Re: Lightest Combat Aircraft!
adsH said:
that is ridiculous Fiber cables may be good and cost effective on ground based comm systems where speed of transmission is critical. but an AC having Fiber G wires is ridiculous the Adapters would be costly the Modulation demodulation technology would be required for every Fiber, would be costly and potentially heavy.
Wrong. Infact anyone here...most likely Shamayel will tell you as he is one guy I know of, who works in the lab with Fiber Optics modulation-demod technology, that Fiber demod-mod equipment is much lighter then analog medium. I am not sure why the fighters will use Optics, unless there is a technology to disrupt the internal electrical communication of an airplane. Also the modulation-demodulation of optics is darn cheap when you compare it to the cost of an aircraft. I will not be surprised if there are already some european cars manufactured with optics for control instead of battery. Overall it is all digital medium which is far more light in weight, cost even though is higher then analog but still has come down heavily. Besides very stable against interference.
adsH said:
the entire AC would have to rebuilt to incorporate such a fragile technology. On the pluss side it would have enhanced protection and resistance to EM impulse waves. and improved Data transmission. But the Fiber wire tech is too costly and requires too much maintenance. the only People that can truly produce high quality Fiber wire that are good enough for military Use would be Germans. who currently have a monopoly in the medical fiber optics.
There is not much difference in Optics used in military or other normal telecommunication Industry. There is already one very big Industrialist house (can not remember the name, I think it is Reliance/Alembic but I maybe wrong) in India manufacturing various type of multimode/single mode fiber optic cables and they are exporting them to Asia Pacific Market including Singapore. In US also, some of the MSO have imported Optics from India due to cheaper rates. As far as the leaders are concerned that is Corning, when it comes to Optics. Optics can be made according to the general specification of the customer and there is no magic in that. Germans have monoply in medical equipment and since equipment is made in germany, it is pretty obvious that they will use german optics due to the local market. Fiber cost is not as much as people may think. It costs only 70 cents for a foot of optical cable....and if purchased in bulk the price will be far much cheaper.
adsH said:
i would imagine Fiber OPtic wiring is vulnerable to the Unknown factors so Original Metal wiring would be required for Backups, which means the Ac would have significant weight added to it.
Optic wiring is less prone to even unknown factors provided it is insulated correctly. If it is, then it is far much more reliable then anything. I am sure the aircraft manufacturer would already have thought about the implications posed by optics and would have taken great measures to ensure the reliability.
adsH said:
you would need sonic shielding the insulators would have to researched. the fiber could shatter on sound barriers.
Shatter on sound barriers??? If it is shielded well enough it is very reliable. Far much more then a shielded electrical cable. There are plenty of insulators already out there in open market for anyone to buy.
adsH said:
the fiber optic cables are hard to repair if there is an insulation break, which occurs at a higher frequency in non-static bodies. the angle of turns ie twisting of the wire while they are placing the fiber cables are limited the Light only bends within the wire at certain angles.
adSH, It is very cheap to join the optics in todays modern world. You can buy a Fiber Joining machine for as low as 300 USD in the market which will do the job just as perfect as you can get to. It requires so much of less human interference. it aligns the fiber itself and all one needs to do is to insert two ends in. It use to be a nightmare before to join fiber but technology is moving ahead way to fast and prices are on earth now. They obviously need to take care how much they can bend the fiber, but if correct openings are designed to place fiber in...it is goingto be far much more easily manageable then electrical wires. You can do only one job with one metal cable, but if muxing of different wavelengths is implemented in that particular piece of optics, you are running only one optical cable to do various jobs.. Imagine how much lighter it would be in absence of all that jungle of metal wiring to and forth?
Frankly, working with Fiber Optics practically for last 5-6 years, I have known this that Optics can stand far much more torture then copper/aluminium wires, only if they are insulated in the way, they should be. I have come to rely 100 times more on optics and am crazily happy about the way, they can be managed in such a little space.