I don’t think anyone has posted this as yet. Interesting view. The case for building an evolved Collins Class submarine
They will be getting a UAV capability which can be operated out of ISO Containers Under Sea 129 phase 5 and this will be a major improvement over the Fremantle's and Cape's, it will greatly improve the Search capabilityI think the point above is that a chopper is at hand and onboard when required. If the chopper has to Lilly pad from another vessel, assuming it is within range it doesn’t really help in an emergency situation. The idea of having a chopper on board has merit and really does broaden the patrol capability and range.
They will be getting a UAV capability which can be operated out of ISO Containers Under Sea 129 phase 5 and this will be a major improvement over the Fremantle's and Cape's, it will greatly improve the Search capability
I think the point above is that a chopper is at hand and onboard when required. If the chopper has to Lilly pad from another vessel, assuming it is within range it doesn’t really help in an emergency situation. The idea of having a chopper on board has merit and really does broaden the patrol capability and range.
There were a couple of Hams as well, used as diving tenders and torpedo recovery vessels. I got my self lectured over the tons at one point, told off by and ex PO when I commented on the being our last wooden ships, I was told very firmly that I was talking out my backside as they were steel!Consider yourself slapped!
(“Ducky” = Duchess, nickname she was known by. As opposed to the fluffy duck, always in full, Swan)
You could make an argument about the Tons I suppose but they are hardly MSC
I think the point above is that a chopper is at hand and onboard when required. If the chopper has to Lilly pad from another vessel, assuming it is within range it doesn’t really help in an emergency situation. The idea of having a chopper on board has merit and really does broaden the patrol capability and range.
And that is why I deliberately said "will greatly improve the search capability" nothing about rescuing. Would a 3500t Cutter with a specialised SAR Helicopter make a far better platform for Search and Rescue, yes. But in the areas the Arafura's will be operating the need is just not there in enough quantity to justify that degree of expense, especially compared to the USCG.A UAS could certainly increase the sensor footprint, SA and search area for a vessel it is embarked on. However, I am unaware of any UAS which could be relied upon to carry out a variety of SAR taskings apart from the Search portions. Just as an example of what I mean, consider some of the missions that USCG MH-65 Dolphin helicopters engage in. Granted, these particular helicopters are typically stationed at, and deploy from land-based USCG Air Stations, they do also sometimes deploy from USCG Cutters.
I think something similar was posted from ASPI earlier. New Collins would be a huge new undertaking, but we are already committed to LOTE collins, so its about expanding that. The most pessimistic assessment seems to indicate 1 SSN by 2040. If that is the case, it may be something the Gov needs to look at. But then you have questions about build volume to make it viable, really its at least 3. This would perhaps mean that 3 of Collins do not go LOTE which would likely increase the availability a little bit before they go away. We have to do the LOTE no matter what, we have to life extend and evolve Collins to keep it relevant.I don’t think anyone has posted this as yet. Interesting view. The case for building an evolved Collins Class submarine
Is there an argument that to address some of the shortfalls in fleet numbers extra Poseidon aircraft could be considered e.g. a much shorter timeline for procurement able to be at specific areas of contention quicker, no disruption to present shipbuilding schedules,
Not sure I follow your logic here, given how military training courses are run (well trained instructors and compressed training time frames). Having done several ADF instructor training courses myself and then done APS training there's big differences in training quality. Remember that with military courses you have (literally) a captive audience who are motivated to be there (quite often the training is linked to pay & promotion qualifications) and there are consequences (pay/career) if you fail.


The first LOTE sub will last until 2038. Assuming that there are no more life extensions the rest of the Collins Class will be gone by the late 40s. I don't necessarily see that as a problem if we can obtain second hand nukes to cover the gap between the Collins and introduction of whatever replaces them. I have a feeling that their might also be a few more second hand nukes available by the late 30s.I think something similar was posted from ASPI earlier. New Collins would be a huge new undertaking, but we are already committed to LOTE collins, so its about expanding that. The most pessimistic assessment seems to indicate 1 SSN by 2040. If that is the case, it may be something the Gov needs to look at. But then you have questions about build volume to make it viable, really its at least 3. This would perhaps mean that 3 of Collins do not go LOTE which would likely increase the availability a little bit before they go away. We have to do the LOTE no matter what, we have to life extend and evolve Collins to keep it relevant.
This might be advantageous as then you can slip into next gen SSN subs from the get go and not run a mixed SSN fleet and a mixed SSK/SSN fleet. It gets sub building up and running before going nuclear.
The configuration and size of Collins is still good in concept for a SSK. But its still a ssk.
The Sub program is in a huge state of flux.
P8 aint replacing ships, but do provide a large fast sensor and weapons platform. IMO its a better platform to put heavy missile on than a OPV. I believe there is a possibility of 1 more P8 being ordered. Given the current make up of the RAN we will be heavily reliant on this platform to cover the RAN, where ever they go. But then how survivable is a P8 unescorted?
