dragonfire
New Member
Really? Please explain.
My post was supplementing Dzirhan's post pl refer to it
Really? Please explain.
My post was supplementing Dzirhan's post pl refer to it
This is wht most ppl dont get, it is easy for ppl to just say/comment on things without realising the geo-political/political situation on the ground. Am sure modern air forces operate on stated doctrines and the fighters play a huge role in this, but the need of the hour situations and the best possible options with strategic outlook play a big role in the final decions made
What am trying to say is simpleI know.
Sorry, I understand Dzirhan's post but not yours. It's not a challenge, rather, it a request for a clarification on your supplemental point.![]()
What am trying to say is simple .............
Why cant Malaysia get Israeli's to do the same for them too- sounds like a political reason than a millitary one - right ?
it's a religious issue - which is far more complex than a political issue
I understand the issue Malaysia being a predominantly muslim country, point here being the decision is not a purely milltary one right
it's not a military decision. matahir and all those since have stayed with no israeli trade (a hollow threat anyway) as they link it to the issue of palestine.
it's a religious decision
Religious and political actually, Israel is the only country Malaysia does not recognize in any event so no ties or cooperation is possible. Back in the 80's it was actually proposed by the RMAF that the A-4 Skyhawk refurbishment be done through a third party which would actually get it done by Israel but it was deemed a no go.
What am trying to say is simple...
As far as a need is concerned any Air Force the size of RMAF (or any AF for tht matter) would prefer the same platform for a particular role and not employ different platforms. However we dont live in a simple world we live in a very complex world.
...why cant India buy J-10 from China - it looks like a capable craft and the pricing also looks good enough - no chance - political reason - if a military decision was to be made then they would look only at need vs capability and price they wouldnt see political logic - but tht's not how things work - not simple - very complex - right
In case of RMAF like Dzirhan stated, they saw wht happened to the Indonesians when they got embargoed, they wanted to prevent tht as a possible reality, even in India which does not have any US origin fighters there are a lot of people, politicians, authors, journalists, ex-defense pros, analysts who argue tht any purchase of fighters from the US is a major risk for future as it could get embargoed, sanctioned etc etc which could possibly render such a US origin fleet rendered useless or of lesser utility.
Again I would go back to India's case - when the MMRCA competition was announced the Super Hornet was not one of the contendors only when the civil nuclear deal got through did the US field this fighter - tht's bilateral relationship and its effect on millitary sale. While talking about options India outright has ordered (althoug in multiple contracts) the SU-30MKI in much larger numbers than the MMRCA order, there were no competitions, no global tender, RFIs etc, It had a need - to counter the PAF F-16 threat and it had the resources and a willing supplier of a competent craft which the liked - result outright order.
gf0012-aust and Dzirhan, thanks for both your posts, I really enjoyed reading them.![]()
As I mentioned before, logistics is always the basic test of military competence. A component of modern air forces / armies measurement of their ability to fight is the degree of coherence of their logistics system. Only fanboys and 3rd world military leaders will not be concerned about logistics.
I believe the above data supports my argument that the coherence a logistics system is an important handmaiden to the modern war fighter.