SHOOOSH thats a secret!;-)but i was told Arunta and now Stuart were going into ER pre upgrade...they would never mothball ships in the RAN to save money...![]()
SHOOOSH thats a secret!;-)but i was told Arunta and now Stuart were going into ER pre upgrade...they would never mothball ships in the RAN to save money...![]()
SHOOOSH thats a secret!;-)
funny that, Forgacs have turned around, BAE (esp Willy) has a lousy reputation.
their reputation is a bit like NGC's in the US when they were in the steel skimmer game...
but i was told Arunta and now Stuart were going into ER pre upgrade...they would never mothball ships in the RAN to save money...![]()
but i was told Arunta and now Stuart were going into ER pre upgrade...they would never mothball ships in the RAN to save money...![]()
Never, look at Kanimbla and Manoora...
Or the other half a dozen or so ships tied up at FBE, which I was quite surprised by, passing by on the Manly fast ferry earlier today...
Tobruk, Success, many FFG's and so on...
![]()
So basically they, with the exception of the period immediately following privatisation and the massive investment in the yard by the federal government leading up to the ANZAC contract, Williamstown have always been a below par ship builder. It appears that current issues are simply the yard returning to type.
Its a strange footbal Williamstown. Was never meant to be a navy yard but due to WWII was built up as one but never enough to meet demand after the war then things went down hill big time in the 60s and 70s with low productivity. It cost a billion $$ back in the 1980s (when a billion was worth 2.7 times it is now) to bring it up to speed and produce two FFGs. For the same cost we could have brought six FFGs from the USA or an all new air wing for a HMAS Australia (24 x SHAR, 12x Sea King).
Yet what for? We had a much better yard at Cockatoo Island. Bigger, better facilities, capable of easy growth to on the level production (no earthworks or shutdown period needed), better worforce, better management, better products. Yet Cockatoo Island is closed down and Williamstown kept sucking in money. Cockatoo could have built the Collins class, Anzacs, AWDs, LHDs even more AORs (as long as no more design drawings written in French). Cockatoo was also right beside the main fleet base. With half the fleet needing seious maintenance would be nice to have 5,000 people working away with multiple dry docks only a few chains away up the harbour.
Just another Australian style management own goal...
On the subject of NGFS I came across this old write up from DID, apparently the Germans toyed with the idea of putting a PZH-2000 turret onto their F125 Frigates but could not make it work,
http://media.defenseindustrydaily.com/images/ORD_Naval_MONARC_PzH-2000_on_F220_Hamburg_lg.jpg
Its a strange footbal Williamstown. Was never meant to be a navy yard but due to WWII was built up as one but never enough to meet demand after the war then things went down hill big time in the 60s and 70s with low productivity. It cost a billion $$ back in the 1980s (when a billion was worth 2.7 times it is now) to bring it up to speed and produce two FFGs. For the same cost we could have brought six FFGs from the USA or an all new air wing for a HMAS Australia (24 x SHAR, 12x Sea King).
Yet what for? We had a much better yard at Cockatoo Island. Bigger, better facilities, capable of easy growth to on the level production (no earthworks or shutdown period needed), better worforce, better management, better products. Yet Cockatoo Island is closed down and Williamstown kept sucking in money. Cockatoo could have built the Collins class, Anzacs, AWDs, LHDs even more AORs (as long as no more design drawings written in French). Cockatoo was also right beside the main fleet base. With half the fleet needing seious maintenance would be nice to have 5,000 people working away with multiple dry docks only a few chains away up the harbour.
Just another Australian style management own goal...
What has happened to that shipyard you are talking about? is still operating? wasnt the HMAS Success built there?
And please forgive this question but, is there any drydock big enough for the LHDs in Australia? I supose there is at least one but where is it?
What has happened to that shipyard you are talking about? is still operating? wasnt the HMAS Success built there?
And please forgive this question but, is there any drydock big enough for the LHDs in Australia? I supose there is at least one but where is it?
No. When was it?Captain Cook Dock at Garden Island should be able to.
Dimension are: 345m x 45m x 14m...
Is it still the largest dock in the southern hemisphere?
No. When was it?
Aha! Sturrock graving dock., Cape Town. Also at Coatec | Sturrock dry dock refurbishment of main de-watering pump New to me, but been there since 1944, so just pipped yours to the post. Damn! And there I was, thinking yours had been the biggest for 20-odd years.
Not much in it, though.
Beat the King George VI dock at Singapore (1938, 303 x 39.6 x 13.1) , but that's 1 degree north, so didn't count anyway. It's not even the biggest dock in that shipyard now.