Not a breach of contract, just an insult to the time and effort put in when responding.
IIRC The original date was to be 2014 , The RFI was against a set of criteria, this was all thrown out and another aircraft all together was selected in 2002 (the JSF).
Now which set of criteria did the JSF meet?.... considering it was a paper plane at that time? first flight was in 2006!! and that wasn't even a production representative variant!. so it was judged against aspirational targets..:unknown
JSF deliveries in 2014-2020 timeframe.. that should have gone straight into basket 3
As for the SH it may have some training commonality with the current hornets, but I can't see it vastly exceeding the Typhoon in capability and I believe an attempt should have been made to fully compare several alternatives.
As I recall the Royal Australian Air force wasn't even aware they required an interim aircraft!!, let alone actively accessing alternatives, its a ministerial decision as far as i can tell with no interference from the experts.
I'm happy that the current governments review is going ahead, as Brendon Nelson can't quite explain why or how he arrived at the decision!.
People in Australia should give a damn.. its my tax money there spending..
A polite question.
Are you quite sure that there was no information in the public arena - surely the manufacturer publishes some specifications - that would have caused those making the decision to take it off the "possible" list?
You usually don't look at the public arena to judge capability, some figures publically published for the Typhoon are way out, its more usual to get a brief from the vendor and then get your pilots to have a play with it to see if it does what it claimed, this takes quite some time.
Deliver was a problem for Typhoon before about 2014 but the selection of another aircraft taht was supposed to be available in that time frame does not seem to be a bar to selection!.
Cheers