Royal Australian Navy Discussions and Updates 2.0

With research into Hypersonic missiles per AUKUS and even ship mounted laser weapons a Hunter class ddg could be formidable ,even the helicopter bay could be assessed for multiple drone storage as per racks
 
It's a lot of weight up high.

Ballast, increased draft and an additional GT to compensate for the weight. An AW ship will need more sensors, not less, so even more top weight.

Volume limits will require the removal of additional ASW systems.

Placing 64 VLS Cells into the Mission Bay area would add elevated weight but that would be significantly offset by the removal of the Mission Bay Handling System and its supporting infrastructure which is very heavy. BAE indicated that the towed sonar may also have to be removed but the design could be transformed into a very good AWD.

Images courtesy of Navy Lookout & Rolls Royce

IMG_0288.jpeg
IMG_0289.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Can’t help thinking that the notion of removing the VDS castrates it to a significant degree.
The loss of such a modern ASW sensor capability in a MFU would be a notable loss in a given task force, especially with the proliferation of submarine assets out there.

A VDS is kinda like the minimum spec for a new build nowadays and into any foreseeable future.
 
Can’t help thinking that the notion of removing the VDS castrates it to a significant degree.
The loss of such a modern ASW sensor capability in a MFU would be a notable loss in a given task force, especially with the proliferation of submarine assets out there.

A VDS is kinda like the minimum spec for a new build nowadays and into any foreseeable future.
Nobody said we had to have the full 8x8 Mk41 cells in the mission bay space, nor the full 4x4 Mk87 canisters for NSM on top as originally depicted. 4x8 or 6x8 additional Mk41 cells and just a 2x4 NSM would surely enable retaining Sonar-2087 in such a large combatant, considering the French, Greek & Swedish FDI can still carry the full fat dual-tow compact version of the CAPTAS-4 at half the size. 80 cells is still plenty.
 
Project of Concern meeting for the Arafura Class OPV this week…

An absolute masterclass in how not to run a project, brought to you by the RAN…

So what’s the go with the OPVs

I thought they were fairly simple vessels of an established design

I understand there was some safety challenges that both Brunei and the RAN were working through but really what’s the story.

Is it engineering or service politics
Bastard child and all.

Is this evolving to be a sell off fleet?

Most confusing

Regards S
 
South Korea just launched their fifth Chungnam Class Frigate. They first cut steel in 2025! How do they do it? If we could build warships even at twice their pace we'd be in a better place.
 
So what’s the go with the OPVs

I thought they were fairly simple vessels of an established design

I understand there was some safety challenges that both Brunei and the RAN were working through but really what’s the story.

Is it engineering or service politics
Bastard child and all.

Is this evolving to be a sell off fleet?

Most confusing

Regards S
What's the story about removing the gun from one of the ships?
 
South Korea just launched their fifth Chungnam Class Frigate. They first cut steel in 2025! How do they do it? If we could build warships even at twice their pace we'd be in a better place.

The S. Korean is the world's second largest shipbuilder, after China I believe. With that sort of volume of building as well as the number of active yards, the size of the workforce (~125,000) and increasing levels of automation, it is not all that surprising that S. Korea is able to go from first cut to launch for vessels so quickly.
 
The S. Korean is the world's second largest shipbuilder, after China I believe. With that sort of volume of building as well as the number of active yards, the size of the workforce (~125,000) and increasing levels of automation, it is not all that surprising that S. Korea is able to go from first cut to launch for vessels so quickly.
Can we transplant one of their yards here? LOl. With our so-called ally having frigate troubles there's the solution.
Now, back to our regular program. What's with our OPVs? Are they going to be armed or not. The program seems to be a cluster****!
 
Last edited:
No, it was Rudd and Faulkner. The option for the fourth, without a renegotiation, expired in October 2008, on the 5th IIRC. I drafted one of the ministerials which tried to exercise it. A fourth could of course have been ordered later, probably up to about 2011 so as to preserve commonality and avoid major equipment unavailability, but we would have then needed to negotiate with Navantia for a licence and ASC/Raytheon for the build. However, after Oct 2008 it was very obvious that the GotD wasn’t interested.
I think we have discussed this before and you have even pointed this out before now you mention it. So bad on me for making you repeat yourself.

