There seems to be a convenient loss of collective memory regarding sub design. Why do we forget that a 216 does not exist and that the Japanese already have a number of evolved 4,000 tonne subs? Why should the RAN once again be the risk taker with a new hull? Do the Germans or French have some magic capacity that eluded the Swedes?
I haven't seen any data to suggest which is the most appropriate and I have no preference but I do know that whatever boat we buy, system integration will be a challenge when we predetermine that a AN/BYG1 CMS is mandatory?
At least option J begins with a proven hull.
Many have brought up the false (IMHO) view that Japanese tech transfer is something new, not the case, Japanese manufacturers have been building overseas for decades including full tech transfer.
What we have mandated is a submarine that once again will be an orphan and therefore a risk in both cost and time and whichever sub is chosen will have 2/3 of the project cost spent in Adelaide over their lives.
The CEP is well understood by both the Europeans and the US so its not a demon process that some make it out to be. My view is that we should let the process run and have faith in it, Abbott is not stupid enough to wear the Kim Beazley mantle (re Collins) and although he might have blundered in gushing about Soryu early on, he seems to have stepped back and allowed the experts to properly evaluate the options. By appointing Kevin Andrews to defence, he has given the job to one of his most experienced, careful and most respected (within the APS) men, one who is not going to blunder in the same way that his predecessor did.
Finally, we are wedded to the US for the boats CMS and weapons therefor US influence is going to play a major role in which option is chosen but I also believe that the geopolitical reality of China will also influence the decision.
There's a lot to ponder.
Chris, probably the most reasonable, balanced and fair comment I've seen for a while regarding the Collins replacement, a great post!!
With some of the comments and posts lately I was starting to think that the 'secret deal / Captain's pick' was all signed, sealed and done and that our Japanese friends were already cutting and shaping steel for the very first of the Soryu(A) class boats,
HMAS Rising Sun!!!
It just seems to me that everyone is trying to read between the lines and interpret things that may or may not be there (mostly not there!), or are adding two and two together and coming up with five! Just way too early to assume what the final outcome will be.
I agree with your comments regarding the PM, yes he did appear to get all very excited about the prospect of Soryu in RAN service (with what appeared to be no competition being run), but it does appear that things have calmed down since then.
And I also agree with you about Def Min Andrews, yes he is a bit of a dull and boring pollie on the surface (in my opinion), but he's been around for a long long time and I get the impression that he has a pretty firm handle on what he does and won't let himself get into a position were stupid decisions (and comments) will jump up and bite him on the bum, too experienced a politician for that to happen.
And talking of the Def Min, this transcript of an interview that he did with ABC (just prior to the Japan trip) is a pretty good read (in my opinion):
Defence Ministers » Minister for Defence – Interview with ABC – Visit to Japan
As you can see he makes it very clear that there is ‘no’ MOTS solution and that ‘all’ contenders will need to modify their boats, here are a couple of the relevant quotes from the transcript:
Well, first of all, there’s no such thing as an ‘off-the-shelf’ model of submarine, and in each case there are modifications and changes that would need to be made.
The Japanese submarine is about the size that we are looking for in Australia, but obviously it requires changes. What we want is a submarine which has the endurance of the Collins; that has superior stealth capacity to the Collins, and; is one which is going to be interoperable in terms of the weapons system with the US.
Now, that’s going to require design changes and modifications in the case of whichever submarine we buy from, which ever country, and so it’s important that each of the countries, Japan included, understand that.
And this quote too:
Well as I said, each of these submarines will need modifications. It is true, the French submarine, the Barracuda, is a bit bigger that what we are looking at and is a nuclear powered submarine so it would require modification to a conventional power source.
The German submarine is not a big as what we are looking for and would need to be up-scaled for Australia. But there is no off-the-shelf submarine that perfectly fits our needs. Each of these countries are going to have to modify it and I’ve detected so far a number of claim and counter-claim about each other’s product so far and I’m sure we will hear more of that in the next few months.
Like you Chris, I agree, lets all sit back and wait and see what the outcome of the CEP is, rather than trying to read the tea leaves and trying to join the dots, especially when it comes to some of the comments being made in the media and by ‘so called’ experts too.
Cheers,