement could be crucial in helping the F-14B enter production. The F-14A was only a stop-gap, lead-in-production aircraft (only 70 planned to be built) until the definitive F-14B. It had the right engine in place of the TF30, the F401 (a bigger version of the F100), and all digital avionics. The CAC Tomcat could perhaps dispense with the AWG-9 and Phoenix and carry a multi role set of avionics. Like the F-15’s radar integrated with the retractable FLIR turret of the A-6 or S-3. Such an aircraft would be excellent as a centrepiece for both the RAAF and RAN.
Production of both the aircraft and the carrier would be well underway before the election of the Whitlam Government so they would have to proceed with them. Especially as they would all be done in Australia. The new carrier could be built at Whyalla and then fitted out at Cockatoo Island.
It strikes me that this discussion is a bit off topic for most of this thread and even this forum. There is a new what if and modellers forum at:
Beyond The Sprues - Index
We might want to migrate this discussion there? Volkodav and Tasman let me know what you think (PM)?