Safe landing.
This morning a C-130 Hercules returned to RNZAF Base Auckland after developing issues with its electrical generator while en route to Nausori. Smoke entered the cabin through the aircraft’s aircon system while the crew was attempting to isolate the problem with the faulty generator.
The aircraft, with 15 crew members on board, landed safely at Whenuapai just after 11.30am.
The C-130 can operate safely at full capacity with a faulty generator with no impact to aircraft safety. Nevertheless, it is standard procedure to turn back to the nearest suitable landing airfield following situations such as this.
Great work crew!
It's just a generator fault and they go u/s (unserviceable) every now an then, with this one being repaired if it's not written off due to fwt (fair, wear & tear). There is no need to be melodramatic about Kiwi Hercs falling out of the sky, because aviation crashes have many and varied causes, with the apparent age of the aircraft as only one possible contributing factor.Maybe this could be seen as a kick in the ass for pollies and those involved to get a move on with their replacement! before my earlier prediction comes true and they actually have a crash and casualties on their hands.
It's just a generator fault and they go u/s (unserviceable) every now an then, with this one being repaired if it's not written off due to fwt (fair, wear & tear). There is no need to be melodramatic about Kiwi Hercs falling out of the sky, because aviation crashes have many and varied causes, with the apparent age of the aircraft as only one possible contributing factor.
So now we know that the C17 is off the list.Because the production of C-17 aircraft was ending, advice was provided to Ministers on options to bring forward consideration for replacing elements of the air transport fleet. Ultimately, Ministers decided not to pursue this option at this time.
The NZG have released the documentation around the proposed C17 acquisition. The proposal put to Cabinet was for the last white tail and was submitted in April of this year. After due consideration:
So now we know that the C17 is off the list.
The NZG have released the documentation around the proposed C17 acquisition. The proposal put to Cabinet was for the last white tail and was submitted in April of this year. After due consideration:
So now we know that the C17 is off the list.
Actually it might not be quite off the list!?? Regarding "Ministers decided not to pursue this option at this time". What does "at this time" actually mean, because even the very last document titled "Draft Cabinet paper C-17 Acquisition Options (18 March 2016)" was still pursuing the acquisition of the last Whitetail. Presumably then if Cabinet rejected that proposal in April (I might have missed it - was there a doc that said Cabinet rejected it outright?), if one looks at the docs it does mention the possibilities of leasing or acquiring existing C-17's (the US is mentioned on more than one occasion, although interestingly Australia is also mentioned at one stage! NZDF wouldn't have mentioned that line without there being some sort of top level discussion between the two countries, surely? It's by the by anyway now seeing it was only mentioned once).
I read the full docs earlier but am now (due to having to be in a hurry) having trouble locating the relevant parts, but I thought it was mentioned that any decisions on the USAF releasing some of its existing C-17's wouldn't be known until 2018??
Then if we go back to last week's discussions on when other DWP docs were released, which mentioned like-for-like replacements of the C-130's and Boeing 757's, in some of the docs were charts that had something new in there which didn't seem to be picked up by discussions here at the time. (And sorry I don't have time to revisit the docs at the moment to confirm what I'm about to say - hopefully someone else can or I will tomorrow), but as well as the circa 2020 C-130/757 Strategic/Tactical airlift replacements, there was a new category called something like "Heavy Airlift" project which was circa 2018 I think.
What I'm guessing that means is, and probably from lessons learnt by NZDF/MOD (and DefMin Brownlee - hats off to him) valiantly attempting to fast-track an attempt to acquire two C-17 Whitetails ahead of the Future Air Mobile project study conclusion and ahead of the planned retirement dates of the C-130/757's in the 2020's ... as revealed by the release of these latest C-17 docs ... it was probably hard work trying to convince Cabinet and importantly Treasury (ref the last C-17 doc in the list) due to the need to make variations in the current airlift fleet (in order to cut operational costs) so that funds could be diverted to acquire C-17(s) ahead of time. As per that last C-17 doc Treasury seemed unconvinced.
So the optimist in me thinks that although the C-17 acquisition has been set back for now, the inclusion of the new "heavy airlift" category around 2018 for the DCP... could possibly line up with a potential lease from existing US stocks (that's IF the USAF does actually retire some). If this is the case then like I mentioned above, kudos to NZDF/MoD and the DefMin for forcing this change and perhaps this is why the MoD website statement says "Ministers decided not to pursue this option at this time"?
If this is the case then the info released last week makes better sense, which is, and to simplify the airlift project funding case perhaps ... like-for-like C-130/757 replacements and potentially 2x additional "heavy-lift" aka C-17 acquisitions (and if the C-17 falls through, then it's onto A400M and even the Kawasaki YCX gets a mention in these latest C-17 docs).
If this happens this could be a better outcome for the NZDF because not only would they retain current airlift numbers (5+2), they may potentially acquire 2 additional heavy lift aircraft!
