So what vessel that is out there is close to Aussie requirements.
That is just the point - apart from the evolved Collins class, or a new design from ASC et al, there isn't one.
MB
that's what I thought I was wondering if our gov got a sniff of the current issues with the s80 and that helped make the decision against OTS designs as we had been burnt before also.
On another note is there a reason we don't operate tomahawks from our subs? I know we operate harpoons. Firstly could they even operate from a Collins class?
Secondly does the RAN require land attack capability from our subs? Or from the surface fleet for that matter?
Thanks
1. Tomahawks would impact too greatly on the available weapons storage space.
2. At present, no. I believe (though I'm happy to be corrected) that Harpoon Block II does not come in encapsulated form and therefore we operate only legacy Block 1C Harpoon from the Collins.
3. RAN has a land attack capability from it's surface ships at present. 76mm guns, 127mm guns have obvious land attack capability and the Harpoon Block II missile can all strike fixed and relocatable land targets, as seen in the video below:
Harpoon Block II Missile - YouTube
In future Government is planning on acquiring a "strategic" land attack capability to be carried by the RAN's surface and sub-surface fleets. Most expect that to be based on Tactical Tomahawk missiles, but perhaps other systems might be available by then.
Block II Harpoons are sub launch capable...no idea whether or not the RAN has the appropriate fire control system or rounds though.
However, the Harpoon Block II's land attack is seriously limited compared to even a Block III TLAM. Also can't do moving targets in a practical sense.
RAN introduced Block II in the early - mid 2000's. It has now successfully conducted live fire launches against open ocean targets, littoral ship targets and land targets.
Against fixed or relocatable (but static) targets, the Harpoon Block II is as capable a weapon as the SLAM-ER (albeit with less range). The antenna and GPS/INS guidance package from JDAM and SLAM-ER has been added to it, so whatever they can accurately target, so can Harpoon Block II.
Lacking the IIR seeker and 2 way data-link of that weapon, it obviously isn't as capable against moving targets, but regardless of that fact, with the Advanced Harpoon Weapons Control Station (which RAN acquired) and the necessary targetting data, the Harpoon Block II provides a capable land attack missile system.
Here's what the Royal Australian Navy thinks of that point, anyway.
Harpoon Block II firing a first for Navy capability | Royal Australian Navy
That's all very familiar, but none of that is relevant to the point that the Harpoon Block II is a significantly less capable land attack missile than a Block III TLAM, particularly in range.
And again, neither is of any practical use against a moving target. Even though Tactical Tomahawk (Block IV) theoretically is, even that is of somewhat limited utility.
I don't recall any suggestion that the Harpoon II was intended for use against moving targets or that it was more capable than Tomahawk CM's.
RAN has practiced and validated the weapon's utility against land based targets, which was the sole point I made in response to Weegee's question about whether RAN maintains a land attack weapons capability.
I suspect that the issue over the Collins and whether it can fire Harpoon Block II is a matter of national sensitivity. I suspect that some of our Northern neighbours would get very upset (publicly) if we admitted we operated a submarine launched land attack capability.
I think the political view is to admit that our submarines are capable of engaging shipping with a range of weapons and glossing over the precise capability of the submarines...
Hence why there has been VERY little discussion over whether or not Harpoon Bock II has been added to Collins and all RAN literature that I've seen has only ever mentioned Harpoon Block 1C...
Ok thanks for the info guys, on another note has anyone heard how HMAS Choules is going since she has entered into service again?
Today I found information on the Tenix 56m SAR patrol boat that was offered as a Fremantle class patrol boat replacement, but missed out to the Armidlale class
I understand they were to be based on the San Juan SAR boats built by Tenix for the Phillipines coast guard.
links
San Juan-class patrol boat - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
what it looks like
http://ruelbaby.blogspot.com.au/2012/07/p15b-to-modernize-philippines-coast.html
according to 'ever reliable' wikipedia these boats can do 26 knots top speed, and sustain 12 knots in seastate 4. Not sure how that compares to the Armidale class? top speed may be similar, but the slimmer hull of the Armidales might be able to be pushed faster in a sea state
Boat is optimised for SAR, thus top speed is less than a Fast Attack Craft. My 'ideal' Armidale class replacement would be very much like these 56m tenix vessels, however a bit narrower, a bit longer and with some more power, this should result in greater speeds. Downside would be less internal volume (though still heaps more than Armidale class) as a narrower hull can support less topweight. So at a rough guess reducing beam from 10.5m to say around 9.7m would mean the top most deck would have to be cut down, and the superstructure reduced in size. Trade off would be higher speed at cost of reduced internal volume. A FAC of similar displacement would tend to have a beam of around 9m to 9.3m (obviously can go faster - upside, but internal volume and topweight that can be carried is much less -downside)
some specs
560t
56m x 10.5m x 2.5m
approx 11,000hp
can handle 300 evacuees for a short while
can land a 4.7t helicopter (bell 429 class or heavier)
a mix of these vessels, plus some 2000t hulls that could also be used for an OPV and MCM work and hydrographic survey makes sense to me.
For those in the know, obvioulsy this information is old hat, for the rest of us, it may be of some use.
With 14 Armidales doing the offshore work and 8 Bays doing the near shore work we still have massive holes in our EEZ.
I'd much rather see the Armidale replacement and then on top another six 2000 ton OCV vessels to act as mother ships in peace time and in war time as in combat corvettes.
Your supposition is too simplistic. Firstly, the primary detection capability within the EEZ is provided by air assets. Surface assets react. Secondly you have sold short the efforts of the MCU.
Customs do a great deal of "offshore" work.
The ACPB's are unsuitable for sustained offshore border protection duties.
They are too small, they have no aviation capability and have no reserve accommodation to handle refugees. Any wartime contribution would be minimal.
Your proposal for 6 or 7 OPV's for BP is in line with SEA 1180 but would need to be boosted to about 12 to keep the requisite number on task.
[/I]
Air assets are useless unless you can act on their tracks. So even if we cover the sky with drones we'll need need enough intercept vessels to do the actual work.
Sounds a little contradictory here. First you say the Bays do a great deal of offshore work, then the Armidales (of course larger vessels) are not suitable for sustained offshore work. Which is it? The Bays are a bit of a pig when the sea gets up.
Not what I'm suggesting. I'm suggesting 12 PBs for non warlike operations