I've been to Afghanistan and have spoken with the BM drivers who were Abrams crew commanders and all would agree that Afghansitan is great tank country but all knew that Australia simply doesn't have the supply chain to be able support them. That's mostly due to the fact that we don't have any armoured fuel trucks short of a battle mog.
Refuelling a helo and refuelling a fuel guzzling tank is what kept major tank deployments out of Afghanistan.
What rot. The reason the Abrams never went to Afghanistan is because there was never a need for it. Or, at least a need that was worth the opportunity and political cost. Resupply of fuel was never a warstopper. Uparmoured TTFs would have been fine in resupplying the Abrams in theatre (it was how everything else was resupplied). You'd have to build a few more to do it, but that would only take a few months (they are essentially built to order).
Afghanistan is actually pretty terrible tank country. They are useful down in Kandahar and Helmand where it is flat (and, perhaps not coincidentally, where the US, Canadian and Danish tanks were), but from Uruzgan on up not so much. They might be useful for knocking down some dudes quala in the green zone, but we weren't doing that. For everything else an ASLAV was good enough.
Settle down mate. It was you who needed to bring up "reading them at work" as if other people here arent in similar roles.
That was exactly my point. You aren't the only one that has access to things that aren't in the public domain.
You claim about what have subs done for us is immediately counted by your own argument of another battalion. What exactly would another battalion have done for national security?
My use of another brigade (not battalion) was only an example of an unfulfilled requirement. However, I'll answer your question. Another Brigade over the last ten years would have given the Army the ability to conduct all the governments requirements. There have been times over the last ten+ years where the government has asked the Army to do things that they haven't been able to do because there was simply not enough soldiers to do it. That is bad. That is entirely what the ADF is for - providing options for government.
Now, would an extra brigade be helpful in a naval war with China? Not so much. But equally, how useful have the Collins been over the last decade of deployments abroad? Also, not so much. The ADF must be balanced, and simply advocating 12 subs no matter what because some dude wrote a capability requirement for it isn't particularly helpful.
What I meant was that is not as if Defence publishes any strategy especially sub strategy online and that a Defence think tank who's written dozens of papers about it would be a good start for people unfamiliar. Papers written by professional analysts in consultation with Navy and Governemnts and unclassified for release.
So, someone in the navy has written a requirement stating that 12 subs is good therefore it must come to pass? I could find literally hundreds of papers from within defence and outside stating the absolute need for all sorts of capabilities. Double the fast jet fleet? An extra LHD or AWD? More P8s and KC-30s? More helicopters for the Army? More tanks? Take your pick.
I don't disagree that subs are useful. I don't disagree that we should be buying new ones. I don't even necessarily disagree that we should be buying 12 of them. What I do disagree with is the notion that discussion about whether we should be buying 12 of them is not on because there is a 'requirement' for 12 of them. Which was my original point.