Australian Army Discussions and Updates

To be fair, AFAIK it's a unique case.
I was aware of it, I just didn't realise it had retained so much amphibious capability. I checked it out after your response and it is impressive.

Basically, going forward, medium navies like Australia should ensure every crewed ship has at least a mission bay and multi layered defences. Idealy there should also be large, medium and small ships specialising in drone fabrication and operation.
 
Australia considers US variant of Israel's Iron Dome to protect military bases from missile attacks

Back to LAND 6504

There are a bunch or articles like the above link, indicating the ADF requested pricing for MIRC, patriot and an Aegis based system (presumably derringer). NASAMS (I assume upgraded with at least AMRAAM-ER), and interestingly the Korean L SAM are aparently in the mix.

I get the second two, but why would we be interested in MIRC (based on the Israeli Tamir) missile system, it seems to be a similar capability to NASAMS (with AMRAAM-ER), and doesn't have any capability in the balistic missile protection.

Seperately, I wonder if Derringer could be integrated with the Kongsberg FDS used with NASAMS. It would make for a more compact and seamless package, with one system managing it all. I know Aegis is already configured for SM2, but given the standard missile family is made by the same company that makes the AIM120 and AIM9, I would have thought it was achievable with minimal effort.

How good would NASAMS be with SM2, and a future pathway to SM6 and even SM3.
 
Australia considers US variant of Israel's Iron Dome to protect military bases from missile attacks

Back to LAND 6504

There are a bunch or articles like the above link, indicating the ADF requested pricing for MIRC, patriot and an Aegis based system (presumably derringer). NASAMS (I assume upgraded with at least AMRAAM-ER), and interestingly the Korean L SAM are aparently in the mix.

I get the second two, but why would we be interested in MIRC (based on the Israeli Tamir) missile system, it seems to be a similar capability to NASAMS (with AMRAAM-ER), and doesn't have any capability in the balistic missile protection.

Seperately, I wonder if Derringer could be integrated with the Kongsberg FDS used with NASAMS. It would make for a more compact and seamless package, with one system managing it all. I know Aegis is already configured for SM2, but given the standard missile family is made by the same company that makes the AIM120 and AIM9, I would have thought it was achievable with minimal effort.

How good would NASAMS be with SM2, and a future pathway to SM6 and even SM3.
I suspect the strategy is an overlapping series of systems.

Something like the “iron dome” where shorter and longer ranged systems are paired to maximise each’s strengths and minimise weakmess.

For example MRIC and Patriot working together.

Why this wouldn’t be NASAM’s and Patriot I am uncertain, but ADF is reputedly interested according to media reports.
 
I suspect the strategy is an overlapping series of systems.

Something like the “iron dome” where shorter and longer ranged systems are paired to maximise each’s strengths and minimise weakmess.

For example MRIC and Patriot working together.

Why this wouldn’t be NASAM’s and Patriot I am uncertain, but ADF is reputedly interested according to media reports.
Sold! we will take 6 of each.......and 10 missiles!.....no 20!
 
It has $10b in funding, Ukraine just ordered 500x PAC-3 MSE’s for $2.1b (AUD no

Paid for by European countries & Canada. Won't arrive for a while, because production's much less than demand.
Sure, would have been wonderful if they stuck with FSP2020 plans for this capability from an industrial POV, but the point is, our funding clearly allows for a substantial inventory of interceptors.
 
Having the money isn't the problem.

LockMart has a $52.5 Billion USD backlog on orders for PAC-3 MSE, with a production capacity of ~600 missiles/year, increasing to 2,000 year by 2030.

If $2.1 Billion USD gets you 500 missiles, $52.5 Billion gets you ~12,500. Even at 2,000 units/ year it will take over 6 years to clear the backlog and they aren't due to hit that target until 2030.

An order placed now isn't going to be delivered until well after 2030.
 
Having the money isn't the problem.

LockMart has a $52.5 Billion USD backlog on orders for PAC-3 MSE, with a production capacity of ~600 missiles/year, increasing to 2,000 year by 2030.

If $2.1 Billion USD gets you 500 missiles, $52.5 Billion gets you ~12,500. Even at 2,000 units/ year it will take over 6 years to clear the backlog and they aren't due to hit that target until 2030.

An order placed now isn't going to be delivered until well after 2030.
What would be very interesting is if Australian soveriegn capability is expanded to include local production. We could offset early deliveries in exchange for adding to global production capacity.
 
I really can't help but feel these army ships are two decades too late and have been overtaken by events.

The war in Ukraine, or more to the point, the Black Sea raises serious questions about their survivability.

Their payloads will be defenceless in transit unless escorted by at least a GPF. Yes, there are fantasy Arafura class star destroyers and Cape class battle cruisers, but realistically, there are not enough escorts to go around.

The more I think on it, the more I am certain we need a modern day APD, with a minimum GPF level sensor and weapons suite, supporting LPDs with DDG level weapons and sensors. When not deploying, or maybe while deploying, army long range fires, to remote locations, they could concurrently provide sea control and sea denial capability. This could be with their own onboard CS, but also through deployable and accompanying uncrewed platforms.

