One must remember that as GF has stated numerous times asset do not work in isolation they are force multipliers, the carrier has a decisive part to play in the Air-Sea Battle. The Air-Sea Battle concept is about the ability of the Air Force and Navy to perform highly integrated operations that will enhance their effectiveness across a range of contingencies, flying a few F35B off the LHD does not meet that challenge unlike a platform which is set up to meet that challenge.
But the cost to convert some of a F-35A purchase to a F-35B purchase is relatively little. If the last squad was a mix of 14 F-35B/14 F-35A the price difference would be perhaps a $100-$200 million. The F-35B can perform nearly identically to a F-35A in all other roles, so if they can operate in any useful way off the LHD then for $100-$200m you have gained useful capability. Throw in $50m to make improvements for operating LHD's with F-35B and you have a fairly low cost project with low risk and high common logistics that may give Australia useful capability and enhance our F-35A, AWD and LHD capability augmenting, multiplying and complimenting it.
You would be able to train Army, Navy and Air force with F-35B's, so that we can integrate more closely with allied forces. The F-35 is such a game changer in terms of situational awareness, ISR, CAS, low observables, EW etc that we will need to spend considerable time with Army and Navy to embed and make use of those new capabilities. Our pilots would become better/more diversely trained, with more opportunity to work with US, UK etc forces and greater relevance for the air force for international missions.
Acquiring a completely new ship (and or new ship type) would add a huge cost (Billion plus, for CATOBAR multi billions), huge risk etc. Thats not on the table at this stage.
Acquiring F-35B would impact on LHD use and upgrades, fleet oilers purchase, RAAF training facilities and upgrades, RAAF logistics etc. It would be good if we looked into this now to ensure suitable funds/equipment etc are made available.
It might come back and say the F-35 in no way can operate off the LHD's, or huge sum of money would need to be spent to make it compatible. Or operations so compromised its not worth pursuing.