We should also have 3 Antarctic OPVs, much like the VARD 7-100-ICE-AOPV that will enable us to handle the Southern Ocean and Antarctic Ocean ice.
Nor me. It looks as if it's not been published.Anyone know the stipulated Mogami range? Can't seem to find it anywhere.
IMO NZ has the opposite problem to Australia.
They simply don't spend enough to sustain the desired capability, even though the have been very smart on acquisition and operate extremely professionally.
We on the other hand have made bad procurements and acquisitions, spend huge sums of money and still cut capability.
i asked a stupid question in google and this is what came backAnyone know the stipulated Mogami range? Can't seem to find it anywhere.
Are you suggesting something along the lines of the Fassmer 120 MPV crew 60 plus 240 grunts about 6000 tonnMaybe instead of OPVs NZ should look at the OPV role being undertaken by a multirole ship such as a modern APD (assault transport), with an OPV systems fitout, but designed for installation of corvette or frigate level systems if required.
Instead of frigates, invest in a multi role aviation ship with significant C3I and a frigate sensor / weapons suite. This ship could operate the MRH as well as what ever replaces the SuperSeaSprite, with accommodation for an infantry company.
i asked a stupid question in google and this is what came back
Gives it a range of 8000nm I have no idea where the info came from or for that matter if it is correct.
Edit cancel my last that info applies to a Heavy Cruiser from the 30's
Why.What is the strategic imperitive? why would China ever wish to invade NZ?
The only answer I can surmise is, if the Chinese invaded Oz to secure much needed resources and they thought that NZ provided a base for an allied counter offensive, they may consider neutralising NZ and then 16 RNZAF F 16s might be an annoyance.
But this scenario is deeply in la la land.
I have been quietly following this thread and the arguments for and against reintroducing an ACF.
It seems the main reason advocates for an ACF use is, for want of a better term, “invasion of the homeland”.
What is the strategic imperitive? why would China ever wish to invade NZ?
The only answer I can surmise is, if the Chinese invaded Oz to secure much needed resources and they thought that NZ provided a base for an allied counter offensive, they may consider neutralising NZ and then 16 RNZAF F 16s might be an annoyance.
But this scenario is deeply in la la land.
Therefore, let NZ use its treasure and manpower on more useful endeavours many of which have been proposed here, AEW, Frigates and Maritime surveillance (P8 and drones).
But this scenario is deeply in la la land.
I would disagree with you on the logistics. Due to our current lack of defence ability, most of the logistics could be achieved with current commercial ships or aircraft, as we would have no current way of stopping this from happening and any initial wouldn't have to be of any significant size, simply take control of the port of your choice, preferably with a good size airport and run from there.I have never seen the Air Combat Force as a requirement to defeat an invasion. Simply put the logistics in trying to mount an invasion on NZ, make it near but not impossible to achieve.
I can’t see any strategic benefit for NZ in allocating scarce resources to an ACF.ASSAIL, I'm surprised this highly unlikely scenario is your take-away from this discussion.
I'm assuming that in the short term, if NZ rediscovers its responsibilities as a nation and neighbour, then the increasing of existing scarce resources such as P-8A and FFG are a priority. In the medium term, especially with a traditional Western maritime nations perspectives, and for the same reasons as why RAAF has enhanced combat capability over the past few years, then we might quickly identify that RNZAF Air Power has a key role to play and find suitable ways to reestablish this mission over time.
To look at EW or large UAS specialist platforms may be too niche when the nation wants maximum balance and capabilities from a small force. The ACF missions are universally consistent whether they are in direct defence of NZ (least likely), contributing to a long term JTF in PNG or NW Australia (certainly possible), or part of a small Coalition operation (very likely). The ACF capabilities provide speed, firepower, and flexibility. With suitable aircraft like F-35s multiple roles can be flown ISO the physical, kinetic, requirements of the nation of NZ. These unique characteristics are what NZG has lost and why, if professionally assessed, they could be resurrected.
I can’t see any strategic benefit for NZ in allocating scarce resources to an ACF.
In all the JTF examples you quote, greater advantage would be gained (at lower cost) by the RNZAF contributing tactical airlift, surveillance and other capabilities already in service and expanded.
It’s a cost benefit proposition, what will the NZDF forgo in acquiring an ACF? The RNZN perhaps?
I would disagree with you on the logistics. Due to our current lack of defence ability, most of the logistics could be achieved with current commercial ships or aircraft, as we would have no current way of stopping this from happening and any initial wouldn't have to be of any significant size, simply take control of the port of your choice, preferably with a good size airport and run from there.