kiwipatriot69
Active Member
good jump in capability then, thanks.
Yeah just added rant to that thread! Govt can moan all it likes about the cost but if they lose the JLP to Hobart the net loss to the Chch economy over 10 years will well & truly dwarf the cost of even a single C17.
Ok appreciate the tanker offers an alternative for a C17 but again it relies on allies (US ice breaker) & removes a valuable asset from the region for a period over summer each year - rob Peter to pay Paul!
I'd be curious to know what a round trip (incl. logistics etc) to the ice would take!?! I assume the Govt would look at 1 trip at start & end of Antarctic season.
Also looks from those discussion docs as if all 4 IPV's will go - still think there's a part for 2 to play - doing the range of tasks they currently do (training; patrol, SAR etc etc).
Actually a Svalbard class OPV might kill two birds with one stone. They are rated as an icebreaker capable of breaking up to 1m of ice. Generally in late February - early March the sea ice in McMurdo Sound breaks up for a short period which should enable a Svalbard to escort a RNZN MSC into McMurdo for off loading and reloading. Regarding cost, the ship cost the Norwegians slightly less than CAN$100 million and Canadian govt bought the design for CAN$5 million. Hence we possibly could buy the design for a similar sum and have the ship built in a Korean yard. My 2&1/2 cents worth.The NV Svalbard / Harry DeWolf Class is an ideal SOPV platform for the RNZN.
Have to say she looks quite portly though at 6000 tonnes.![]()
Actually a Svalbard class OPV might kill two birds with one stone. They are rated as an icebreaker capable of breaking up to 1m of ice. Generally in late February - early March the sea ice in McMurdo Sound breaks up for a short period which should enable a Svalbard to escort a RNZN MSC into McMurdo for off loading and reloading. Regarding cost, the ship cost the Norwegians slightly less than CAN$100 million and Canadian govt bought the design for CAN$5 million. Hence we possibly could buy the design for a similar sum and have the ship built in a Korean yard. My 2&1/2 cents worth.
The US$80m build price in 2001 was quite cheap though it did not include the radar. Which does raise a question. What are the RNZN doing with the legacy systems on the current Anzacs that are being replaced by the FSU?
We have the LOSV and the SOPV coming online in the next few years and I wonder what would be generally possible / appropriate to refurbish and cross-deck over to these vessels.
A Svalbard variant built at a Korean yard under license would be very plausible. Korea has built is own ice vessel the RV Araon in recent years and have 2 Antarctic bases as well as a Arctic research program which ironically is on Svalbard Island in Norway.
She does look a bit portly, but if we went with the Norwegian design and completely forgot about the Canadian specs, it would be quite attractive.
Canada has taken this design and stuffed it up so each ship will cost over $600+ million. Building in SK sounds like a great idea.
The costings for the Canadian build seem to be blown out of all proportion Mr C. From the article I Iinked, the design was acquired for $5 million and a contract worth $288 million was given to Irving Shipbuilding for just redesign work when Norway designed and built the Svalbard for $100 million.John.
Is that the procurement and WoL cost?
I would not be surprised if a Korean build from a licensed or OTS design happens for the LOSV and the SOPV as well as the Endeavour.
I believe more of our defence spend will be spent in the Pacific Rim for trade / defence relationship reasons.
The costings for the Canadian build seem to be blown out of all proportion Mr C. From the article I Iinked, the design was acquired for $5 million and a contract worth $288 million was given to Irving Shipbuilding for just redesign work when Norway designed and built the Svalbard for $100 million.
Canada has taken this design and stuffed it up so each ship will cost over $600+ million. Building in SK sounds like a great idea.
I'm not sure whether that cost includes sustainment? One would hope so. By way of comparison, Australia signed a contract with Navantia for 2 X AORs earlier this year for AUD 640 m plus a periodic (5 years IIRC) sustainment contract for $250m
Bringing this back to the RNZN, I would hope that the Endeavour replacement contract doesn't exceed Navantias price by the time it's signed. It would be nice to have NZ piggyback off the Oz order to provide a substantial and valuable contribution to an ANZAC TF.
Korean yards can build good ships if there is strong oversight and adherence to stringent quality standards. I would look strongly at this option.
I'm not sure whether that cost includes sustainment? One would hope so.
John.
Is that the procurement and WoL cost?![]()
Do you have any more information? I've not heard anything about Hyundai building AORs for India.NZDF has shortlisted Hyundai Heavy Industries (HHI) as 'preferred supplier' so no Navantia piggyback option available, although HHI are building 3 AOR for India IIRC and perhaps that offers a piggyback option (of sorts).
Do you have any more information? I've not heard anything about Hyundai building AORs for India.
Do you have any more information? I've not heard anything about Hyundai building AORs for India.
'Make in India': Korean major Hyundai to build warships in India | india | Hindustan Times
Hyundai Heavy Industries Nears Shipbuilding Deal
Looks like a split build - first vessel will be built in Korea with a fair number of Indian shipyard staff learning on the job, and the following vessels being built by HCL in India with supervision from Hyundai.
If it goes ahead - this is India after all!
'Make in India': Korean major Hyundai to build warships in India | india | Hindustan Times
Hyundai Heavy Industries Nears Shipbuilding Deal
Looks like a split build - first vessel will be built in Korea with a fair number of Indian shipyard staff learning on the job, and the following vessels being built by HCL in India with supervision from Hyundai.
If it goes ahead - this is India after all!