The Hobart class is definitely getting them though, not just 'capable' of it?
I assume it'd be in the Defence White Paper?
read the white paper quote I posted recently, it is definately in there
The Hobart class is definitely getting them though, not just 'capable' of it?
I assume it'd be in the Defence White Paper?
On the need to replace the armidale class boats in the Australian Navy.
According to some the ideas is to use 'large ' ships in the 1500 to 2500 tonnes range. In my opinion this is not wise.
Firstly I recognise there is a need to have larger ships for longer range tasks, for fighting enemy ships etc. I guess you would call these corvettes. The issue is that a corvette is going to cost much much more to buy, to man and to operate that a patrol boat.
If the Armidale class is a fraction too small, then how about a replacement class of about 10 boats on 400 to 450 tonnes. This extra 100 to 150 tonnes would allow for a longer hullform with more speed, with more volume for fuel. Idea would be to keep weapons and payload much the same.
Just maybe it could have a small flight deck for handling helicopters (not a hanger or onboard helicopter) just the ability to land a small helo, and refuel it. See the Esmerelda class in Ecquador, they have a 600 tonne ship with SSM, SAM and a helo.
A bigger (longer) Armidale class would be cost effective, more comfortable, easier to maintain (less weapon systems) than a corvette. There are missions that a corvette is better at doing. But there are also many missions that a cheap, small craft is better at doing. Things like Port Security, defending oil platforms and gas rigs (having a presence) dealing with illegal fishing vessels, dealing with asylum seekers, going to aid of vessels in distress, interception of drug smugglers and just maybe small terrorist/pirate vessels (unlikely but not impossible )
A patrol boat would be much cheaper because first it is smaller, needs less fuel, needs less crew, does not require sophisticated systems. A patrol boat does not need torpedoes, 3D radar, sonar, SSM, a big gun, etc etc. Would anyone care to contrast the cost of the 250 tonne Armidale class boat with a 1500 tonne corvette. What is the cost ratio 1:4 , 1:7 or is it 1:10 . It would be interesting to know
Take a guess at 8:1 then 12 patrol boats or the cost of 1.5 corvettes. You could do a lot of good work with 12 patrol boats, much of it would be boring, low tech stuff, but still important and still worth doing.
On the need to replace the armidale class boats in the Australian Navy.
According to some the ideas is to use 'large ' ships in the 1500 to 2500 tonnes range. In my opinion this is not wise.
Firstly I recognise there is a need to have larger ships for longer range tasks, for fighting enemy ships etc. I guess you would call these corvettes. The issue is that a corvette is going to cost much much more to buy, to man and to operate that a patrol boat.
If the Armidale class is a fraction too small, then how about a replacement class of about 10 boats on 400 to 450 tonnes. This extra 100 to 150 tonnes would allow for a longer hullform with more speed, with more volume for fuel. Idea would be to keep weapons and payload much the same.
Just maybe it could have a small flight deck for handling helicopters (not a hanger or onboard helicopter) just the ability to land a small helo, and refuel it. See the Esmerelda class in Ecquador, they have a 600 tonne ship with SSM, SAM and a helo.
A bigger (longer) Armidale class would be cost effective, more comfortable, easier to maintain (less weapon systems) than a corvette. There are missions that a corvette is better at doing. But there are also many missions that a cheap, small craft is better at doing. Things like Port Security, defending oil platforms and gas rigs (having a presence) dealing with illegal fishing vessels, dealing with asylum seekers, going to aid of vessels in distress, interception of drug smugglers and just maybe small terrorist/pirate vessels (unlikely but not impossible )
A patrol boat would be much cheaper because first it is smaller, needs less fuel, needs less crew, does not require sophisticated systems. A patrol boat does not need torpedoes, 3D radar, sonar, SSM, a big gun, etc etc. Would anyone care to contrast the cost of the 250 tonne Armidale class boat with a 1500 tonne corvette. What is the cost ratio 1:4 , 1:7 or is it 1:10 . It would be interesting to know
Take a guess at 8:1 then 12 patrol boats or the cost of 1.5 corvettes. You could do a lot of good work with 12 patrol boats, much of it would be boring, low tech stuff, but still important and still worth doing.
