The Fast Response Cutter doesn't appear to offer much more than our existing IPV's; Damen also offered a similar design when they tendered for Project Protector.
Now would you think the Royal New Zealand Navy would ever take a version of the US Coast Guard's Fast response cutter, the Sentinel class Cutter and the US Coast Guard's National Security Cutter. Also how would the Royal New Zealand Navy be compared to the US Coast Guard.
I would have thought that the Royal New Zealand Navy would have some type of dual Navy-USCG type role. Maybe they could have a High end Multi-role frigate and Corvette & LPD type for their naval role. Their middle would have been something similar to the US Coast Guard's National security cutter and their low end a Fast response cutter type.
From memory, they have a significantly longer range, and being larger might handle high sea states better. IIRC they can also operate a pair of aircraft like helicopters and/or UAV's.
The other area which I suspect is significantly better is the sensor suite, including air/sea search radars, which I am uncertain if the OPV's have, or have to that degree. The cutter's armament is also better than that of the OPV's, having a 57 mm gun as well as a CIWS...
-Cheers
So all in all they appear fairly evenly matched, the only major difference is in armament, I'm sure the IPV could be up gunned if necessary. IMO there would be no point in replacing our fairly new IPV's with a vessel which we could have bought from Damen a few years back but chose not to.
The one thing with the National security Cutter, would be that the National Security cutter would have better sea keeping and better endurance than most frigates. As for the Sentinel-class FRC, I believe It has the Protector IPV beat by Armament, Sensor suites and speed.
The one thing with the National security Cutter, would be that the National Security cutter would have better sea keeping and better endurance than most frigates. As for the Sentinel-class FRC, I believe It has the Protector IPV beat by Armament, Sensor suites and speed.
Why would the National Security Cutter have better seakeeping? As for range I'm sure if a frigate was needed with 12,000 NM range it could be built, it's just a matter of having enough bunkerage.
As for the IPV if the govt had stumped up more cash they could have been better armed, with better sensors. I think the IPV must have a more streamlined hull, it's nearly as fast but with significantly less installed power.
This is getting silly, vessels are built for the conditions they are liable to encounter during their operating life
The one thing with the National security Cutter, would be that the National Security cutter would have better sea keeping and better endurance than most frigates. As for the Sentinel-class FRC, I believe It has the Protector IPV beat by Armament, Sensor suites and speed.
I would have thought that the Royal New Zealand Navy would have some type of dual Navy-USCG type role. Maybe they could have a High end Multi-role frigate and Corvette & LPD type for their naval role. Their middle would have been something similar to the US Coast Guard's National security cutter and their low end a Fast response cutter type.
I'll say this, Can Any frigate, OPV or cutter survive a trip to the Bearing Sea and come back to port without smelling of puke. The NSC has done a trip in the bearing sea and has survived it. Go watch an episode of Deadliest catch and see what a trip into the bearing sea is like.
You don't appear to understand the NZ context and I strongly suggest you look at some charts and maps. You also need to read back though this thread and that will give you an understanding of the RNZN, its mission and the issues it faces. NZs area of interest extends from beyond the equator on the Indian and Pacific Oceans to Antarctica. Our SLOC are in the Indian and Pacific Oceans, and to a lesser extent the Great Southern Ocean. USCG ships do not meet the mission requirement of the RNZN as set down by the NZG. The RNZN is a combat Navy, not a Coastguard.
Try the Southern Ocean on any given day where seas of 6m + are the norm and the winds whip all the way around the southern latitudes with no land to disturb them. Some learning for you. An ocean wave is generally wind generated and the height of the wave in the open ocean is determined by the energy of the wave which it gets from the wind. So the area need for the wind to generate an ocean wave is called the fetch. The greater the fetch the more energetic the wave and the larger the wave. In the higher latitudes of the Souhern Hemisphere there is no land to inhibit the wind so like I said it whips around the whole planet with it's fetch being planetary in scale.I'll say this, Can Any frigate, OPV or cutter survive a trip to the Bearing Sea and come back to port without smelling of puke. The NSC has done a trip in the bearing sea and has survived it. Go watch an episode of Deadliest catch and see what a trip into the bearing sea is like.