weegee
Active Member
LHD01 is progressing rather well, so far.
Just a quick question. Why does Canberra run with L02 and Adelaide L01 when Canberra is the lead ship and bearer of the class name?
LHD01 is progressing rather well, so far.
Just a quick question. Why does Canberra run with L02 and Adelaide L01 when Canberra is the lead ship and bearer of the class name?
Because the pennant number 01 (Adelaide) and 02 (Canberra) are the same as the previous (FFG) ships bearing their names.
Same as the AWD Hobart and Brisbane will have the same pennant numbers as the previous DDG ships of the same names.
Ahh that makes a lot of sense. When is Adelaide set for sea trials? I suppose it will be lateish 2015?
Can anyone confirm or deny the rumours that NUship Canberra had issues with her propulsion system during sea trials?hwell
[*]An expanded version of CEAFAR would likely deliver similar or superior performance to SPY-1D on the AWDs
[*]Which in turn raises the question of why the government of the day didn't opt for the Flight IIA Arleigh Burke, or G&C international Frigate as the RAN wanted or the Type 45/SPY3/AEGIS combo suggested by industry when they were already planning what they knew would be superior to the F-100[/LIST]
I should have specified the AUSPAR and other advanced projects that were already under way when the AWD design decision was made instead of referring to an expanded CEAFAR. I believe the capability provided by AEGIS and SPY-1D(v) was needed just that it was poorly executed, the reason to go for a cheaper platform was to get more hulls but in the end we didn't.
Happy to be corrected but as I understand it there is no public knowledge of CEAFAR or AUSPAR being about to compete with a SPY-1D. AUSPAR is always reported as a classified program with the US developing prototypes. All I've read is that a higher power version is being positioned for Future Frigate, not what the power is or what it could compare to.
There's zero public knowledge but there is a hell of a lot of inside info running around about how its competitive and in some areas - superior
and thats by people directly involved
I'm a big fan of CEAFAR the technology is truly world beating but let's not get ahead of ourselves.
Realistically AUSPAR wasn't/isnt ready, and CEAFAR wasn't really operational when the AWD decision was occurring (AFAIK). Proving it on a destroyer platform is something that is yet to happen. For risk alone it made sense not to go down that road (IMO).
I really see them as two different systems, for two different ships. At some point in the future that may change (with time and money). Despite any technical superiorities any and each has. The AWD project is late enough as it is, I don't think anyone wanted to add more risk, cost, complication etc. Its one of the main advantages of the F-100 design over the G&C design.
Interesting about Canberra. There may be minor teething issues, it isn't a navy ship yet, its only just gotten wet. I would be surprised if they had a design or operational issue, as its pretty much a carbon copy powertrain wise isn't it? Fairly known quantity.