Royal Australian Navy Discussions and Updates

Status
Not open for further replies.

RubiconNZ

The Wanderer
Tuvalu has a problem because their airport can't accept C17 or C130's (I think a C130 could land, empty max). Anything else is going to take a long time to shuttle any supplies. Vanuatu has a large international airport that regularly takes commercial flights, Tuvalu and Kiribati are less lucky, and have a bigger problem moving things around within nation. Kiribati because things are so spaced out.

I imagine once the patrol boat is at Tuvalu it will be tasked with shipping supplies around Tuvalu and medical runs etc.

Of course a $600 million project to replace them is up in the air at the moment too.
https://au.news.yahoo.com/a/26524611/shipbuilders-to-bid-for-new-patrol-boats/. They will be steel hulled.

Given Au and NZ new sealift assets I would have thought they would have been keen to utilize them.
C130's can land on Tuvalu.

A few years ago a RAAF C17 flew desal equipment to Samoa, and the RNZAF C130 flew it the rest of the way to Funafuti.

Funafuti International Airport has a ex WW11 runway of 1500 metres (from Wiki)
 

StingrayOZ

Super Moderator
Staff member
C130's can land on Tuvalu.

A few years ago a RAAF C17 flew desal equipment to Samoa, and the RNZAF C130 flew it the rest of the way to Funafuti.

Funafuti International Airport has a ex WW11 runway of 1500 metres (from Wiki)
You right, doing some googling brings up the RNZAF landing. My bad.
 

Raven22

The Bunker Group
Verified Defense Pro
Given Au and NZ new sealift assets I would have thought they would have been keen to utilize them.
I think you'll find they will be used, it just takes time.

Ironically, the response might be delayed by another cyclone. 3 Bde is the online brigade, so they will be providing the warm bodies for the response, however TC Nathan has taken a turn back towards the coast of North Queensland, and therefore might prevent, or at least delay, loading in Townsville. The government might not be too keen to commit everything to support Vanuatu with a likely category 3 cyclone barrelling towards cairns either.
 

Volkodav

The Bunker Group
Verified Defense Pro
Tuvalu has a problem because their airport can't accept C17 or C130's (I think a C130 could land, empty max). Anything else is going to take a long time to shuttle any supplies. Vanuatu has a large international airport that regularly takes commercial flights, Tuvalu and Kiribati are less lucky, and have a bigger problem moving things around within nation. Kiribati because things are so spaced out.

I imagine once the patrol boat is at Tuvalu it will be tasked with shipping supplies around Tuvalu and medical runs etc.

Of course a $600 million project to replace them is up in the air at the moment too.
https://au.news.yahoo.com/a/26524611/shipbuilders-to-bid-for-new-patrol-boats/. They will be steel hulled.

Given Au and NZ new sealift assets I would have thought they would have been keen to utilize them.
Steel is cheap and air is free, maybe something larger than 40m would make sense so as to incorporate a multi mission deck, perhaps even large enough to take a pair of 20' containers and of course a suitable crane to load / off load them. Just a thought.
 

ADMk2

Just a bloke
Staff member
Verified Defense Pro
Steel is cheap and air is free, maybe something larger than 40m would make sense so as to incorporate a multi mission deck, perhaps even large enough to take a pair of 20' containers and of course a suitable crane to load / off load them. Just a thought.
The problem with that statement though, is that if you give the ship more real estate, the users want to do more with it. The extra mission systems then add to the cost and on and on it goes.
 

Volkodav

The Bunker Group
Verified Defense Pro
The problem with that statement though, is that if you give the ship more real estate, the users want to do more with it. The extra mission systems then add to the cost and on and on it goes.
The current boats are a perfect example of for but not with as they have space and weight for a variety of systems they have never been fitted with, i.e. a deck gun (only some of the boats even have an MG). The boats will be built to a price and if the end user can't afford extra gear Australia definitely won't be paying for it, it's not the same as a parent navy pushing to fill empty space, these are gifts, they come as they are.
 

rjtjrt

Member
Post 14764
The aircraft need to also either be able to be refueled, or have sufficient onboard fuel for the return trip. Given where Vanuatu is, either the aircraft are able to refuel there, or are making trips fairly lightly loaded.
Noumea is not far from Port Villa (300nm), and essentially on track between Aust and Port Villa. Refuel there on way back to Australia if needed.
 