And the details you have there are the bit I was really missing. It was a complete new negotiation,

If I ever catch Rudd (not impossible), I will have to ask him about the reasoning behind it. Because ideologically it was against the very line he is pushing very hard now about deterrence. Maybe it was internal politics. Prime ministers aren't dictators, and as we have seen are somewhat at the mercy of the cabinet and their party. It would be great to gleem more into this. I just want to know why. Even after nearly 20 years it still bugs the hell out of me why we only built 3 bloody ships.

I had one or two odd conversations with navy people that seemed to indicate they very much wanted that 4th and industry was crying out for it. Damage to work force, industry, and capability were huge. I don't even think we saved any money by not building it.

Or design our own hull and use the supply chains we established for Hunter and Mogami. It's not rocket science, we have the talent and the whole idea of doing Hunter the way we did it was to build a sovereign ship design and build capability
I think we will certainly have the capability to do that. Japan has future ships being designed and built, we should benchmark them, but IMO I think after mogami and hunter, Australia needs to get back into designing, building and operating its own ships, built around our special needs, and our industry support.
Can we transplant one of their yards here? LOl
Why so can build 3 ships and then tear it all apart.

Japanese and Korean and Chinese yards are so effective because they prioritise build volume.

We still don't have a proper continious ship building program.
 
Can we transplant one of their yards here? LOl. With our so-called having frigate truobles there's the solution.
Now, back to our regular program. What's with our OPVs? Are they going to be armed or not. The program seems to be a cluster****!

Australia could build a yard like S. Korea has if Australia does not already have one comparable or better. However, the physical facility is only part of the solution. The workforce is part of where Australia has struggled, with around 15 to 20k involved in commercial and naval shipbuilding, depending on sources used. The other area where Australia has struggled is having a steady flow of work or projects to utilize said workforce and ensure skill retention.

One of the major reservations I have about SEA 3000 and Australia establishing another/a new naval shipbuilding facility, but now in WA is what happens once the SEA 3000 build winds down, and/or Hunter-class FFG build. Will there be enough work to continue to sustain facilities and workforces in SA and WA?
 
I think we have discussed this before and you have even pointed this out before now you mention it. So bad on me for making you repeat yourself.

And the details you have there are the bit I was really missing. It was a complete new negotiation,

If I ever catch Rudd (not impossible), I will have to ask him about the reasoning behind it. Because ideologically it was against the very line he is pushing very hard now about deterrence. Maybe it was internal politics. Prime ministers aren't dictators, and as we have seen are somewhat at the mercy of the cabinet and their party. It would be great to gleem more into this. I just want to know why. Even after nearly 20 years it still bugs the hell out of me why we only built 3 bloody ships.

I had one or two odd conversations with navy people that seemed to indicate they very much wanted that 4th and industry was crying out for it. Damage to work force, industry, and capability were huge. I don't even think we saved any money by not building it.


I think we will certainly have the capability to do that. Japan has future ships being designed and built, we should benchmark them, but IMO I think after mogami and hunter, Australia needs to get back into designing, building and operating its own ships, built around our special needs, and our industry support.

Why so can build 3 ships and then tear it all apart.

Japanese and Korean and Chinese yards are so effective because they prioritise build volume.

We still don't have a proper continious ship building program.
I was joking about the shipyard. but you are right as we need to get beyond set numbers and programs and have a continuous production line. As I have said before, Japan have worked that out and we need to do the same. There needs to be a bi-partisan approach to budgeting for non stop production.
Start designing the next AWD and commit to a continuous line like the Arleigh Burkes producing updated batches using the same basic hull design and allowing room for growth. Plan for 4 to 6 ships at least with updated versions replacing earlier hulls from the initial run to prevent obsolescence in the fleet. Some of the designs coming out of Europe seem packed to the gills already. There must be room for expansion and adequate power generation for next generation weapons.
 
Back
Top