A few corrections. The MiG-35K does not exist. You're conflagrating the MiG-29K and MiG-35 both of which are new-built..
Yes, I meant the MiG-29K. Thanks.
A few corrections. The MiG-35K does not exist. You're conflagrating the MiG-29K and MiG-35 both of which are new-built..
Sure some of those countries have quality assistance from Russia (Algeria comes to mind) but let's be frank here. Rather than retiring the MiGs, why no the Hornets? We can't even use the Hornets except to show the public that we have shiny American fighter jets! Our Hornets couldn't even fire a missile on ACCIDENT seeing as the source code is locked and we don't have access to those because the American's won't let us have em! (Or so I've been told. I did remember that Mahathir did make a statement on it, it's on YouTube, feel free to find it)
Yes, it was a bit of shocking news to me really. The RMAF wants to retire their MiG-29s. I completely believe this to be a case of imbecility and stupidity that so blatantly plagues my beloved country's government. The reason behind it was so stupid! To save on maintenance costs! The magnitude of such stupidity could only be equated to the poor excuses often made by the Communist Party of the Soviet Union to cover their own asses in politics!
While the MiG 29K/MiG 35's would not share the same weakness of the MiG 29's
Are you sure on this? Does the RD-33MK engine and Zhuk-ME radar have a much higher time between overhaul than the RD-33 and NO19M Topaz ? In terms of mantainance hours,
how does the RD-33MK compare to the GE F404-GE402? There were some figures about this on an Indian blog, I'll try to look it up. Don't get me wrong here, I'm not anti-Russian or against Russian products. I firmly believe that for an air arm like the RMAF, which has traditionaly operated Western gear, a new operating/mantainance philosophy and procedures have to adopted to operate russian gear. Then again, this is just my opinion, I'm far from being any kind of expert.
Ergonomically, while I'm assuming that the glass cockpit of the MiG-29K is a big improvement over the MiG-29N, how it does compare to the cockpits on the Super Hornet or Gripen?
The RMAF, like the Malaysian Armed Forces as a whole, faces particular problems relating to government policy. The government mandates foreign defence procurements must be done via registered Bumiputera companies owned by Malays. This means new equipment and spare-part acquisitions must be done through local middlemen, their commission duly adding to the cost. The end result is a lack of spares and support equipment due to artificially inflated prices and a lack of funds. Furthermore, these brokers do nothing to advance offsets that would help the local defence industry. A problem peculiar to the TUDM is a mix of Western and Russian aircraft that does little to simplify the logistics chain.
Have these Migs completed their service life, when were they procured ?
I was kinda sad too when the decision was made, but have come to accept that the RMAF cant be maintaining too many different types. .
The deal now seems to be at replacing the MiG's for 6 additional MKM's which seems good to me. .
Plus eventually I think even the Hornets's should be retired as they too are aging and too limited in quantity. Their roles can be performed by the MKM's anyways. .
The MAF should look at a future MRCA that is light and can replace the roles of the MiG's/Hornets and complement the MKM's in a network centric warfare..
ON the MiG's i think it was foolish political decisions that killed it. No proper maintenance or support was created for the plane when they pruchased it, and they allowed the mutiple local vendors to supply parts, which is shocking, as the only means of these silly companies to survive is by inflating their services rendered, while not contributing in the least to the nations defence. .
I think this is no longer true with the MKM's situation which should rightly be so..
I also think Russia today is a more reliable defence supplier and they have cleaned up their act , with proper support contracts for their new line of flankers and MiG's. Plus their newer planes have longer TBO compared to the soviet era built hardware. .
The craft looked in decent condition. Have these Migs completed their service life, when were they procured ?
also think Russia today is a more reliable defence supplier and they have cleaned up their act , with proper support contracts for their new line of flankers and MiG's. Plus their newer planes have longer TBO compared to the soviet era built hardware. While the MiG 29K/MiG 35's would not share the same weakness of the MiG 29's i do not think they are suitable for our MRCA needs now. We should look at a western platform that can complement the MKM's.
IIRC, these refurbished MiGs were procured in 1995 and they should have plenty of hours left before end of life (which is why they are being offered for resale). One of the problems faced is the maintenance cost for the small fleet.
So are the fighters on offer to any particular nation/ Or has anyone expressed interest in acquiring them. The Migs if procured first hand in 1995 have got atleast 10-11 years more given a service life of 25 yrs and if maintained properly then can be upgraded (very costly these days though) and used for maybe 10 more years
I remember going to Russians booths at defence shows in the 90's, the people there looked bored and were only too happy if you didn't ask any questions. Most of the time English was a problem, if you asked too many questions, you'd get a poster or brochures and they would walk away pretending to be busy.
With the MKMs is still early days, only time will tell how well they'll do as far as servicibility goes.
Plus eventually I think even the Hornets's should be retired as they too are aging and too limited in quantity. Their roles can be performed by the MKM's anyways.
One of the good things about MKM is that, we share a lot of commonality with the Indian MKI. since India will build the aircraft locally, that means we can turn to India for many of the parts in case the Russian fail to deliver. The same happen with our RF-5E when US refuse to sell us the parts needed. we decided to turn to the Swiss,
Plus both India and China is capable of providing spares if things get tough, which i dont think will happen coz the Russians are getting serious about their product image.
On the Hornets, I dont see a future for them, whether or not they have a 100% readiness rate. So what do u do with 8 hornets?
The new Najib administration does really mean business and being a former defence minister, he I believe can see the problems faced by the MAF and doing all he can to mend the ways the nations defence is carried out. Perhaps if you take some time reading about this on the Malaysian newspapers online, you would have known about it.
India and China can provide certain spares but for radar and engine parts and troubleshooting, I think the RMAF will still have to rely on the Russians. As part of the support intrasructure established for their MKMIs and MKKs, does anyone know if the IAF and PLAAF have the capability to perform engine overhauls? In July 2009 the PO Ural Optical and Mechanical Plant was awarded a contract to spares to the RMAF.