The Russian-Ukrainian War Thread

I actually agree that the river (Dnepr/Dnipro) would constitute a “perfect”/equilibrium border and commented so long time ago (maybe more than once). Problems:
- How do you get there?
- Why?
- What happens if you start losing Belarus, where is the “perfect” border then? And so on.
Somehow, many (I would argue most “successful”) countries don’t have these “perfect” perceived borders and manage to live somehow and mostly happily so. Not without occasional troubles, of course. I should probably cut short here in order not to contradict my usual Russian propaganda proprogramming
Well if you think the Dnepr is the perfect border, I have good news for you. It runs through Belarus and into Russia, in iirc Smolensk region. So presumably that's where it would be. That having been said, perfect borders tend to be nonsense. In a few places around the world geography lines up relatively neatly but in many more it doesn't. I think the better question is, equilibrium between whom? What are we even trying to balance with this theoretical exercise?

Realistically I think currently the deal that makes sense territorially is for Russia to hand over what they hold in Khrakov and Sumy in exchange for Ukraine handing over territory to the administrative borders of Donetsk and Lugansk region and that becomes the international border. This recognizes realities in the ground, resolves the political question of "liberating the Donbas" and pushes Russia away from Sumy and Khar'kov. But based on recent statements I don't think the sides are ready to end the war yet.
 
BTW, Putin's changed his mind about peace in Ukraine. He now demands that NATO must remove forces & infrastructure from some of the former Warsaw Pact countries which are now NATO members as part of any agreement.

Obviously, he's not negotiating in good faith. He's demanding defences must be dismantled. Remind anyone of Sudetenland & Polish Corridor?
 
BTW, Putin's changed his mind about peace in Ukraine. He now demands that NATO must remove forces & infrastructure from some of the former Warsaw Pact countries which are now NATO members as part of any agreement.

Obviously, he's not negotiating in good faith. He's demanding defences must be dismantled. Remind anyone of Sudetenland & Polish Corridor?

Thats interesting and concerning if true. I read it was one of the variants under discussion and included arrangements for the withdrawal of Russian forces from Transnestria and Moldava granting independence referendums to Transnestria and Gagauzia in the event of EU membership.
 
If you started watching the video, you may have understood (no guarantees though). Expand to full screen on mobile for better viewing experience.
I'm sorry but I have no desire to watch a youtube video, I'm sure that if you have a point a simple multi page wall of text should make it clear
 
I don't have general businessmen or commoners on mind. But the ones at the very top, that have been pulling the strings for a long, long time. The descendants of those who financed communists living outside of Russia, prior to the 1917 Revolution, with the same idea of ruining the Russia (which communism succeeded for about a century).

And as I stated, the "invading the neighbors thing" is in Russian minds probably "Let's get them before they get us". Russia with Ukrainians included barely survived 2 great western invasions, both the greatest invasions yet in known history at the point. With Ukrainians on the other side now chances for the (inevitable in their minds) future go slim so let's take at least half Ukrainians with us and put that border at the huge Dnieper. That's how I see their logic. And as a matter of fact something like 70% of Ukrainians east of Dnieper wouldn't mind that much, at least that's how their voting pretty much went for years.
Perhaps you mean Highlander?
 
BTW, Putin's changed his mind about peace in Ukraine. He now demands that NATO must remove forces & infrastructure from some of the former Warsaw Pact countries which are now NATO members as part of any agreement.

Obviously, he's not negotiating in good faith. He's demanding defences must be dismantled. Remind anyone of Sudetenland & Polish Corridor?
Negotiating in good faith? That is like shooting yourself in the foot. Maximize your demands and then, graciously, cede...
At the same time, he is asking, or allowing, the EU at the table.
 
How many countries have invaded Russia since the 2nd World War? How many countries has Russia invaded since then? Why are Russian's confused when European countries join NATO.
Well, I more than a bit confused here.
Why after WW2? Why those before don't count, any reason for that? There was a League of Nations before that, there were international treaties before that. I think that the concepts of good, evil and interests existed long before that.
How many countries have been invaded not by Russia, even after WW2?
Only invasion counts? If Russia had been bombing Ukraine since 2022, that would be "all right" for you?
I would use "angry", maybe "threatened" or "uneasy" about Russians, not confused. (Do you think that people in Latin America are confused about a coup d'etat organized by the US? Again, do military interventions count?)