With New Zealand's Project Protector, their OPVs ran twice and a half the cost of the IPVs each.
OPV NZ$89,718 million
IPV NZ$35,784 million
I don't know about ship hulls, but I know that aluminium bike frames are more than half the weight of steel. Lighter, yes, but not half the weight. A given thickness of aluminium is less strong than the same thickness of steel.
Ah! Same applies to aluminium hulls. This page explains far better than I can. You do get a weight saving, but not 50%.
Looking at the schedule of major RAN projects
- Future Submarine has an initial design concept in FY2009-10 to FY2010-11
- Maritime combat Helicopter (24 new Anti-Submarine Warfare/Anti-Surface Warfare Helicopters): First Pass Approval FY 2009-10 to FY 2010-11
- OPV scheduled First Pass Approval FY 2012-13 to FY 2014-15
- LCH scheduled First Pass Approval: FY 2012-13 to FY 2014-15
- Maritime Operational Support Capability.(Success replacement) 2016+
- Strategic Sealift: 2019+
- Future Frigate 2019+
I guess the desicions to expect in the near future are the intial concept design for the future submarine and the maritime warfare helicopter.
Any thoughts on the likely options for these?
Scope
This phase is intended to provide an organic combat aviation capability to Navy’s surface combatant fleet. This includes the acquisition of multi-role naval combat helicopters, weapons, synthetic training, infrastructure, logistics and other support systems.
Background
The Navy’s current tactical helicopter capability is provided by the Seahawk S-70B-2. A surface warfare strike capability was to have been provided by the cancelled Seasprite program. The White Paper indicated that as a matter of urgency the Government would acquire at least 24 new naval combat helicopters. The new aircraft will possess advanced anti-submarine warfare capabilities along with an ability to fire air-to surface missiles.
Australian Industry Opportunities
Acquisition
In order to minimise technical, schedule, and financial risks it is envisaged that a Military-off-the-Shelf (MOTS) solution will be sourced from overseas. There may be some opportunity for Australian industry in aircraft assembly, and development of some support systems.
Through-life Support
The retention of an off-the-shelf configuration is considered important for cost effective Australian based deeper level maintenance, engineering and through-life support.
That is a very comprehensive comment, there is a lot of very interesting information there
what are the main weapons and sensor capabilities of the MH-60R and the NFH?
how do the surface strike capabilities of these systems compare?
what are these systems likely to cost? The DCP has budgeted Very High> $1500m
It will be several years before these are in service
- First Pass Approval FY 2009-10 to FY 2010-11
- Year-of-Decision FY 2010-11 to FY 2011-12
- Initial Operating Capability 2014 to 2016
the background information from the 2009 defence capability plan
That is a very comprehensive comment, there is a lot of very interesting information there
what are the main weapons and sensor capabilities of the MH-60R and the NFH?
how do the surface strike capabilities of these systems compare?
what are these systems likely to cost? The DCP has budgeted Very High> $1500m
It will be several years before these are in service
- First Pass Approval FY 2009-10 to FY 2010-11
- Year-of-Decision FY 2010-11 to FY 2011-12
- Initial Operating Capability 2014 to 2016
the background information from the 2009 defence capability plan
What is aircraft?
UAV's? Given the enviroment in 10 years time I think it may be a wise decision to have something that can shoot down some sort of survellience drone or some hostile/annoying little UAV which could be inserted into the battlespace from the water. I don't think its intended to engage high threat level fixed/rotary winged craft (attack helicopters and fighter planes).
We could always do with more capability.
Here's a link that provides some more info.
Rational to rationalise? Australia's future naval combat helicopters revisited by Andrew Davies
Australian Strategic Policy Institute
A good read in that some not so obvious points are examined.
rb