Does anyone know why the Giuseppe Garibaldi design was eliminated from the RAN carrier replacement program? It made it to the final three before being dropped leaving only the SCS and Modified LPH options before the Invincible offer. I would have thought it was a pretty good match for the RAN requirement.
I would have thought that if Australia did consider a carrier, it would be about 40'000 tonnes in size. Maybe something like the Italian or French carriers.
The Navy would probably need an extra 1,000 personnel but the forces have demonstrated a capability to recruit to meet high demand the past 10 years (retention is a different problem). And carriers are cool and much easier to recruit for than refugee taxis or submarines. Frankly once the LHDs start sailing around most people will think we have carriers anyway.
I would have thought that if Australia did consider a carrier, it would be about 40'000 tonnes in size. Maybe something like the Italian or French carriers.
:dance:dance:dance
Perhaps if the US was to make considerable cuts to its carrier force.
3rd LHD seems more in the realm of possibility than a completely sensible approach to a carrier as there isn't any political will to get one..
Perhaps if the US was to make considerable cuts to its carrier force.
A full milspec ship like this with the LHD combat system, self-defence weapons (ESSM, Phalanx), built in Australia wouldn’t cost more than $3 billion.
In the unlikely event this would happen it wouldn't help the RAN much. USN carriers are far too big for the RAN to operate short of a national mobilisation. A small CVL requires about one quarter or less of the resources needed to operate an American sized carrier.
If for instance we did get the green light for a CV and choose to use the exiting Super Hornets then buy F35C at a later date, would the French carrier CDG be the minimum size required. As I recall the recovery of E2D Hawkeyes were marginal at best and F35C being heavier than Super Hornets and the catapults being shorter than a USN CV could they operate from her or would we need something along the proposed CATOBAR UK CVF to future proof ourselves.
In the unlikely event this would happen it wouldn't help the RAN much. USN carriers are far too big for the RAN to operate short of a national mobilisation. A small CVL requires about one quarter or less of the resources needed to operate an American sized carrier.
I dare say the point being made was that if the US reduced their carrier fleet, Australia would be less able to rely on US naval dominance to provide for our security, and therefore that Australia would seek to improve our own capabilities by building a carrier. Not that Australia would buy and operate a US CVN.
So of all the aircraft capable ships currently in service or soon to be in service, what's left, if of course one became available on the cheap?
I dare say the point being made was that if the US reduced their carrier fleet, Australia would be less able to rely on US naval dominance to provide for our security, and therefore that Australia would seek to improve our own capabilities by building a carrier. Not that Australia would buy and operate a US CVN.
Here is just some food for thought. Now I got this info from the World Bank website and its for 2013.
Italy who has the Cavour class carrier (which seems to be the a good fit for Australia) has the worlds 9th largest economy coming in with a GDP of approx US$2 trillion and has a population of around 65mil.
Australia comes in 12th at just over US$1.5 trillion and a pop. of 23mil.
Now this is the one i found interesting, India (who has aspirations of having 3 carriers) comes in at 10th with a GDP of only US$1.8 trillion. YES i know they have a pop. of 1.2 billion and they probably pay their sailors peanuts compared to Aussie sailors, but surely we can afford an aircraft carrier (maybe if we get it built in India lol).
.THE Rudd government has shuffled around hundreds of millions of dollars of defence spending so that it can chop the defence budget by $1 billion in 2016-17 to meet its surplus target.
The economic statement says defence spending is to be increased by $359 million in 2013-14 and $304m in 2014-15.
However, spending is to be cut by $89m in 2015-16 and $1bn in 2016-17. Spending jumps again by $426m in 2017-18. That amount is beyond the forward estimates and goes into the six-year period of "funding guidance" under a system introduced with the May budget to provide more certainty, especially for the defence industry.
The overall effect is that Defence gains $1.089bn in funding across several years and loses the same amount, most of it in the 2016-17 financial year.
Defence Minister Stephen Smith said the overall changes were modest. "We wanted to make a contribution to the surplus in the financial year 2016-17 so . . . we've moved $1bn out of that financial year, $600m of that goes into forward years. In other words it goes into the financial year 2013-14 and 2014-15
It's things like this that makes me worry more about what we are going to loose or can't afford to obtain and far less about if we will ever see a Carrier in service.
I have done some more reading and it struck me that Italy was producing pretty much what Australia needed at the time it was needed. The Garibaldi class carrier, Maestrale class frigate, Durand de la Penne class destroyer, San Giorgio class amphib in addition to the Lerici class MCMVs we actually did get. Each of these would have filled a RAN need, had a level of commonality with some of the existing systems and could have been built locally with updated systems, i.e. Mk41 VLS.