Now if one reads the C-17 docs in comparison, originally to fast track the C-17 Whitetail purchases come 2016 etc, the NZDF, due to having to fit in with existing budgets (and savings made from deferring the new naval capabilities), the RNZAF would either have had to give up 1x or both 757's and/or 1x C-130. A reduced airlift fleet is never a good idea (especially in this day and age of medium-high tempos) as that reduces NZ's ability to sustain operations and deal with concurrent or additional unexpected demands etc.
I disagree with your assessment regarding C17s. There are too many unknown variables dependant upon any possible acquisition now of any C17s, be they lease or whatever. There has been no indication whatsoever that the US would consider parting with the aircraft and the term that the NZG use is "Ministers decided not to pursue this option at this time", knowing full well that C17 production is already history. Come US Presidential Inauguration Day next January, it will be a different ball game and if HRC wins, she plays hard ball. She is not her husband and is definitely not the incumbent. If DJT wins then all bets are off because who knows what way US defence and foreign policy will go. Hence I believe that given the available evidence, C17s in Kiwi colours are no longer viable.Actually it might not be quite off the list!?? Regarding "Ministers decided not to pursue this option at this time". What does "at this time" actually mean, because even the very last document titled "Draft Cabinet paper C-17 Acquisition Options (18 March 2016)" was still pursuing the acquisition of the last Whitetail. Presumably then if Cabinet rejected that proposal in April (I might have missed it - was there a doc that said Cabinet rejected it outright?), if one looks at the docs it does mention the possibilities of leasing or acquiring existing C-17's (the US is mentioned on more than one occasion, although interestingly Australia is also mentioned at one stage! NZDF wouldn't have mentioned that line without there being some sort of top level discussion between the two countries, surely? It's by the by anyway now seeing it was only mentioned once).
I read the full docs earlier but am now (due to having to be in a hurry) having trouble locating the relevant parts, but I thought it was mentioned that any decisions on the USAF releasing some of its existing C-17's wouldn't be known until 2018??
Then if we go back to last week's discussions on when other DWP docs were released, which mentioned like-for-like replacements of the C-130's and Boeing 757's, in some of the docs were charts that had something new in there which didn't seem to be picked up by discussions here at the time. (And sorry I don't have time to revisit the docs at the moment to confirm what I'm about to say - hopefully someone else can or I will tomorrow), but as well as the circa 2020 C-130/757 Strategic/Tactical airlift replacements, there was a new category called something like "Heavy Airlift" project which was circa 2018 I think.
What I'm guessing that means is, and probably from lessons learnt by NZDF/MOD (and DefMin Brownlee - hats off to him) valiantly attempting to fast-track an attempt to acquire two C-17 Whitetails ahead of the Future Air Mobile project study conclusion and ahead of the planned retirement dates of the C-130/757's in the 2020's ... as revealed by the release of these latest C-17 docs ... it was probably hard work trying to convince Cabinet and importantly Treasury (ref the last C-17 doc in the list) due to the need to make variations in the current airlift fleet (in order to cut operational costs) so that funds could be diverted to acquire C-17(s) ahead of time. As per that last C-17 doc Treasury seemed unconvinced.
So the optimist in me thinks that although the C-17 acquisition has been set back for now, the inclusion of the new "heavy airlift" category around 2018 for the DCP... could possibly line up with a potential lease from existing US stocks (that's IF the USAF does actually retire some). If this is the case then like I mentioned above, kudos to NZDF/MoD and the DefMin for forcing this change and perhaps this is why the MoD website statement says "Ministers decided not to pursue this option at this time"?
If this is the case then the info released last week makes better sense, which is, and to simplify the airlift project funding case perhaps ... like-for-like C-130/757 replacements and potentially 2x additional "heavy-lift" aka C-17 acquisitions (and if the C-17 falls through, then it's onto A400M and even the Kawasaki YCX gets a mention in these latest C-17 docs).
If this happens this could be a better outcome for the NZDF because not only would they retain current airlift numbers (5+2), they may potentially acquire 2 additional heavy lift aircraft!
Now if one reads the C-17 docs in comparison, originally to fast track the C-17 Whitetail purchases come 2016 etc, the NZDF, due to having to fit in with existing budgets (and savings made from deferring the new naval capabilities), the RNZAF would either have had to give up 1x or both 757's and/or 1x C-130. A reduced airlift fleet is never a good idea (especially in this day and age of medium-high tempos) as that reduces NZ's ability to sustain operations and deal with concurrent or additional unexpected demands etc.
C-5s that are not being upgraded to C-5Ms were simply worn out to the point that made upgrading unfeasible. IIRC, NZ needs a lifter that can land in Antarctica which I don't think has been done and there are likely many destinations that lack the runway length needed for the C-5.
C-5s that are not being upgraded to C-5Ms were simply worn out to the point that made upgrading unfeasible. IIRC, NZ needs a lifter that can land in Antarctica which I don't think has been done and there are likely many destinations that lack the runway length needed for the C-5.
Any A models converted to Ms or was it just the Bs? Forty hours of maintenance for one hour of flight time is horrendous, almost as bad as the RCAF's fifty year old SeaKings.
the running costs for a galaxy as opposed to the c17's would be horrendous, they'd kill your sustainment budgets