Just because we have been flying loads in the C-130 for the past 50 years does not mean it is an efficient use of Strategic Airlift. The NZDF now has a number of oversized loads (LAV, MHOV, NH90, MTOC, GCS etc) that the C-130 cannot move. C-17s provide the options for moving a greater number and variety of loads in different configurations for a number of different agencies. Where it might not have been cost effective to fly loads in the C-130 it may become so when using the C-17 thus providing greater utility to the Government, Military Allies and other countries.
C-17s have been regularly operating out of Whenuapai & Ohakea for the past 10 years with no refuling problems. As an aside the RNZAF fleet of tankers are being replaced under the LTCP project
You are right we do not "borrow" a aircraft, we "task" an aircraft from another nation to meet our requirements e.g. fly a waterplant up to the Islands for our MFAT. This is being done today by JFHQ and will be expanded on as part of the C-17 Introduction into Service
The C-130 life extension allowed the A/C to make its 2017 (stretched out to 2020) Life of Type out of service date, the benefits of the life extension are rapidly running out as we get closer to this date. If we wait much longer the C-17 option disappears and we may find ourselves stuck with the A400 which may not be the optimum platform for the NZDF.
This is what the Tactical aircraft (C295/C27J) is for, you would not send a platoon to the Solomons in either a C-17 or a A400. You would put the 50-60 soldiers into the RNZAF C-17, stop off in Townsville and pick up the 100 ADF soldiers attending the excercise and carry on to Singapore thus carrying out tasking for the ADF
Look I dont want to be seen as not hearing your concerns but anyone can come up with reasons not to do something and for every negititive around the C-17 purchase there is a positive. Yes it will mean a change to the way the NZDF/RNZAF does business but that is nothing to be worried about, it should be something to celebrate.
Im an definately not saying C130 is an efficient use of strategic resources I am just stating that in our case neither is C17 nesscessarily especially in such small numbers requireing so much outlay.
I have been hearing about AF tanker replacement for years and the excuse has always been there is no spare money, has this changed? Don't assume the LTCP is replacing every vehicle in the NZDF, army are getting new tankers as this has already been approved and more importantly funded. Any new tankers will more than likely come out of the aircraft budget as support equipment, again diminishing the total left available as aircraft tankers are not cheap.
Yes we have been refuelling C17 for years but they do not fly here with empty tanks and are just that, visiting, therefore not constantly requireing top ups which actually takes planning to support on top of daily operations. The problem would not be age and state of said tankers but more number available and volume of fuel required. RNZAF bases are not currently set up to handle such volumes routinely, they could be but again it all costs.
Yes we can task allied aircraft but that is all determined by availability, if it was such a sure thing then this talk of needing our own organic C17 would be moot. Sharing AC works fine when we are all going to the same party, as does happen now, but with our differing foreign policies this will not always be the case therefore we need to think of our own needs first and foremost, co-operation is just a bonus at the end of the day.
We have had large items of kit for decades, this is not new but seriously how often do we need to surge them quickly? I can count the number of times in my lifetime on one hand therefore is it really as big of a problem as made out to be? NZLAV only just deployed on ops for the first time in recent years and how long have we had them?
The only problem I have with sinking so much resources into 2 C17, whilst clearly amazing aircraft, is numbers available and fat left in the lard for the smaller tactical lifters which I see for us as just as if not more important for our actual day to day operations. For every positive I can also see a negative, just depends what side of the fence you are looking at it from I guess.
In the end funding, despite what some on here seem to think is finite and not going to get any bigger any time soon (would not be surprised if was sneakily trimmed TBH) so we should use it wisely for the long term good to cover most contingencies as possible efficiently and economically otherwise we could find ourselves caught out in the future.