Trackmaster

Member
The Tobruk is in Townsville, loading aid for shipment to Vanuatu.
An RAF C-17 is due at Amberley tomorrow morning to begin a shuttle to Port Vila.
 
Last edited:

alexsa

Super Moderator
Staff member
Verified Defense Pro
The current boats are a perfect example of for but not with as they have space and weight for a variety of systems they have never been fitted with, i.e. a deck gun (only some of the boats even have an MG). The boats will be built to a price and if the end user can't afford extra gear Australia definitely won't be paying for it, it's not the same as a parent navy pushing to fill empty space, these are gifts, they come as they are.
The length of the vessel is limited by port facilities as well. These vessel have deicated berths in many cases as they cannot tie up the limited port facilities (in some cases they have the only port facilities). In those cases it is simply not possible to use a longer vessel as the cost of blasting or digging out the wharf space is prohibitive.

This is not the case for all potential recipients but it is for many.
 

40 deg south

Well-Known Member
LIMA 2015: Fincanteri sizes up Aussie frigate programme amid Asia expansion - News - Shephard

Italian shipbuilder Fincanteri is eyeing up the SEA 5000 Future Frigate programme in Australia that will replace the Royal Australian Navy’s (RAN’s) eight ANZAC-class frigates.

The requirement is for a military off-the-shelf anti-submarine warfare (ASW) ship and Fincanteri will put forward a modified variant of its FREMM frigate that it has built for the Italian Navy.
No surprises here.
 

Volkodav

The Bunker Group
Verified Defense Pro
Fair call but 40m is already significantly longer than 31m of the current PPBs, are the berths large enough for this or is it already planned to improve the facilities?
 

alexsa

Super Moderator
Staff member
Verified Defense Pro
Fair call but 40m is already significantly longer than 31m of the current PPBs, are the berths large enough for this or is it already planned to improve the facilities?
Just, apparently. I had heard that much over 36 would be a squeeze in some cases.
 

ASSAIL

The Bunker Group
Verified Defense Pro
While on the subject of Pacific PB's, it wasn't good to see the Vanuatu Police PB high and dry from TC Pam. Didn't look like too much damage and I hope it can be repaired locally.
 

Volkodav

The Bunker Group
Verified Defense Pro
Interview with Steve Ludlam, former Managing Director and Chief Executive of the Australian Submarine Corporation (ASC)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KbncepEJ42g&feature=share&ab_channel=SAGEIntl66

John Bruni - also tied up with RUSI SA

http://www.linkedin.com/profile/vie...thToken=7L0d&ref=NUS&trk=NUS-body-member-name

one of the good academics worth paying attention to
Very interesting, thanks for that.

One of the biggest differences under Ludlum was that ideas that had been parked for years suddenly got up and made a very real difference. There was a layer of people in ASC who where very much "that's not how we do things here" and the easiest way to get off side with them and potentially stuff your career was to push a new idea. Ludlum seemed to fix that problem and where people wouldn't change he changed the people. Ironically these resistant types who were responsible for most of the inertia were also the ones who seemed to believe the anti-ASC rhetoric in the media and parliament, I could go further in describing them but I wont.
 
While on the subject of Pacific PB's, it wasn't good to see the Vanuatu Police PB high and dry from TC Pam. Didn't look like too much damage and I hope it can be repaired locally.
If they do require local repair, Frustratingly, everyone will have to be happy with the answer, when asked 'when is going to be done?' Comes the reponse - 'Tomorrow' :)

The bigger issue will be the inter-island 'ferries'. Pretty much the lifeline getting in/ out. The island of Tanna damage assessment doesn't look good.
 

John Fedup

The Bunker Group
Very interesting, thanks for that.

One of the biggest differences under Ludlum was that ideas that had been parked for years suddenly got up and made a very real difference. There was a layer of people in ASC who where very much "that's not how we do things here" and the easiest way to get off side with them and potentially stuff your career was to push a new idea. Ludlum seemed to fix that problem and where people wouldn't change he changed the people. Ironically these resistant types who were responsible for most of the inertia were also the ones who seemed to believe the anti-ASC rhetoric in the media and parliament, I could go further in describing them but I wont.
His final comment about avoiding the "boom and bust" cycle is so right on! I think Australia is better positioned now to avoid this. Hopefully Canada's naval renewal will result in a more stable industry as well.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top