Somewhat puzzled by this Austral takeover thing!
Four company's ( Nations ) are in contention for a very lucrative deal worth billions to do a mixed build overseas and locally in Australia at Austral.
Austal is up for a takeover by one of the overseas contenders and the government says I'm not getting involved!
Does this not look problematic on many levels.
Perplexed S
Hanwa recognise that if they own the yard, then they are in the box seat for the ship design and they can lock the other GPF tenders out. They are having a crack at trying to achieve that. Good on them, that's smart business, maybe they will be successful. I would do the same if I were in their shoes. Fortune favours the bold..
I haven't seen anything from the other three GPF providers stating an interest in purchasing Austal, so this is a unique offering from Hanwa and one of their differentiators. The others will eventually present their proposals for synergies and will have some different ways of demonstrating this.
I should note here that the other competitors to purchase Austal are all American private equity funds. Hanwa is the only ship builder that has a hat in the ring.
While the government have said that they have no concerns with Hanwa purchasing the yard, there have been some other media releases indicating that FIRB authorisation (necessary for any foreign bid) will be unlikely before the ship platform has been selected. So I think this will move forward on the go slow.
If the S Korean design is selected for the GPF then it makes a lot of sense for them to also own the yard. I think the Americans are comfortable with both the S Koreans and Japanese to be more involved with the USN program, so unlikely to be significant concern from them.
If the S Korean design is not chosen, then I suspect Hanwa will move on and look for another opportunity. Perhaps buy one of the other American yards currently for sale.
The government is saying they are not getting involved with the Austal sale process. Neither should they as it is a private business, not a public organisation. There is no difference to this than there would be to BHP or Rio Tinto. Privately they have right of veto through FIRB and via the Americans with their similar right of veto. They will do this when the time is right and they don't need to make a decision now.
I would be startled if the four GPF bidders are not all in communications of some form with the government or defence in the lead up to a tender being released. They are all hungry and want the work, and will be looking for any opportunity to give themselves a competitive edge, perhaps even steer/influence the tender to a scope that is favourable to them. There will be a lot of pushing and shoving and positioning going on.
The government will need to maintain an unbias position during the tender, hence their public position. Sometimes this comes off as being aloof. We all remember the debacle with the original conventional submarine tender where the government clearly had a favourite.
I am sure all have all stood up an internal bid team to prepare their offer well in advance of the GPF tender being released. They will all know we are sensitive to having American weapon systems, have a desire to integrate Seafar and 9LV, want more missiles, and will have researched our local rules. And they will all be seeing what they can do without basterdising the base design, increasing the price or delaying production too much. The yard that can do this juggling act the best will likely be the winner.
I don't think that the government has washed their hands or are not being involved, just it is behind the scenes and key decisions will wait until the appropriate time to make.