kiwipatriot69
Active Member
Three yrs before Hercs start being retired isnt much of a time frame to work with Ngati, when are we expecting an RFI to be done for airlift replacement?
The RFI for both the FAMC and FASC were out last year and both are now closed. So now the MOD and NZDF will be digesting and analysing the responses before sending a submission to the Minister and Cabinet requesting permission to issue a RFT for the C130 replacement.Three yrs before Hercs start being retired isnt much of a time frame to work with Ngati, when are we expecting an RFI to be done for airlift replacement?
To cut an already small fleet of airlift from 5 tactical and two Strategic further, surely that would set a dangerous precedent, even with the added capability, where we at times would have no planes available for an emergency? After all, look at all the HADR missions we diid just last year,not counting disaster relief in our own country, and exersizes abroad. I would actually like a few extra NH90 if it could be managed within the budget too, for that reason.
RegR and kiwipatriot69,
I can see both sides of the coin/argument from both of you.
Yes far more capable, modern, airframes can give you both greater capability and availability (possibly equal or greater), but yes of course the total number (minimum number) is also an issue too, obviously there has to be a 'balance' between both ends.
A couple of examples with the RAAF's procurement/operation of the C-17A Fleet.
Originally four (4) procured, and I do remember reports at the time that suggested that the Oz Government said if the RAAF wanted more airframes it could (all pre GFC days when there was plenty of 'cash' floating around!), true or not, I don't know?
Anyway, couple of interesting moments in the history of C-17A in RAAF service (well I think so anyway!).
When the RAAF responded to the Japanese Tsunami, at one stage three of the four airframes were based in Japan, and the fourth (from what I've read) was back in Oz, but in maintenance, which basically meant that if there was a local need (emergency?), one of those three in Japan would have had to come home, maybe that got 'the powers that be' thinking about increasing the fleet size, who knows?
The next event was when the 'first' of the four was coming due to return to Boeing for a six month 'heavy' maintenance period, basically this would have meant that the RAAF would have been down to 'three' airframes in Oz for approx. two years (eg 1 airframe away for 6mths at a time, 4 x 6mths equals two years).
And if I remember correctly, new airframe No 5 arrived in Oz just prior to airframe No 1 headed off to the US for its heavy maintenance period and that solved that problem.
And subsequently the RAAF also saw the arrival of Nos 6, 7 and 8, all good!!
My point?
What ever airframe the NZG eventually chooses, I would think that its not just how much more capable that airframe is over the one being replaced, but both numbers and also schedule heavy maintenance periods (as per the C-17A six month heavy maintenance period).
Anyway, just my opinion of course!!!
Cheers
Ngati, How long can it take from an RFI to a tender being made regarding the hercules, seeing you have stated the RFI part was done last year, are we talking several months, or a year or so usually?
Is what currently is set aside for the Hercules replacement set in stone, or would govt be willing to adapt to currency fluctuations and other cost increases,to ensure we have the right numbers?
kiwipatriot69 said:Is what currently is set aside for the Hercules replacement set in stone, or would govt be willing to adapt to currency fluctuations and other cost increases,to ensure we have the right numbers?
all tender evaluations take into account currency fluctuations. I assume NZ Treasury like everyone else has an algorithm they refer to to make the whole of life calculations
in addition, NZ like Oz factors in contingency which can be up to half the total final through life costs
Surely, if the contract calculation is a real thing, the contingency should be taken up to a variable degree on average 50% of contracts, and given back to a variable degree in the other 50% of contracts.
Is that what happens in real life?
Or are contracts prices nearly always deliberately underestimated to get the item in train, then the "contingency" used up.
Unlike Indonesia we will not be looking at manufacturing the aircraft locally. Part of the Indonesian deal with Airbus includes a technology transfer that will possibly see 3 of 5 aircraft assembled by PT Dirgantara Indonesia in Bandung following the first two assembled in Seville with more locally built if ordered.
If one is looking for guidelines around how much it will cost NZ - the UK 'package' is informative.
The UK package would need to be viewed with caution, as they have been part of the financing consortium and I therefore would assume that the package would not include any development recovery costs, which could apply to non consortium customers.
Yes but Britain succeeded from the EU with BREXIT, would those rules still apply?
They were applicable at the time of the contracting and are applicable at the moment. The UK has not yet left the EU, although it is in the process thereof, hence EU rules and regulations still apply until the BREXIT Agreement between the EU and the UK enters into force. Such an agreement has yet to be negotiated. The UK package figures should be used as a guide, not as something carved in stone, because the NZG will negotiate its own deal. However the UK package data are, like the French figures, quantative data with a high degree of reliability.Yes but Britain succeeded from the EU with BREXIT, would those rules still apply?
What? And defy EU transactional accounting rules for inter-governmental contracts. I would assume they would do no such thing.
As the consortium members have already paid their portion of the development costs this would not be included in the individual aircraft contracts as such, as contracted with Airbus. The individual governments would, in all probability have these costs in the overall package costs of the aircraft in their individual defence budgets. As a normal business practice the consortium and Airbus would try to recover some of these cost from overseas sales and this has been publicly stated several times.
Totally agree that there is no slight of hand and individual governments will be accounting for the development cost in their various budgets as per normal accounting practices, but this money was spent many years ago and would have been in the budgets for those years. The current expenditure is for the manufacture of the aircraft by Airbus. You are right that the total program costs will reflect the total per aircraft cost.And those development costs have been transferred over to the final costed price - irrespective of the purchaser there is no slight of hand and the costed figures are very accurate because transactional accounting rules are followed. That is why consortium nations got antsy when they had to increase their investor dispersions into the project - it increased their ticket prices. Those costs are not recovered by pinging foreign buyers - in fact foreign buyers are welcome in that they reduce production costs. There are clear transactional demarcations with respect to financial transactions whether one is wearing an investor hat, a supplier hat or a buyer hat, even tough the principal entity may have a finger directly or indirectly in each of those phases. It is there to stop financial corruption and be transparent.
Totally agree that there is no slight of hand and individual governments will be accounting for the development cost in their various budgets as per normal accounting practices, but this money was spent many years ago and would have been in the budgets for those years. The current expenditure is for the manufacture of the aircraft by Airbus. You are right that the total program costs will reflect the total per aircraft cost.