Being a hypothetical, there is much unknown here. It's unprecedented. But I think it also misses an important context - when Israel negotiated peace with Syria back in the 2000's for example, one of the demands was no Iranian presence on Syrian soil. Likewise, Israel is highly likely to demand something similar of Lebanon in the current and following negotiations if they extend to peace talks.
So in any realistic case, such presence would in itself be in violation of the peace agreement.
I'll use Syria as an example once again. If Iran's military presence in Syria is used, for example, to rearm Hezbollah in Lebanon, then that could certainly be constructed as a military threat and violation of an agreement.
In that case, Israel could, as in the Assad precedent, request Syria to remove Iran's presence on its own (with a deadline), or in the less likely case inform Syria that it will remove Iran's presence and de-conflict so that Israeli and Syrian military assets do not shoot at each other.
During ISIS's peak of popularity, its Sinai branch fired missiles at the Israeli city Eilat. Although a breach of the peace agreement, it did not break down, and Israel and Egypt coordinated to remove the threat, including with Israeli airstrikes on Egyptian soil and deconfliction with Egyptian forces.
Again interesting aside but it doesn't address the argument I'm making.
What time period are you referring to? I can only assume you mean the IAI Searcher (Forpost) sale to Russia, which at the time was dwarfed by other western arms sales to Russia, including an entire French Mistral LHD whose sale was only cancelled at the last moment. Israel was not the exception back then. West-Russia relations were much less hostile back then.
In the mid-'00s Russia didn't sell Iskanders to Syria on Israeli request. After the events of '14, Israel didn't sell tech to Ukraine on Russia's request. Post '14 Israel continued to not only sell UAVs to Russia but Elbit system had set up shop in the Urals to work at the Ural Civil Aviation Plant to produce the Forpost-RU, the very same that's currently bombing Ukrainian forces near Sudzha. That joint cooperation started around 2011, but continued well beyond '14 and iirc sometime around '18 they were still doing it. Do you know when they stopped? I sure don't.
Yes, actually.
Israel and Iran were also mutually hostile post-revolution, yet they cooperated against the Iraqi nuclear program.
But the comparison with the USSR-USA is a bad one. USA-USSR were each other's main adversaries. For Israel, that would be Iran. Russia ceased to be a major adversary after the USSR collapsed, and even before that when peace with Egypt and Jordan was negotiated and Soviet/Russian presence at Israel's borders was reduced to just a fraction of the past.
A closer comparison would be the US preferring Iran take over a certain area from the USSR, as Iran was not nearly as important an adversary.
But another difference here is that the US is a superpower with global reach. Israel is not. Its resources are limited, and just defending its borders takes up significant treasure and manpower, far beyond what western nations would typically accept.
I don't believe Russia is any kind of adversary for Israel at this point. Russia and Israel deconflicted over Syria quickly and efficiently, and Israel went out of their way to cooperate with Russia. Russia on the other hand allowed Israel quite a bit of freedom in striking targets inside Syria without Russian interference, and limited Syrian IADS capabilities to minimize threats to Israel. Those are not the actions of adversaries. Consider Israel's public statements. Do they call Russia an adversary? It seems to me you want to have this idea of Axis vs Allies and put Israel on the "Allies" side so you push this idea but it doesn't line up with reality. Arguing that Alawite civilians shouldn't be protected because they're untrustworthy because Assad worked with Russia is hypocritical in the extreme.
Because, as I explained, there is no reason to get kinetic over things. Hostile actions are kept at a low. Israel sells arms to Europe. Russia sells arms to Israel's adversaries, including Hezbollah, and invests in political influence campaigns across the west, including in Israel.
It's not like Israel and Russia are neutral to one another. It's more hostile than friendly.
It's another way to say they're not adversaries. Just not friends either. It's not one or another.
Tell me, do you honestly believe the Alawites generally see Israel favorably and would accept an alliance?
This is an absurd question. If they don't favor such an alliance, they should be exterminated by jihadis?
What do you find wrong about this statement?
If you really can't figure that out, I don't think I can help you.
There are also clashes in Jenin between PA security forces, local terrorist orgs, and Hamas. All of them consider Israel an enemy, and all are terrorist organizations. So when they kill each other, just because there are civilians being murdered by them, it somehow makes the local civilian populations view Israel favorably? No. It won't.
Who cares how they view Israel? What does this have to do with the statement I made?
My first response in the forum (I wrote much more on Twitter) on the subject was:
"I hate the IRGC and Assadists as much as everyone else, but this brutality is meant to signal to us that they're (HTS) just Assadists 2.0.
Like I said on the day it happened (HTS revolution) - I'm happy for the Syrians who feel like they've been liberated, and at the same time Jolani is still the ISIS longbeard he always was. "
In a wider look at the region, Alawites have multiple options to choose from as protectors, and given sentiment toward Israel in the region - Israel is an unlikely option. Is that a wrong assessment?
Alawites have no choices whatsoever. They live under an authoritarian regime in a semi-failed state.
If so, why do you believe Alawites would prefer Israeli support over Russian, Iranian, or Turkish?
Who said anything about Israeli support? Other then you of course...
Israel is not the middle east's police. Nor is it anyone's cultural parent.
It doesn't have the resources to intervene on everyone's behalf. One tribe massacring another is called "ethnic cleansing" in the west, and "Monday" in the middle east.
It intervened in Druze and Kurds' favor because they've proven valuable allies in the past.
If the EU and US decided they want Israel to take up that role and finance the relevant expenses - I'm all for it. Really. But when our own security challenges take budgetary precedent, I don't see that happening. I certainly don't see the EU supporting Israel in such an endeavor, especially with their unique interests in Syria.
This thread isn't called "Israel and Israeli business". It's called Middle East Defence & Security. I regard the murder of Alawite civilians in particular, and mass murder of civilians of any kind in general, to be reprehensible, and would like to see some actions taken to address it by the gaggle of counrties that have all stuck their grubby hands into Syria over the past 15 years. They all bear some portion of responsibility. I don't know why you assume I'm calling for Israel to form a military alliance with some sort of Assadist Alawite movement. You seem to be responding to something other than what I wrote. So far the only country that has done something to assist the civilians is Russia, but not because they wanted to. They got no choice when throngs of civilians turned up at the base. It's not like the Russian base is set up for riot control. They get very little credit for that. Everyone else gets less.