From what Dutton said a couple of weeks ago we will probably get an announcement on the Subs mid year*, we just need to be patient and wait and see what comes out then. From what Dutton said the plan is to have the first SSN in service well before 2040, what that will be ?????The first LOTE sub will last until 2038. Assuming that there are no more life extensions the rest of the Collins Class will be gone by the late 40s. I don't necessarily see that as a problem if we can obtain second hand nukes to cover the gap between the Collins and introduction of whatever replaces them. I have a feeling that their might also be a few more second hand nukes available by the late 30s.
HMS Astute could be available by then. It is planned for a 25 service life which means it could be available from 2035 which could still give us a decade or so of useful life. Part of me still thinks we will probably end up with a modified version of the Astute so that boat might be a good lead in.
Assuming the US ramps up its submarine production rate there could be a few later build LAs available by that time. In other words I do see options for Australia getting into Nuclear submarines by the mid 30s even if our own nuclear boats aren't ready till the 2040s.
If the Collins LOTE mirrors Sweden's efforts then we can expect to the the fabrication of entire new sections for the existing fleet. If we are fabricating entirely new sections for six boats then how hard is it to fabricate another two to four sections? Depending on the weights of the new systems there may be a need to fabricate new sections simple to provide enough ballast and trim tanks to maintain stability. This means more new sections and the question of how much of the old sub is actually being retained.
I find the concept of building two Joint Support Ships will provide a good balance to the RAN fleet. As they will have some amphibious capability and replenishment capability, they will be effective as a Choules replacement & additional replenishment capability in lieu of building a third AOR. The onboard hospital capability is also very desirable, not only during conflicts but also during disaster relief operation. I would imagine that the RAN would base one on each coast.
It aligns with what Volkodav said in a post on the other thread in May 2017:
”We are some time off the decision on the third AOR/ second LPD, let alone a replacement for Choules but I agree it would make sense to investigate building / acquiring two similar if not identical ships at the time. If a local build is viable they could lead to eventual replacements for the LHDs and AORs being locally built too. I know the LCH replacement has dropped off the radar but if a larger, more flexible design, with a well dock, was selected for that need it could permit the selection of an innovative design to supplement the AORs and replace Choules, for example an LPD with replenishment facilities, or a logistics ship with amphibious support capabilities.(T-AKE, ESD, ESB).”
The Navantia Australia proposal appears to be very capable.
HMS Astute could be available by then. It is planned for a 25 service life which means it could be available from 2035 which could still give us a decade or so of useful life. Part of me still thinks we will probably end up with a modified version of the Astute so that boat might be a good lead in.
Assuming the US ramps up its submarine production rate there could be a few later build LAs available by that time. In other words I do see options for Australia getting into Nuclear submarines by the mid 30s even if our own nuclear boats aren't ready till the 2040s.
If the Collins LOTE mirrors Sweden's efforts then we can expect to the the fabrication of entire new sections for the existing fleet. If we are fabricating entirely new sections for six boats then how hard is it to fabricate another two to four sections? Depending on the weights of the new systems there may be a need to fabricate new sections simple to provide enough ballast and trim tanks to maintain stability. This means more new sections and the question of how much of the old sub is actually being retained.
Not necessarily because the JSS could be sailing as part of a task force. But in an ideal world such ships should have ESSM BLK II, NSM, a good sensor setup so that they have adequate self defence against air and surface threats. That's a problem with phat ships, they've got nothing to protect themselves from modern threats.It'll be interesting to see when we will finally hear more on this front as the WA Shipbuilding factsheet has it down to commence in ~2026 ...
You'd imagine replacing Choules with two(?) JSS would necessitate an escort fleet increase in itself?
But, I guess that same logic should've already applied to the Canberra Class.
The first LOTE sub will last until 2038. Assuming that there are no more life extensions the rest of the Collins Class will be gone by the late 40s. I don't necessarily see that as a problem if we can obtain second hand nukes to cover the gap between the Collins and introduction of whatever replaces them. I have a feeling that their might also be a few more second hand nukes available by the late 30s.
HMS Astute could be available by then. It is planned for a 25 service life which means it could be available from 2035 which could still give us a decade or so of useful life. Part of me still thinks we will probably end up with a modified version of the Astute so that boat might be a good lead in.
Assuming the US ramps up its submarine production rate there could be a few later build LAs available by that time. In other words I do see options for Australia getting into Nuclear submarines by the mid 30s even if our own nuclear boats aren't ready till the 2040s.
OK ... why and what does getting the HMS Astute achieve? If the Virginia is selected (I have my doubts) what is the point. If the Astute is selected with the US reactor ... and (noting the governments worst case outcome) this operational before 2040 ..... why pick up an old boat.The first LOTE sub will last until 2038. Assuming that there are no more life extensions the rest of the Collins Class will be gone by the late 40s. I don't necessarily see that as a problem if we can obtain second hand nukes to cover the gap between the Collins and introduction of whatever replaces them. I have a feeling that their might also be a few more second hand nukes available by the late 30s.
HMS Astute could be available by then. It is planned for a 25 service life which means it could be available from 2035 which could still give us a decade or so of useful life. Part of me still thinks we will probably end up with a modified version of the Astute so that boat might be a good lead in.
Assuming the US ramps up its submarine production rate there could be a few later build LAs available by that time. In other words I do see options for Australia getting into Nuclear submarines by the mid 30s even if our own nuclear boats aren't ready till the 2040s.