Royal Australian Navy Discussions and Updates 2.0

The S. Korean is the world's second largest shipbuilder, after China I believe. With that sort of volume of building as well as the number of active yards, the size of the workforce (~125,000) and increasing levels of automation, it is not all that surprising that S. Korea is able to go from first cut to launch for vessels so quickly.
I'm seriously impressed!
 
WRT Arafura, under the then construct, Navy didn’t; it was in the sponge that had the final say. And the execution was CASG. 3 of the offered platforms would have met Navy’s requirements as massaged by the Force Development folks. Nor did Navy negotiate or manage the contract once the source selection was made.
 
WRT Arafura, under the then construct, Navy didn’t; it was in the sponge that had the final say. And the execution was CASG. 3 of the offered platforms would have met Navy’s requirements as massaged by the Force Development folks. Nor did Navy negotiate or manage the contract once the source selection was made.
In plain English for a dumb cluck like me?
 
I was joking about the shipyard. but you are right as we need to get beyond set numbers and programs and have a continuous production line. As I have said before, Japan have worked that out and we need to do the same. There needs to be a bi-partisan approach to budgeting for non stop production.
Start designing the next AWD and commit to a continuous line like the Arleigh Burkes producing updated batches using the same basic hull design and allowing room for growth. Plan for 4 to 6 ships at least with updated versions replacing earlier hulls from the initial run to prevent obsolescence in the fleet. Some of the designs coming out of Europe seem packed to the gills already. There must be room for expansion and adequate power generation for next generation weapons.

Adding in a domestic design capability is another facet as well. It is quite possible for a company to have a build capability without also having a design capability, and by the same token a company can handle ship design, but not actually build them. Gibbs & Cox of the US is an excellent example of a naval architecture firm that does not handle the actual construction itself.

It would be good for Australia to establish at least enough of a design capability to be able to successfully modify or adapt other designs to Australian service conditions and needs. However, such a capability it much like that of domestic shipbuilding, in that once it has been established it needs to be maintained. Sustaining such a capability seems to have been problematic for Australia through various gov'ts over the years.
 
OMT (Odense Maritime Technology) in Denmark. Used to be the design office of Mærsk's shipbuilding subsidiary, Odense Staalskibsværft ("Odense Steel Ships Shipyard"), which closed down in 2012, making me sad, because ancestors of mine used to work in shipbuilding in Odense. The design office was spun off a couple of years earlier.
 
A lot of Australian shipyards aren't built around efficiency, they are built around sustainability. They are dependant on government defence contracts and are not concerned with efficiency. Not just an Australian problem. Most Western nations I expect. China on they otherhand builds at scale.
 
Incat-Crowther is a design office based in Australia, they do some defence work though mainly smaller patrol vessels. Their larger designs are mostly RO-PAX catamarans.

I'm assuming Austral must have some sort of internal design capability of some sort, presumably CIVMEC acquired something when they took over Lurssen local office.

----------------

In my fantasy world the Federal Government (or one of the state governments) would either part own or subsidise a commercial yard capable of building large Tankers, Bulk Carriers and RO-RO vessels.

Basically take a page out of the 1920's & 30's RN and subsidise the construction of vessels which incorporate features that would be beneficial in times of conflict. Add in strengthened sections of deck with power and data connections that could handle RWS, possibly a Helicopter pad and hanger.

They would be owned/operated by commercial operators such as Teekay, BHP & Fortescue under Australian flag registration.

----------------

In the same fantasy world the Australian government would order a Frigate or Destroyer every 6/12 months and they would be sold off at 15 years old to a SEA nation instead of giving them a MLU.
 
Last edited:
A lot of Australian shipyards aren't built around efficiency, they are built around sustainability. They are dependant on government defence contracts and are not concerned with efficiency. Not just an Australian problem. Most Western nations I expect. China on they otherhand builds at scale.

Are you referring to Naval yards, or commercial ones? I ask because AFAIK there is currently only two-ish active yards doing naval construction at present. ASC at Osborne and the Civmec/Austal facility producing the Arafura-class OPV's (assuming that one is including them as naval construction:confused:)

The rest of the yards which remain active are engaged in commercial shipbuilding (employing something like 66% to 75% of Australian shipyard workers) and generally not producing vessels for defence needs. If memory serves, these kinds of shipbuilding activity centre around specialty vessels for the oil & gas industry, commercial fishing vessels and yacht building. Not really sure how much actual ferry building still takes place in Australia, since whilst Austal is an Australian company, it has now established and used yards in the Philippines and Vietnam to build things like fast ferries, rather than facilities in Australia itself. Austal's moves to offshore commercial yard work is one of the reasons why I am not thrilled about their likely involvement in any WA shipbuilding.
 
The requirements are from RAN...
The RAN is not a homogeneous behemoth and they do not have anywhere near the say in setting requirements that many seem to think.

Mid-level public servants seem to get more say than RAN officers, but most seem to be non defence advisors to government.
 
Not really sure how much actual ferry building still takes place in Australia, since whilst Austal is an Australian company, it has now established and used yards in the Philippines and Vietnam to build things like fast ferries, rather than facilities in Australia itself. Austal's moves to offshore commercial yard work is one of the reasons why I am not thrilled about their likely involvement in any WA shipbuilding.

Probably just Incat? They just sent a Battery-Electric Catamaran Ferry off to Uruguay on a heavy lift ship recently.
 
See comments on AUKUS in this CBO report released recently if interested.


See box 2 page 32,33.
CBO's scenarios don't look at the increased availability of submarine operations in the Indo-Pacific facilitated by SRF-West with it's 4x USN SSN's and 1x UK SSN.

In actual fact according to the USN, the presence of SRF-West actually increases the availability of submarines in the Pacific Theatre (even allowing for the reductoion in USN service of 3x SSN's and potentially 5) and even moreso if Australia's intended purchases are added into the equation.
 
Back
Top