Is it some kind of dogma about Russia or another case of "cognitive dissonance"?
 
Talking about negotiations, maybe we (and Zelenski) should remember this, for 2027, 2028 and, maybe, 2030:
There is a realpolitik reality: any deal that can get Russia on board will look unfavourable to the Ukrainians. But within reason the Ukrainians will have to come to terms with something that may be second best to a deal they would have wanted two years ago, another European diplomat said. That is just where we are. CNN April 24, 2025.
 
Well, I more than a bit confused here.
Why after WW2? Why those before don't count, any reason for that? There was a League of Nations before that, there were international treaties before that. I think that the concepts of good, evil and interests existed long before that.
How many countries have been invaded not by Russia, even after WW2?
Only invasion counts? If Russia had been bombing Ukraine since 2022, that would be "all right" for you?
I would use "angry", maybe "threatened" or "uneasy" about Russians, not confused. (Do you think that people in Latin America are confused about a coup d'etat organized by the US? Again, do military interventions count?)

Is it some kind of dogma about Russia or another case of "cognitive dissonance"?
I thought I was being gracious but if you want you can go back to the Soviet Union or USSR fill your boots.
 
I thought I was being gracious but if you want you can go back to the Soviet Union or USSR fill your boots.
Did you graciously make a side-by-side comparison of invasions (/interventions)? AI could be really useful for that.

I still don't know why only after WW2. It doesn't fit in your fairy tale vision of reality?

Edit
Kurgan started with something like "invading neighbours", a common occurrence before and after WW2, not a Russian pastime.
 
Last edited:
Did you graciously make a side-by-side comparison of invasions (/interventions)? AI could be really useful for that.

I still don't know why only after WW2. It doesn't fit in your fairy tale vision of reality?
Perhaps because the current international order with its norms, expectations and realities was shaped by and established largely after WW2, including some pretty major territorial changes at least in Europe.
 
Perhaps because the current international order with its norms, expectations and realities was shaped by and established largely after WW2, including some pretty major territorial changes at least in Europe.
I think "current" is the key word, as the Congress of Vienna was the current expectation then, but reality keeps changing. Hungary, Egypt and Grenada were invaded, but there was no change in their borders. That would be the difference, that Russia wants to change the border in this occasion, not that there has been an invasion.
 
the Russians believe that NATO is chiefly to blame. countless warnings about NATO expansion ignored, relentless efforts to regime change Russian friendly governments from the middle east to eastern Europe.

NATO and all their intelligence services need to pack up and leave Ukraine for peace to reign, in the absence of that, Ukraine will lose everything east of the Dnieper river including Odesa, if you are thinking Russia will stop so that what ever is left of Ukraine, will rearm, rebuild and remain a threat to Russia then you are not serious for peace
This post caught my interest and was why I responded about Russian invasions or interventions as @resemmes would rather kindly put them.
This article pretty well sums up my thoughts on how Russians think and what results that stem from them.

The Best Defense Is Offense​

While the culture of war has deep roots in Russian history, “it’s a very cherry-picked history,” Carleton says. Even though the wars are cast as defensive ones in Russian telling of history, they have certainly not all been fought for defensive reasons.

“Putin has been scrambling to try and find the right story—that’s usually a sign that something’s going wrong in the war,” says Greg Carleton.
“Putin has been scrambling to try and find the right story—that’s usually a sign that something’s going wrong in the war,” says Greg Carleton.
Take an early case—the war against neighboring Kazan in 1552 led by Ivan the Terrible, who was a Russian tsar. Kazan was a Muslim state some 450 miles east of Moscow, a successor of the Mongol empire. Russia started and won the war, which set the stage for its imperial expansion all the way to the Pacific.

It was the first example of Russia’s “defensive expansionism,” says Carleton. “The thinking is like this: We’ve got a hostile neighbor—or a potentially hostile neighbor—so the best thing to do to protect ourselves is to cross our border and squash that neighbor. And then the next thing is, well, now we’ve got a new border, with a new hostile neighbor. And so we attack—ad infinitum. That’s defensive expansion.”

