- Thread Starter Thread Starter
- #141
In 48 the entire region in general and the Levant in particular was in disarray , in 67 there were Arab nationalism that was behind the joint effort and as you mentioned in 73 there were different reasons to open the front against Israel. What seems today that Turkey, Egypt and few other countries in the region are in better shape since the inception of Israeli State?The only time all these countries can be said to have marched simultaneously was in 1948 and even then they didn't coordinate their actions well and had troops that were ill trained for the task - even more so than the Israeli's. In 1973, Jordan sent a token contingent to the Golan as a sign of solidarity but King Hussein informed the Israeli's first so they would understand why he did it and so they wouldn't badly maul the Jordanian contingent. King Hussein is even reported to have warned Golda Meir that a war was imminent. Morocco planned to send a dozen F-5s to Syria but the pilots were arrested for being part of a coup plot. The biggest joke [if that's the right word] is that Syria and Egypt both went to war in 1973 for completely different reasons and didn't even bother to tell each other! And the reason they went to war was not to overrun Israel, they knew it was beyond the ability of their armies, that the Americans would come into the picture and that the Soviets would object.
Every country there is a political reality and the whole world knows that also! Domino effects are indeed taking place but will not result in the Arabs uniting under a Caliph and all agreeing to march on to Israel, this is an outragous suggestion that does not fit in with hard facts and prsent realities.
No offence but you might as well tell me that leftists worldwide are waiting for another Che again and that Italians are waiting for another Duce .... The only people who are waiting for a Caliph [or in your words a Saladin] to lead a future Caliphate stretching from the shores of North Africa to the Gulf of Oman are people like OBL [now deceased off course] and other dreamers, their view is not shared by the majority of Arabs and this was so clearly proven by the Arab Spring, which made AQ and groups like it irrelevant.
If and when the day comes when Arabs take to the streets in their hundreds of thousands demanding that their leaders severe ties with the West, unite all Arab countries into a single political entity with no borders, expel all foreign [read Western] military presence from Arab lands and declare a jihad, then I might start agreeing with you.
And Egypt is not a ''significant'' state? Last I checked, the thousands of people who rallied at Tahir Square did not even mention Israel.... By your logic they would have been demonstrating because Mubarak had closed the Gaza crossing and was being too compliant with U.S wishes not to offend and press Israel, but they didn't did they?
Turkish/Arab relations in the 1980's and 1990's didn't go as far as the Turks would have wished due to the traditional distrust the Arabs have with the Turks, due to the Ottoman history. The Turks also do not have any land that is occupied by Israel. Egypt signed Camp David [didn't bother to inform its so called Arab partners before doing so] and became beholden to U.S. economic support, and Mubarak's main focus after coming into power was regime survival. Jordan's main fear post-1967 was that Israel would drive the Palestinians onto Jordanian territory [the Israeli's did threaten this] - this would have endagered the very existance of the Hashimite kingdom, thus King Hussein had to play both sides and play nice with Israel, whom he also looked to for protection against Assad the elder.
Well he would say that wouldn't he? What he won't say is that Israel courted Hamas as an alternative to Fatah and he won't say that the Palestnians voted for Hamas as they were totally fed up with the corrupt Fatah. We've gone full circle here, Fatah was a ''terrorist'' group, then it became a ''partner'' for peace when it engaged in talks, then it became a an ''obstacle'' to peace after the talks failed and then became a ''partner'' again when it again agreed to talks but was then ditched by the Palestinians - and now the ''West'' and Israel would prefer that the Palestnians vote for Fatah again....
First of all, Israel is a nuclear power, secondly its enjoys the unconditional support of the world's sole superpower, thirdly the Arabs have better things to do and their own pressing problems to address. Like I mentioned before, contrary to what you believe, the average Arab does not go to bed every night dreaming of destroying Israel.
Indeed I do disagree and yes my assessment us totally contrary to yours.
Egypt is one of most significant state in the entire region of MENA. We must also remember how hundreds of demonstrators entered in the Israeli embassy in Cairo and how Egyptian army deployed to save the lives of Israeli diplomats in women’s clothes.
We should not get mystified with what people are chanting today on Tahrir Square. All the surveys done after regime change shows that predominant majority are in favour annulment of Camp David accord. Morsi and MB are waiting for right time to approve/instigate the anti Israeli sentiments. There first job is to bring their own house in order and as I said before it would take a decade or so to finally maneuver against Israel openlyThat’s why I requested you to goggle the Charter of HAMAS, after so many deaths and destruction people prefer HAMAS over FATAH.
As I mentioned above, all these developments what we see are transitional and it may last for a decade or even more and we should keep in mind that no settlement will make Israel dearer to Arabs/Moslems of greater Middle East. Yes, Israel is a nuclear power so as Pakistan the closest and confidant strategic partner of KSA and Turkey. Yes, Israel enjoys unconditional support of sole Super power of today but it is not guaranteed that US will remain (sole) super power in the decade to come. Finally Arabs and Muslims of today have better things to do same as Arabs and Muslim had better things to do during the period of Nuradin till Saladin. The average and elite Arab/Moslem from Morsi to Erdogan may not dream to destroy the Israel but certainly they do dream to recapture the Jerusalem and bring it back to Islamic fold.
What I tried to articulate in our previous discussion that the so called Arab spring is only the beginning of long drawn strife in the region and I have covered the Shiet/Sunnite sectarian angle too. I am of the same view of “ Zebgivni Brzezinski” as he said after the fall of Mobarak that “he does not see the life of Israel more than 10 to 15 years more”.
This is an assessment based on past, present and expected alteration in the geopolitics of the region. I am of the belief that the geographical boundaries of the region will be reshaped especially in the Levant and Iraq and Israel will be submerged in the erstwhile Levant with Jordan, Lebanon and Palestine.