The idea of a mixed hi/lo approach is fine, but i'd definitely oppose any DDG-1000's. Hell of an expensive ship even for the most powerful navy on earth.
I like the Izumos, I like them alot. It's a design concept i'm rather fond of. Should it count as part of an ANZAC replacement? Not in my book. As much as they like to be called 'destroyers', they are and always will be closer to capital ships in my book rather than escorts, capital ships that require escorts.
Some might disagree with that, but that's my opinion on it.
Potential for savings and reinvestment in the future 12 SSK plan, what's everyones thoughts on that? Going from 6 to 12 seems like one hell of a jump, would something closer to 8 and the spare going into the surface fleet be better? If the boats are larger, more fuel efficient and have a better reliability rate, is 12 the best number?
I don't really know, so that's why all the Q's
IMO, and it is just my opinion, 12 results in an imbalance. 8 is a reasonable number noting we rely on SLOC and need a reasonable escort force not jsut for capital ships. To this end I would love to see 4 AWD.
I am willing to see the ANZAC II cut to 6 significantly more capable ships if this was supplimented by a light frigate (OPV) with greater capabiltiy to provide a lower tier escort with reasonable ASW capability, a self defence capability (ESSM in an 8 cell Mk41 perhaps), limited ASuW (2 to 4 Harppon) and a mid range gun (76mm as and example).
If I have my day dreaming goggles on then 6 (maybe 8) of these would provide a great capability for patrol and supplimentry escort. You could even carry over systems from the ANZAC to lower risk. The 80 to 90m OPV designs from the 90's certainly had a lot fo this capability and extending the desigh by a couple of metres to add range and growth margin and using modern control systems to reduce crew size these would be a capable tier of escort. They wouel also provide additional ship building work if built in batches of 4.
If we were really brign the same hull and propulsion package coudl be used for a fitted for but not with pure patrol vessel to suppliment the fully armed batch.
But this is a fantasy, so while I am at why not add a Cavour to the mix. That would give the RAN:
1 x VSTOL carrier
2 x LHD with limited VSTOL support
4 x AWD
6 x 7000t ANZAC II (built in batches of 3)
8 x Collins replacement (built in batches of 4 and updated between batches)
4 (8) x Light Frigate (built in batches of 4 and updated between batches)
and if we are really dreaming 4 x OPV version
and of course
2(3) x AOR/MARS (whatever is selected)
Hmm.......................... seems reasonable but highly unlikely. However, building in batches allows the build rate to be spread out and avoids fitting obselete equipment to a ship at the end of a long production run. Building a different type of ship between each batch allows redesign (not massive) to take account of operational experiance. Ideally this process would continue and the designs would effectively evolve with lessons being learnt on all platforms feeding into the next batch of ships (whatever they are) where it is applicable.
Way too sensible if you ask me.