If these two aircraft can meet all of the RAAF's fixed wing transport requirements, along with high and low speed IFR tanker roles, it seems to make sense but I wonder if there is a 'middle' area where the C-17 would be too large and the LTFWA too small.
What percentage of C-130 missions could be picked up by the C-17 at the top end and the C-27 or C-295 at the other? Would there be a case to retain a three aircraft fixed wing transport force, with an additional 4 C-17s replacing the remaining C-130Hs and sufficient LTFWA to replace the Caribous along with some C-130H missions? This would provide a force of approx 8 C-17s, 12 C-130Js and how ever many LTFWA aircraft are needed to meet the remaining fixed wing tactical requirements.
Tas