 
This post caught my interest and was why I responded about Russian invasions or interventions as @resemmes would rather kindly put them.
This article pretty well sums up my thoughts on how Russians think and what results that stem from them.

The Best Defense Is Offense​

While the culture of war has deep roots in Russian history, “it’s a very cherry-picked history,” Carleton says. Even though the wars are cast as defensive ones in Russian telling of history, they have certainly not all been fought for defensive reasons.

“Putin has been scrambling to try and find the right story—that’s usually a sign that something’s going wrong in the war,” says Greg Carleton.
“Putin has been scrambling to try and find the right story—that’s usually a sign that something’s going wrong in the war,” says Greg Carleton.
Take an early case—the war against neighboring Kazan in 1552 led by Ivan the Terrible, who was a Russian tsar. Kazan was a Muslim state some 450 miles east of Moscow, a successor of the Mongol empire. Russia started and won the war, which set the stage for its imperial expansion all the way to the Pacific.

It was the first example of Russia’s “defensive expansionism,” says Carleton. “The thinking is like this: We’ve got a hostile neighbor—or a potentially hostile neighbor—so the best thing to do to protect ourselves is to cross our border and squash that neighbor. And then the next thing is, well, now we’ve got a new border, with a new hostile neighbor. And so we attack—ad infinitum. That’s defensive expansion.”

I wonder how kindly you would put US "interventions" in Nicaragua. After 1552, I think to remember.
Yes, it seems that the issue is Russia, not invasion. Russia has its own Monroe Doctrine?
 
Leaving behind Russia as a singularity in time and space...

Zelenski keeps complaining about Starlink/Starshield, because he cannot demand anything. The agreement will end in mid-2027, he has to negotiate, and fund, any new agreement; with Trump.
 
Negotiating in good faith? That is like shooting yourself in the foot. Maximize your demands and then, graciously, cede...
At the same time, he is asking, or allowing, the EU at the table.
But he just keeps increasing his demands. He's not conceded anything, after four & a half years of grinding attrition in which NATO countries have been rearming, & switched away from dependence on imports from Russia. His position has weakened but he's doubled down.
 
I think "current" is the key word, as the Congress of Vienna was the current expectation then, but reality keeps changing. Hungary, Egypt and Grenada were invaded, but there was no change in their borders. That would be the difference, that Russia wants to change the border in this occasion, not that there has been an invasion.

The current conflict is clearly not of such a scale as to re-arrange the existing international order. In general we're seeing the existing system crumble but not collapse. In so far as an international order exists at all, its the post WW2 arrangement.

But he just keeps increasing his demands. He's not conceded anything, after four & a half years of grinding attrition in which NATO countries have been rearming, & switched away from dependence on imports from Russia. His position has weakened but he's doubled down.

If true, it indicates that he does not believe those factors to be particularly impactful. But in general a change of negotiating position does not mean someone is negotiating in bad faith. In fact this was clearly signaled in advance. As far back as '24 iirc, Russian official sources indicated that future negotiating positions would be harsher, not milder.
 
So he's learnt nothing. He made a huge blunder in 2022, he's kept blundering ever since, & he's still doing the same. He's made enemies out of neutrals & strengthened the resolve of those who were already opposed to him by threatening them, & he thinks the way out of that is to threaten more. Arms production in NATO countries & their friends has gone up & is going to go up a lot more, & Trump's wounded & weakened & his replacement's not going to be Putin's friend.
 
So he's learnt nothing. He made a huge blunder in 2022, he's kept blundering ever since, & he's still doing the same. He's made enemies out of neutrals & strengthened the resolve of those who were already opposed to him by threatening them, & he thinks the way out of that is to threaten more. Arms production in NATO countries & their friends has gone up & is going to go up a lot more, & Trump's wounded & weakened & his replacement's not going to be Putin's friend.

Perhaps he's heading for a strategic defeat. On the other hand support for Ukraine is declining, all the major trend lines for Ukraine itself are negative, and Russia has weathered this quite terrible war much better than I would have thought. It's not unrealistic to think that Ukraine will collapse and resolve the conundrum of ending the war. At which point a whole different set of negotiations will take place with other European nations and with the US.
 
Back
Top