7) I'm happy to go with whatever is cheaper though I would be astonished if the whole life costs of the F35 was less than the F18E but that should be a purely evidential question.
It's a case of how thing you can spread your fixed costs over a fleet. If you have one training, conversion, maintenance and weapons clearance path, that's one stack of fixed costs spread over the type chosen. If you have two paths, one for each type, for the same or only a little larger pool split two ways, your fixed costs double more or less.
Running sixty F35C would be likely much cheaper than thirty of one and thirty of another.
Worse, those jets are purple assets, and are needed as much to add to the RAF's striking capability as the RN's. If you go out and spend money on a stack of SuperHornet, you'd never see an F35C on deck I dare say.
Particularly not if you gut the RAF by killing a large chunk of their fleet by stripping out Tornado....
MPA - well, I think we need to be smarter about how we do that - better I think to buy in a chunk of a decent UAV with a search radar, and weapons capability, one that can fly off carriers as well as land. They could be used to fill in for some of the MPA role, some of the RAF's strike and ISTAR and also round out the FAA. You can thus have a cheap and very servicable solution to a number of gaps and shortfalls, and perhaps then look at 4-5 P8 if the economy ever gets un-bent.
Avenger (for instance) can stay up there for twenty hours - you can cover an awful lot of the surface search requirements for the MPA, they'd be brilliant in low to medium level conflicts as they're cheap to buy and to run and they'd work well on carriers I believe - particularly on anti piracy/drugs or counter terrorism where a quiet, stealthy platform with day/night capabilities and a long time on station are major plus points.
They're about a quarter of the price of a bare F18 I believe, and vastly cheaper to run.
Ian