Then again maybe a digger wearing a slouch hat, a fag hanging out of his mouth, firing a MAG 58 from his hip will be enough.
 
LCM started construction in September, in service 2028 apparently.
LCH also started construction this month(November) and will be delivered in 2029.

Defence images





Austal image of the additional facilities required to build LCH, south of the cube, out front of the ex silveryachts facility.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_4334.jpeg
    IMG_4334.jpeg
    492.7 KB · Views: 16
Last edited:
I really can't help but feel these army ships are two decades too late and have been overtaken by events.

The war in Ukraine, or more to the point, the Black Sea raises serious questions about their survivability.

Their payloads will be defenceless in transit unless escorted by at least a GPF. Yes, there are fantasy Arafura class star destroyers and Cape class battle cruisers, but realistically, there are not enough escorts to go around.

The more I think on it, the more I am certain we need a modern day APD, with a minimum GPF level sensor and weapons suite, supporting LPDs with DDG level weapons and sensors. When not deploying, or maybe while deploying, army long range fires, to remote locations, they could concurrently provide sea control and sea denial capability. This could be with their own onboard CS, but also through deployable and accompanying uncrewed platforms.

Then again maybe a digger wearing a slouch hat, a fag hanging out of his mouth, firing a MAG 58 from his hip will be enough.
Funnily enough, when drafting the original needs statement that led to this, I asked the exact same questions. Not particularly healthy for a career as I found out...

It steps into Army's wider failing at the moment - having a clear idea on what is the fight that they are likely to face. The arguments against the escort / AD need (it operates in the littoral and hence is masked by land) fail because it brings the boats (boats? ships?) into the very terrain that Ukraine has shown a low threat can kill ships. I'm quite leary of those who saw "Ukraine shows this and so we must match it" because our operating environment is very different. But playing through the littorals? That removes the range and weather differences.

They will be useful, I'll never say no to useful air or sea lift. But I don't think they'll operate as free of the fleet as AHQ thinks.
 
I really can't help but feel these army ships are two decades too late and have been overtaken by events.

The war in Ukraine, or more to the point, the Black Sea raises serious questions about their survivability.

Their payloads will be defenceless in transit unless escorted by at least a GPF. Yes, there are fantasy Arafura class star destroyers and Cape class battle cruisers, but realistically, there are not enough escorts to go around.

The more I think on it, the more I am certain we need a modern day APD, with a minimum GPF level sensor and weapons suite, supporting LPDs with DDG level weapons and sensors. When not deploying, or maybe while deploying, army long range fires, to remote locations, they could concurrently provide sea control and sea denial capability. This could be with their own onboard CS, but also through deployable and accompanying uncrewed platforms.

Then again maybe a digger wearing a slouch hat, a fag hanging out of his mouth, firing a MAG 58 from his hip will be enough.
Hi Volk

Please clarify a APD.

All for sea lift, but also have concerns with the LCM / LCH vessel concept going forward.

Cheers S
 
Hi Volk

Please clarify a APD.

All for sea lift, but also have concerns with the LCM / LCH vessel concept going forward.

Cheers S
Older destroyers and new build destroyer escorts, converted into assault transports during WWII, for launching raids, resupplying deployed forces, embarking and supporting special forces, raiding forces, recon teams, surveillance teams strike forces etc.

The RAN used they fast mine layers in a similar manner.

The ships retained their surface and AA guns, but gave up their torpedos for landing craft on davits.

They proved very useful and versatile, including naval gunfire support, as adding to task force defences.

They basically were a self-escorting amphibious assault ship with a re-enforced company lift. Imagine a GPF sized modern equivalent with a ramp launched and recovered LCM or LCU and a mission deck?

Such a ship could also serve as the basis of a drone mothership.

 
Last edited:
Older destroyers and new build destroyer escorts, converted into assault transports during WWII, for launching raids, resupplying deployed forces, embarking and supporting special forces, raiding forces, recon teams, surveillance teams strike forces etc.

The RAN used they fast mine layers in a similar manner.

The ships retained their surface and AA guns, but gave up their torpedos for landing craft on davits.

They proved very useful and versatile, including naval gunfire support, as adding to task force defences.

They basically were a self-escorting amphibious assault ship with a re-enforced company lift. Imagine a GPF sized modern equivalent with a ramp launched and recovered LCM or LCU and a mission deck?

Such a ship could also serve as the basis of a drone mothership.

Ok thanks
More of Absalon class than a gunned up LPD.

The LCM and LCH will be fine in peace and where we have complete over match against some small neighbours, but really I cannot see there utility in a larger conflict.
Agree these 26 new vessels will need escorts we just don’t have.
This is an expensive project that for similar money could have provided some very different vessels.
A trade off in numbered for much bigger ships could have provided similar lift with a ship having some significant self defence, true organic aviation facilities and offering a greater range of capabilities.

A bigger ship with connectors

C’est la vie, the deal is done

Cheers S
 
Back
Top